What is the reason we don't "see" the Universe's expansion?

Join the discussion
Registration is free. Start your own thread to ask a follow-up.
2 replies · 2K views
MBBphys
Gold Member
Messages
55
Reaction score
0

Homework Statement


Ok, so if the universe is expanding, and the scale of space itself is changing, then that means that even humans and the Earth is expanding right?
But is the reason why we don't notice this effect the slowness of it?
So v=Hd, where H is Hubble's constant, which has a value of about 70 kms-1Mpc-1
So if we convert that to ms-1m-1-->it becomes (70000/(3.1x10^16))-->2.26 x 10^-12, that means a point one metre away from me is moving away from me at a speed of 2.26 x 10^-12 ms-1?
So if we take an entire human life to be, say, 100 years-->speed * time=2.26x10^-12 x 100 x 365 x 24 x 60 x 60=0.00713 metres-->is this why we do not "see" the expansion?

Homework Equations


V=Hd

The Attempt at a Solution


(See above)
 
Physics news on Phys.org
MBBphys said:

Homework Statement


Ok, so if the universe is expanding, and the scale of space itself is changing, then that means that even humans and the Earth is expanding right?
But is the reason why we don't notice this effect the slowness of it?
So v=Hd, where H is Hubble's constant, which has a value of about 70 kms-1Mpc-1
So if we convert that to ms-1m-1-->it becomes (70000/(3.1x10^16))-->2.26 x 10^-12, that means a point one metre away from me is moving away from me at a speed of 2.26 x 10^-12 ms-1?
So if we take an entire human life to be, say, 100 years-->speed * time=2.26x10^-12 x 100 x 365 x 24 x 60 x 60=0.00713 metres-->is this why we do not "see" the expansion?

Homework Equations


V=Hd

The Attempt at a Solution


(See above)
If our rulers are expanding at the same rate as we are expanding, how will we be able to measure any difference? :smile:
 
MBBphys said:

Homework Statement


Ok, so if the universe is expanding, and the scale of space itself is changing, then that means that even humans and the Earth is expanding right?
But is the reason why we don't notice this effect the slowness of it?
So v=Hd, where H is Hubble's constant, which has a value of about 70 kms-1Mpc-1
So if we convert that to ms-1m-1-->it becomes (70000/(3.1x10^16))-->2.26 x 10^-12, that means a point one metre away from me is moving away from me at a speed of 2.26 x 10^-12 ms-1?
So if we take an entire human life to be, say, 100 years-->speed * time=2.26x10^-12 x 100 x 365 x 24 x 60 x 60=0.00713 metres-->is this why we do not "see" the expansion?

Homework Equations


V=Hd

The Attempt at a Solution


(See above)

I think your figures are a bit out. The lifetime expansion per meter is nearer ##6*10^{-9}m##. Which would be hard to detect.

A better example is the Earth's orbit round the Sun. The expansion of space would amount to about ##1km## in a lifetime. But, the Earth and the Sun are gravitationally bound, which means that gravity counteracts the minute expansion and keeps the two in the same orbit.

A more extreme example would be an object sitting on the ground. A slow expansion of space could not counteract gravity and lift it slowly off the ground.

Similarly the intermolecular forces that keep things together prevent you from expanding, even slowly!