What is the correct way to find the inertia of a bullet entering a door?

Click For Summary

Homework Help Overview

The problem involves a 10 g bullet striking a 12 kg door, which is 1.2 m wide, at the edge opposite the hinge. The bullet embeds itself in the door, causing it to swing open. The main focus is on determining the angular velocity of the door immediately after the impact, with particular attention to calculating the moment of inertia of the bullet and the door.

Discussion Character

  • Mixed

Approaches and Questions Raised

  • Participants discuss the calculation of the moment of inertia for the bullet and the door, with some questioning whether the inertia of the bullet should be calculated as M*L^2. There is also exploration of energy conservation versus angular momentum conservation in the context of the collision.

Discussion Status

Some participants have provided guidance on the relationship between the bullet's momentum and the door's angular momentum. There is recognition that energy is not conserved in this scenario, but angular momentum is, leading to further exploration of the relevant equations.

Contextual Notes

Participants are grappling with the definitions and calculations related to inertia and energy conservation in a collision scenario, indicating a need for clarity on these concepts.

Raisintoe
Messages
23
Reaction score
2
I am having trouble with this one problem. I have tried multiple times to solve it, but come up with the same wrong answer every time. The mistake that I may be making is in finding the Inertia of the bullet entering the door: I figured that some mass at the given radius from the hinge of the door should have an inertia I = M*R^2, is this correct? I = ∫r^2*dm

1. Homework Statement

A 10 g bullet traveling at 350m/s strikes a 12kg , 1.2-m-wide door at the edge opposite the hinge. The bullet embeds itself in the door, causing the door to swing open.

What is the angular velocity of the door just after impact?

Homework Equations


Inertia of the door = ⅓*M*L^2 where L is the Width of the door: ⅓*(12kg)*(1.2m)^2

The Attempt at a Solution


I have taken the approach of finding the kinetic energy of the bullet: ½*M*V^2 and then converting that energy to rotational energy of the door. As I understand it, all energy should be rotational energy because the door swings on its end.

I find the angular velocity of the door (ω) by using: ω = √((M_bullet*V^2)/(⅓*M_door*L^2 + M_bullet*L^2)) = √((M_bullet*(V/L)^2)/(⅓*M_door + M_bullet)). I figured this equation from: KE_bullet = E_door = ½*M_bullet*V^2 = ½*(⅓*M_door*L^2 + M_bullet*L^2)*ω^2I think that I am going wrong when I try to find the Inertia of the bullet: Is it M*L^2? (0.01kg)*(1.2m)^2
 
Physics news on Phys.org
Raisintoe said:
I am having trouble with this one problem. I have tried multiple times to solve it, but come up with the same wrong answer every time. The mistake that I may be making is in finding the Inertia of the bullet entering the door: I figured that some mass at the given radius from the hinge of the door should have an inertia I = M*R^2, is this correct? I = ∫r^2*dm

1. Homework Statement

A 10 g bullet traveling at 350m/s strikes a 12kg , 1.2-m-wide door at the edge opposite the hinge. The bullet embeds itself in the door, causing the door to swing open.

What is the angular velocity of the door just after impact?

Homework Equations


Inertia of the door = ⅓*M*L^2 where L is the Width of the door: ⅓*(12kg)*(1.2m)^2

The Attempt at a Solution


I have taken the approach of finding the kinetic energy of the bullet: ½*M*V^2 and then converting that energy to rotational energy of the door. As I understand it, all energy should be rotational energy because the door swings on its end.I find the angular velocity of the door (ω) by using: ω = √((M_bullet*V^2)/(⅓*M_door*L^2 + M_bullet*L^2)) = √((M_bullet*(V/L)^2)/(⅓*M_door + M_bullet)). I figured this equation from: KE_bullet = E_door = ½*M_bullet*V^2 = ½*(⅓*M_door*L^2 + M_bullet*L^2)*ω^2I think that I am going wrong when I try to find the Inertia of the bullet: Is it M*L^2? (0.01kg)*(1.2m)^2
No, you are right, the moment of inertia of the bullet is MbulletL2.
But it is not true that the kinetic energy of the bullet converts to he rotational energy of the door(with bullet embedded). Energy is not conserved, but the angular momentum is.
What is the angular momentum of the bullet with respect to the hinge before collision?
 
OK, Thank you, I got it now:

I_bullet = M_bullet*L^2:

P_bullet = I_bullet*V/L = M_bullet*L*V:

ω = P_bullet/(I_bullet + I_door)
 
Raisintoe said:
OK, Thank you, I got it now:

I_bullet = M_bullet*L^2:

P_bullet = I_bullet*V/L = M_bullet*L*V:

ω = P_bullet/(I_bullet + I_door)
It is all right now :)
 

Similar threads

Replies
2
Views
2K
  • · Replies 6 ·
Replies
6
Views
2K
Replies
3
Views
3K
Replies
21
Views
3K
Replies
6
Views
5K
  • · Replies 8 ·
Replies
8
Views
3K
  • · Replies 88 ·
3
Replies
88
Views
24K
  • · Replies 2 ·
Replies
2
Views
4K
  • · Replies 20 ·
Replies
20
Views
16K
Replies
2
Views
2K