DeadWolfe
- 456
- 1
I'm stumped.
Silly, it's both.berkeman said:Strange coincidence. Tonight we had a debate about what the plural of octopus is -- it took us a while to find a dictionary. I had everybody convinced it was octopi, until my wife found her (hidden) dictionary and proved that it is octupuses. Doh!
http://www.m-w.com/dictionary/octopusInflected Form(s): plural -pus·es or oc·to·pi
Rach3 said:I'm rather sure it was originally octopi inheriting the Latin declension, and octopuses was a bastardization.
Chambers 20th Century Dictionary said:pl. octopuses, (arch.) octopodes (octopi is wrong)
Actually octopi is such a 'standardization'.Rach3 said:Some people would say adding the "es" makes it a standardization, because it agrees with some other plural forms. I call it bastardization.
(some symbols are not showing up in quote)ETYMOLOGY: New Latin Octopus, genus name, from Greek oktpous, eight-footed : okt, eight; see okt(u) in Appendix I + pous, foot; see ped- in Appendix I.
http://scholar.google.com/scholar?hl=en&lr=&q=octopi&btnG=SearchScholar Google said:Results 1 - 10 of about 796 for octopi
Results 1 - 10 of about 82 for octopodes
Oh baby. This should be good. Well, not good for the mairrage (sp?), but good overall. Wish me luck!Rach3 said:I'm rather sure it was originally octopi inheriting the Latin declension, and octopuses was a bastardization. Some people would say adding the "es" makes it a standardization, because it agrees with some other plural forms. I call it bastardization.
From lower down on that pageRach3 said:
Fowler's Modern English Usage states that "the only acceptable plural in English is octopuses", and that octopi is misconceived and octopodes pedantic. Octopi derives from the mistaken notion that octōpūs is a second declension Latin noun, which it is not.
That's why trucks only carry one octupus at a time.berkeman said:Strange coincidence. Tonight we had a debate about what the plural of octopus is -- it took us a while to find a dictionary. I had everybody convinced it was octopi, until my wife found her (hidden) dictionary and proved that it is octupuses. Doh!
Kurdt said:(spot the deliberate mistake)
Kurdt said:On the serious note
Notice how they don't even mention if the driver was hurt? Typical.BobG said:That's why trucks only carry one octupus at a time.
4 penguins perish in freak Texas truck accident - Octopus unhurt, exotic fish not as lucky en route to temporary home
Why hasn't Pengwino posted today?![]()
“There was another truck full of snakes and alligators that was an hour ahead of them, so luckily we didn’t have to deal with the alligators,” Buchanan said.
chronon said:From lower down on that page
Maybe we should start using octopera on the basis of opus - opera .
http://www.team4news.com/Global/story.asp?S=5256451&nav=0w0vberkeman said:Notice how they don't even mention if the driver was hurt? Typical.
BTW, this part of the article was especially funny:
BobG said:http://www.team4news.com/Global/story.asp?S=5256451&nav=0w0v
Better? (At least they got around to mentioning the driver in the second to last sentence). It even has a picture (the creature under the sheet that had the life support removed looks pretty flat)
BobG said:Edit: BTW, is 'pluaral' supposed to be plural for 'plural' or something?
All I know is that the breathing disorder is called 'pleuresy' because we have 2 lungs.Rach3 said:Nope, plural is not plural, plural is plurals.