What is the Correct Method for Calculating Tension in Equilibrium?

5 replies · 2K views · last reply
blubbulf
Messages
4
Reaction score
0
I don't manage to get this task right. See the pictures. First i take point D and draw a free body diagram. Then i use the equation for equilibrium. I can then calculate the tension in the wires that goes from D to B and from D to C. I then take point B and draw a free body diagram, but all the answers i get is wrong. Can somebody please see what i have done wrong?
 
Attachments
  • Textbook page showing problems 3-20 and 3-21 with a diagram of a chandelier hung by wires from walls at A and C and a central point D, with angles of 30°, 45° and 30° marked.
    3.20.JPG
    18.8 KB · Views: 521
  • Handwritten free-body diagram of point D with tensions T_DB at 45 degrees and T_DC at 30 degrees, weight T_DE = 50 × 9.81 N = 490.5 N, followed by equilibrium equations solving to T_DB = 849.5 N.
    Task 1.JPG
    18.9 KB · Views: 475
  • Handwritten free-body diagram of a joint with tensions T_BA and T_BC, a 30 degree angle and a 45 degree angle, a 849 N load, and equilibrium equations summed in x and y, with solved values for T_BA and T_BC.
    Task 2.JPG
    21.2 KB · Views: 518
Method looks ok. Check your working at the bottom of image Task1.jpg. The third line up looks ok. Last two look wrong.

I got...

TDB (1.11) = 490
so
TDB = 441N
 
Thanks for your reply, and sorry for just putting up pictures. My first time, so i will try to put things together a little nicer. I don't see how to solve that equation. I move 490.5 to the right, divide that with (cos45/cos30)(*sin30) so i stand with TDB+TDB sin45. divide with sin 45 and at last i divide with 2, beacuse TDB+TDB=2TDB. But apparently somewhere this got terribly wrong, and i don't se where.
 
Ah, now i see what you did, but want you get 2TDB when you add them together?
 
Here is my working starting with your equation...

TDB*cos45*sin30/cos30 + TDB*SIN45 - 490.5 = 0

Take TDB outside brackets..

TDB*(cos45*sin30/cos30 + SIN45) - 490.5 = 0

Rearrange..
TDB = 490.5/(cos45*sin30/cos30 + SIN45)

Substitute values..
= 490.5/(0.707*0.5/0.866 + 0.707)
= 490.5/(1.12)
= 438N
Not quite the 441N I got earlier.