What is the Correct Equation for Finding the Centroid of a Circle?

  • Level: Graduate 
  • Thread starter 6Stang7
  • Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Calculus
2 replies · 4K views · last reply
6Stang7
Messages
212
Reaction score
0
I'm trying to determine the centroid of the shape below:
What is the Correct Equation for Finding the Centroid of a Circle?


The curve line is that of a circle, but the equation of for a circle, (x-a)2+(y-b)2=r2, won't work here for obvious reasons, but the equation y=r-[tex]\sqrt{2rx-x^{2}}[/tex] does.

To determine the location of the centroid, the formula is:

Centroid formula: x-bar equals the integral over A of x dA divided by the integral over A of dA, equated to the integral from 0 to r of x(r - sqrt(2rx - x^2)) dx divided by the integral from 0 to r of (r - sqrt(2rx - x^2)) dx.

Centroid formula: ybar equals the integral from A of y dA divided by the integral from A of dA, rewritten as the integral from 0 to r of y(r - sqrt(2ry - y^2)) dy over the integral from 0 to r of (r - sqrt(2ry - y^2)) dy.


To ensure that the equations that I am using are correct, I am going to compare the area calculated by integrating the line with respect to it's corresponding axis against this equation:
Equation A = ((2r)^2 - pi r^2) / 4, written as a formula for an area involving a radius r.

Let's assume that we have a circle with a radius r=1. The area is therefore:

Equation A = ((2(1))^2 - pi(1)^2) / 4 ≅ 0.2146, a closed-form area expression written as typeset mathematics.

Now, I solved the integral two ways: one with Mathcad, and the other with The Integrator.

When I solve it with Mathcad, I get:

What is the Correct Equation for Finding the Centroid of a Circle?


which is wrong because the area calculated is negative. When I solve it with The Integrator, I get:

Handwritten-style integral of 1 minus the square root of (2x minus x squared) dx, with a worked antiderivative result below it involving square roots and a logarithm.


which is also wrong because if this equation where evaluated, you would obtain a number with imaginary components.

I type this equation into my TI-84 and had it calculate the area under the curve and it got an answer that agreed with the known value, so the equation for the curve is correct.

It's been awhile since I've used calculus like this, but this problem should be very straight forward; however, that is not turning out to be the case.

Where have I gone wrong?

EDIT: I'd like to point out that I've already solved for the location of the centroid using a different method. I posted this because I'm more interested in finding out why this method isn't working for me.
 
Attachments
  • What is the Correct Equation for Finding the Centroid of a Circle?
    MRbfl.jpg
    509 bytes · Views: 422
  • Calculus working: the integral from 1 to 0 of sqrt(2x - x^2) dx, followed by an antiderivative written with square roots, a log term, and x^(3/2) terms, shown as a handwritten-style computer algebra result.
    p5yPi.jpg
    6.4 KB · Views: 1,033
  • What is the Correct Equation for Finding the Centroid of a Circle?
    112B8.jpg
    509 bytes · Views: 481
  • Equation: A = ((2(1))^2 - π(1)^2) / 4 ≅ 0.2146
    BtCtj.jpg
    2.4 KB · Views: 457
  • Equation A = ((2r)^2 - πr^2) / 4, written as a formula for an area with a fraction bar.
    Wddr8.jpg
    1.3 KB · Views: 454
  • Centroid formula: y-bar equals the integral over A of y dA divided by the integral over A of dA, rewritten as the integral from 0 to r of y(r - sqrt(2ry - y^2)) dy over the integral from 0 to r of (r - sqrt(2ry - y^2)) dy.
    EtVOC.jpg
    4.3 KB · Views: 440
  • Centroid formula: x-bar equals the integral over A of x dA divided by the integral over A of dA, equal to the integral from 0 to r of x(r - sqrt(2rx - x^2)) dx divided by the integral from 0 to r of (r - sqrt(2rx - x^2)) dx.
    uvwMP.jpg
    4 KB · Views: 464
Last edited:
6Stang7 said:
I'm trying to determine the centroid of the shape below:
Imgur error message reading: The image you are requesting does not exist or is no longer available.


The curve line is that of a circle, but the equation of for a circle, (x-a)2+(y-b)2=r2, won't work here for obvious reasons, but the equation y=r-[tex]\sqrt{2rx-x^{2}}[/tex] does.

To determine the location of the centroid, the formula is:

Handwritten centroid formula: x-bar equals the double integral of x dA over A divided by the double integral of dA over A, equals the integral from 0 to r of x times (r minus the square root of 2rx minus x squared) dx, over the integral from 0 to r of (r minus the square root of 2rx minus x squared) dx.

Centroid formula: y-bar equals the integral over A of y dA divided by the integral over A of dA, equals the integral from 0 to r of y times (r minus the square root of 2ry minus y squared) dy, divided by the integral from 0 to r of (r minus the square root of 2ry minus y squared) dy.

These equations look correct to me. I get

[tex]\bar{x} = \bar{y}= \frac{r(10-3\pi)}{12-3\pi}[/tex]
 
LCKurtz said:
These equations look correct to me. I get

[tex]\bar{x} = \bar{y}= \frac{r(10-3\pi)}{12-3\pi}[/tex]

That is exactly the answer. Can you please go into some detail about how you obtained it? Can you also explain why I am not getting the correct answer when I try integrating for the area under the curve?