Angular acceleration, velocity, momentum of a door?

Click For Summary

Homework Help Overview

The problem involves a door modeled as a uniform rod, focusing on its rotational motion around a vertical axis. The scenario describes an external force applied by a person to slam the door shut, with various aspects of angular acceleration, velocity, momentum, and energy being explored. Participants are tasked with analyzing the effects of different points of force application and the role of hinges in the system.

Discussion Character

  • Exploratory, Conceptual clarification, Mathematical reasoning, Problem interpretation, Assumption checking

Approaches and Questions Raised

  • Participants discuss the calculation of angular acceleration and the moment of inertia, with some questioning the application of torque and the axis of rotation. There are attempts to derive equations for tangential forces and the implications of pushing at different points on the door. Several participants express uncertainty about their calculations and seek verification of their results.

Discussion Status

The discussion is active, with multiple participants providing their calculations and questioning each other's reasoning. Some participants have offered guidance on the correct formulas to use, while others have pointed out potential errors in previous calculations. There is a mix of agreement on certain answers, but also significant debate over the correct approach and assumptions.

Contextual Notes

Participants note potential typos in the problem statement regarding the distance from the hinges and the time duration of the force application. There is also mention of the need to clarify the axis of rotation and the moment of inertia used in calculations.

Haveagoodday
Messages
43
Reaction score
1
Skjermbilde 2015-10-29 kl. 21.45.27.png


1. Homework Statement

A door of width l = 1.00 m and mass M = 15.0 kg is attached to a door

frame by two hinges. For this problem, you may ignore gravity, as we are

interested in rotational motion around the vertical axis. There is no friction

of any kind.

An angry mother-in-law slams the door shut, by pushing at the middle of

the door (l=2 from the hinges) with a force of F = 100N, lasting a time

t = 0:.00 s. The door is initially not rotating. The door can be taken to be

a uniform rod, for the purpose of this exercise.

a) What is the angular acceleration of the door while it is being pushed?

b) What is the resulting angular velocity, angular momentum and rotational

kinetic energy from this push?
c) Assuming that she let's go of the door (leaving it to slam shut) at the

moment in the motion when the door is perpendicular to the wall, how long

does it take for the door to close?

d) What would be the result of a), b), c) and d) if she had pushed not in the

middle of the door but at the edge (l from the hinges)?

In addition to the force of the mother-in-law, the hinges also provide force,

both radial (centripetal) and tangential force while the mother-in-law pushes

(they also compensate for gravity to keep the door upright, but ignore that

for now).

e) Combining angular acceleration and linear acceleration considerations, find

the tangential force Fh supplied by the hinges as a function of d, the distance

between the hinges and the point of application of the mother-in-law force

(d was l=2 in part a) and b), and l in part c); now use a general d). Don’t

put in explicit numbers, just find the equation.

f) For which d do the hinges not need to provide any tangential force?

The Attempt at a Solution


Can someone check on my solutions, All answers appreciated![/B]
a)
τ= l/2*F=50
τ=M*(l/2)^2*α
α=τ/M*(l/2)^2= 13.33 rad/s^2

b)
ω=ωi+αt=2.7 rad/s
I=(1/12)*Ml^2=1.25 kg*m^2
L=I*ω=3.375 kg*m^2/s
K=(1/2)*I*ω^2=4.56 J

c)
θ=θ+ωt+(1/2)αt^2
π/2=2.7t+(1/2)13.33t^2
used the abc rule
t=0.323 s
d)
τ= l*F=100
τ=M*l^2*α
α=τ/M*l^2= 6.7 rad/s^2

ω=ωi+αt= 1.34 rad/s
I=(1/3)*Ml^2=5 kg*m^2
L=I*ω=6.7 kg*m^2/s
K=(1/2)*I*ω^2=4.489 J

θ=θ+ωt+(1/2)αt^2
π/2=1.34t+(1/2)6.7t^2
used the abc rule
t=0.512 s


e)
This solution i am sure is wrong
Fh(d)= τ(d)/I + F(d)/M

d)
d=l
 
Physics news on Phys.org
Haveagoodday said:
View attachment 91039

1. Homework Statement

A door of width l = 1.00 m and mass M = 15.0 kg is attached to a door

frame by two hinges. For this problem, you may ignore gravity, as we are

interested in rotational motion around the vertical axis. There is no friction

of any kind.

