fatjjx
- 3
- 0
the regular ellipse formula in 2D is x^2/a^2 + y^2/b^2 = 1. but how can it be transformed into a 3D formula including the parameter of z?
thank you!
thank you!
The discussion centers on the formulation of an ellipse in 3D space, exploring how the 2D ellipse equation can be adapted or extended to three dimensions. Participants consider various mathematical representations and the implications of dimensionality on the definition of an ellipse.
Participants do not reach a consensus on the appropriate formula for an ellipse in 3D space. Multiple competing views remain regarding how to represent an ellipse mathematically in three dimensions, and whether the discussion pertains to ellipses or ellipsoids.
Some participants note that defining an ellipse in 3D may depend on the orientation of the ellipse relative to the coordinate axes, which introduces additional complexity in formulating the equations.
symbolipoint said:Try thinking in the other direction:
Would an ellipse in ONE dimension be (x^2)/(a^2)=1 ?
Do you accept that an ellipse in TWO dimensions is (x^2)/(a^2)+(y^2)/(b^2)=1 ?
Now how would you use three dimensions?
Did he mean ellipse or ellipsoid? The former is a 2D curve in 3D space whereas the latter is a 3D surface.Gib Z said:It's probably not best to tell the OP to guess the formula from a pattern and say that its just "intuitive". One could just as well presume that since in one dimension x/a =1, and in 2 dimensions (x/a)^2 + (y/b)^2 = 1 that following the pattern into 3 dimensions is obviously (x/a)^3 + (y/b)^3 + (z/c)^3 = 1. We could probably think up a more stupid one as well.
Fatjjx - What you want to describe is an "Ellipsoid" - http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ellipsoid
Basically, you start off with the equation of a Sphere, which is easy to derive using the Pythagorean theorem, and then you apply Linear Transformations, which in this case are just squeezing and stretching the sphere to make an ellipsoid.
Gib Z said:It's probably not best to tell the OP to guess the formula from a pattern and say that its just "intuitive". One could just as well presume that since in one dimension x/a =1, and in 2 dimensions (x/a)^2 + (y/b)^2 = 1 that following the pattern into 3 dimensions is obviously (x/a)^3 + (y/b)^3 + (z/c)^3 = 1. We could probably think up a more stupid one as well.
Fatjjx - What you want to describe is an "Ellipsoid" - http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ellipsoid
Basically, you start off with the equation of a Sphere, which is easy to derive using the Pythagorean theorem, and then you apply Linear Transformations, which in this case are just squeezing and stretching the sphere to make an ellipsoid.