What Is the Potential Energy Function for This Force?

Click For Summary

Homework Help Overview

The problem involves a force given by F = -2 N/m^3 ( (2xyz - z^3)i + x^2z j + (x^2y - 3xz^2)k ) and requires finding the potential energy function, calculating work done on a block, and determining the block's initial acceleration. The context is within the subject area of classical mechanics, particularly focusing on potential energy and forces in three-dimensional space.

Discussion Character

  • Exploratory, Conceptual clarification, Mathematical reasoning

Approaches and Questions Raised

  • Participants discuss the possibility of integrating the components of the force separately and question the necessity of checking if the curl of the force is zero. There are suggestions regarding using path integrals versus direct integration methods. Some participants express uncertainty about how to begin the calculations for work and acceleration.

Discussion Status

There is ongoing exploration of different methods to approach the problem, including the suggestion to guess a potential function whose gradient matches the negative of the force. Some participants have made attempts at calculations but express confusion about the results, particularly regarding the work done and the potential function.

Contextual Notes

Participants note that the problem does not specify certain details, such as whether to check the curl of the force, leading to assumptions being made. There is also mention of the reference point for potential energy, which may influence the calculations.

brianbigb03
Messages
7
Reaction score
0

Homework Statement



1. Given F = -2 N/m^3 ( (2xyz - z^3)i + x^2z j + (x^2y - 3xz^2)k ).
a. Find the potential energy function for this force, taking (i + 2 j + k) m as reference point.
b. Find the work done by this force on a 4-kg block moved from the reference point to the
origin.
c. Find the initial acceleration of the block, if at that time this was the only force on it.

Homework Equations



U(x) = -∫Fdx


The Attempt at a Solution



for a. can i integrate i j and k separately? using the reference points as my limits?
and then i have no clue where to begin on b. and c.
any help is greatly appreciated
 

Attachments

  • q1.jpg
    q1.jpg
    16 KB · Views: 477
Physics news on Phys.org
brianbigb03 said:

Homework Statement



1. Given F = -2 N/m^3 ( (2xyz - z^3)i + x^2z j + (x^2y - 3xz^2)k ).
a. Find the potential energy function for this force, taking (i + 2 j + k) m as reference point.
b. Find the work done by this force on a 4-kg block moved from the reference point to the
origin.
c. Find the initial acceleration of the block, if at that time this was the only force on it.

Homework Equations



U(x) = -∫Fdx


The Attempt at a Solution



for a. can i integrate i j and k separately? using the reference points as my limits?
and then i have no clue where to begin on b. and c.
any help is greatly appreciated

You don't integrate Fdx. You integrate the dot product of F.dr where r(t) is a path connecting the reference points. I'd suggest taking a straight line. Once you take the dot product there's no i,j,k left. And you can only play this game if curl(F)=0. Did they want you to check that?
 
they didnt specify. but I am assuming that the curl is 0.
 
brianbigb03 said:
they didnt specify. but I am assuming that the curl is 0.

It is. You can check that if you need to. But my point is that you need to do a path integral, not just a dx integral. Part c is really much easier than the other two, you really should be able to handle that one even if the other two are giving problems.
 
yea i have been working on other problems since i wasnt sure how to start this one. But i did the dot product and for my function i got.
2*((2xyz-z^3)+(2x^2z)+(x^2y-3xz^2).

stop me if I am wrong here but the rest should be:

part b looks like i just use (1,2,1) and plug them into my potential function

part c is just a=f/m
 
An alternative to the path integral is basically trying to guess a function U(x,y,z) whose gradient is F. It's not really too hard. Try it.
 
brianbigb03 said:
yea i have been working on other problems since i wasnt sure how to start this one. But i did the dot product and for my function i got.
2*((2xyz-z^3)+(2x^2z)+(x^2y-3xz^2).

stop me if I am wrong here but the rest should be:

part b looks like i just use (1,2,1) and plug them into my potential function

part c is just a=f/m

Yeah, I'll stop you there. Maybe you aren't really doing path integrals. See my last post. Try to guess a potential function and then see if it works. You know the gradient of U is -F, yes? And sure, once you have that b is easy. c is easy any way you do it and you don't need a and b to do it.
 
almost forgot i have to integrate this dot porduct but that shouldn't be too hard.
 
ok let me try that then.
 
  • #10
ok so the grad of F is the partial with respect to x,y,z. so if f is the gradient i need to indiviually integrate i j k with respect to x y z.
 
  • #11
brianbigb03 said:
ok so the grad of F is the partial with respect to x,y,z. so if f is the gradient i need to indiviually integrate i j k with respect to x y z.

Sort of, sure. If you can find a U such that grad(U)=(-F) then you are done. I kind of think of it more like guessing as with that as a hint. Can you find U? Mmm. It doesn't have any i,j,k in it. It's a scalar function.
 
Last edited:
  • #12
And so now I see where the rest of the class is on the test...:). 11 more to go!
 
  • #13
ok i collected the common terms in i j k so i understand that but when i try to find the work (w = -(change in potential) i get 0.
 
  • #14
brianbigb03 said:
ok i collected the common terms in i j k so i understand that but when i try to find the work (w = -(change in potential) i get 0.

What did you get for a potential function?
 
  • #15
The simplest thing to do is integrate along the straight line from (1, 2, -3) to (x, y, z). However you could also use the "broken" line from (1, 2, -3) to (x, 2, -3), then to (x, y, -3), then to (x, y, z). On the first of those only x varies so only the "dx" part is non-zero, on the second only y varies so only the "dy" part is non-zero, and on the third only z varies so only the "dz" part is non-zero.
 

Similar threads

  • · Replies 20 ·
Replies
20
Views
3K
  • · Replies 2 ·
Replies
2
Views
2K
  • · Replies 14 ·
Replies
14
Views
3K
Replies
5
Views
2K
  • · Replies 19 ·
Replies
19
Views
3K
Replies
12
Views
2K
  • · Replies 10 ·
Replies
10
Views
2K
Replies
19
Views
3K
  • · Replies 19 ·
Replies
19
Views
4K
  • · Replies 7 ·
Replies
7
Views
3K