An angry mother-in-law slams the door shut, by pushing at the middle of

the door (l=2 from the hinges) with a force of F = 100N, lasting a time

t = 0:.00 s. The door is initially not rotating. The door can be taken to be

a uniform rod, for the purpose of this exercise.

a) What is the angular acceleration of the door while it is being pushed?

b) What is the resulting angular velocity, angular momentum and rotational

kinetic energy from this push?
c) Assuming that she let's go of the door (leaving it to slam shut) at the

moment in the motion when the door is perpendicular to the wall, how long

does it take for the door to close?

d) What would be the result of a), b), c) and d) if she had pushed not in the

middle of the door but at the edge (l from the hinges)?

In addition to the force of the mother-in-law, the hinges also provide force,

both radial (centripetal) and tangential force while the mother-in-law pushes

(they also compensate for gravity to keep the door upright, but ignore that

for now).

e) Combining angular acceleration and linear acceleration considerations, find

the tangential force Fh supplied by the hinges as a function of d, the distance

between the hinges and the point of application of the mother-in-law force

(d was l=2 in part a) and b), and l in part c); now use a general d). Don’t

put in explicit numbers, just find the equation.

f) For which d do the hinges not need to provide any tangential force?

The Attempt at a Solution


Can someone check on my solutions, All answers appreciated![/B]
a)
τ= l/2*F=50
τ=M*(l/2)^2*α
α=τ/M*(l/2)^2= 13.33 rad/s^2

b)
ω=ωi+αt=2.7 rad/s
I=(1/12)*Ml^2=1.25 kg*m^2
L=I*ω=3.375 kg*m^2/s
K=(1/2)*I*ω^2=4.56 J

c)
θ=θ+ωt+(1/2)αt^2
π/2=2.7t+(1/2)13.33t^2
used the abc rule
t=0.323 s
d)
τ= l*F=100
τ=M*l^2*α
α=τ/M*l^2= 6.7 rad/s^2

ω=ωi+αt= 1.34 rad/s
I=(1/3)*Ml^2=5 kg*m^2
L=I*ω=6.7 kg*m^2/s
K=(1/2)*I*ω^2=4.489 J

θ=θ+ωt+(1/2)αt^2
π/2=1.34t+(1/2)6.7t^2
used the abc rule
t=0.512 s

e)
This solution i am sure is wrong
Fh(d)= τ(d)/I + F(d)/M

d)
d=l
It appears that you have some typos in the statement of the problem

I assume she pushes the door at a point located L/2 from the axis of rotation. (Lower case L should be banned as a variable.)

The time interval over which she pushes is not given. It looks like you used t = 0.20 seconds.

What did you use for the moment of inertia of the door ?
 
SammyS said:
What did you use for the moment of inertia of the door ?
... and about what axis?
Haveagoodday, you seem to have used ML2/4 in a) and ML2/12 in b).
 
I have same answers in a and b, but you have a typo in b. In c you have to calculate again, your answer is wrong.
 
coffeemanja said:
I have same answers in a and b,
None of the answers given to a) and b) in the OP are correct.
 
And why is that so? My only guess is that I should take Fsin0 instead of pure F... Then it will change all the answers
 
Wait, it will not change a thing.
 
A) ΣFt=mat->at= ΣFt/m=6,7
α=at/r=6,7/0,5=13,4
Where did I go wrong?
 
at is tangential acceleration
 
  • #10
coffeemanja said:
And why is that so? My only guess is that I should take Fsin0 instead of pure F... Then it will change all the answers
My guess is that haruspex did not guess.
 
  • #11
coffeemanja said:
A) ΣFt=mat->at= ΣFt/m=6,7
α=at/r=6,7/0,5=13,4
Where did I go wrong?
This is rotation. Use torque and moment of inertia.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: coffeemanja
  • #12
haruspex said:
This is rotation. Use torque and moment of inertia.
Now I got 40 in a.
 
  • #13
coffeemanja said:
Now I got 40 in a.
Better, but as Sammy pointed out in post #2 the L=2 must be a typo, probably for L/2. Does that change your answer?
 
  • #14
haruspex said:
Better, but as Sammy pointed out in post #2 the L=2 must be a typo, probably for L/2. Does that change your answer?
L/2 is correct. And that is what I used.

All answers are new and angry mother-in-law is slaming the door faster, when she holds at the edge. Seems reasonable.
But I'm so stuck at e) now...
 
  • #15
coffeemanja said:
L/2 is correct. And that is what I used.
Then you are probably using the wrong moment of inertia formula. What did you use?
coffeemanja said:
All answers are new
Would you like them checked?
coffeemanja said:
But I'm so stuck at e) now...
How far do you get? What equations do you have?
 
  • #16
coffeemanja said:
Now I got 40 in a.
 
Last edited:
  • #17
haruspex said:
Then you are probably using the wrong moment of inertia formula. What did you use?

Would you like them checked?

How far do you get? What equations do you have?

i now got 40 in a
and 8 rad/s, 10 kgm^2/s, 40J in b
are these answers correct?
And what equations can i use in c?
 
  • #18
Haveagoodday said:
i now got 40 in a
As I implied in post #15, I get a different answer. Please post your working.
 
  • #19
coffeemanja said:
I have same answers in a and b, but you have a typo in b. In c you have to calculate again, your answer is wrong.
how did you calculate c?
 
  • #20
haruspex said:
As I implied in post #15, I get a different answer. Please post your working.
in a:
I=Ml^2/12=1.25
α=T/I=40
in b:
w=w+αt=8
L=Iw=10
K=Iw^2/2=40
 
  • #21
Haveagoodday said:
how did you calculate c?
Coffeemanja should not lay out the solution for you.
What is the acceleration in part c?
 
  • #22
Haveagoodday said:
in a:
I=Ml^2/12=1.25
Where is the axis of rotation?
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: Haakon
  • #23
j
 
  • #24
haruspex said:
Coffeemanja should not lay out the solution for you.
What is the acceleration in part c?
I don't want him to give me the solution, i calculated the problem and i got a wrong answer, all i want is just a tip.
 
  • #25
haruspex said:
Where is the axis of rotation?
is it the y axis, or?
 
  • #26
Haveagoodday said:
is it the y axis, or?
Where is it in relation to the door?
 
  • #27
haruspex said:
Where is it in relation to the door?
it is in relation to the height of the door?
 
  • #28
Haveagoodday said:
it is in relation to the height of the door?
No, it's vertical. In relation to the width.
 
  • #29
haruspex said:
No, it's vertical. In relation to the width.
Ok, but how does that make my result wrong?
 
  • #30
Haveagoodday said:
Ok, but how does that make my result wrong?
You're not answering my question. Where is this vertical axis in relation to the door's width? Does it run up the middle of the door?
 

Similar threads

  • · Replies 17 ·
Replies
17
Views
1K
  • · Replies 6 ·
Replies
6
Views
2K
Replies
3
Views
3K
  • · Replies 1 ·
Replies
1
Views
3K
  • · Replies 5 ·
Replies
5
Views
3K
Replies
335
Views
17K
Replies
3
Views
2K
  • · Replies 3 ·
Replies
3
Views
2K
Replies
8
Views
2K
  • · Replies 7 ·
Replies
7
Views
2K