B What is the Universe expanding into?

[Akshaya dhakal]

TL;DR Summary

If it is everything then what is it expanding into?

As we know universe is everything having every matter and energy. From the observation using Hubble's law it was said that the galaxies are moving away from the Earth which means the universe is expanding. If it is everything then what is it expanding into. Is there some outer edge that it can expand into or any center it is expanding from? Is it infinite?

 

[Ibix]

Our current best model of the universe is infinite, yes. But even finite and closed models don't expand into anything. As far as we are aware there is nothing outside the universe for it to expand into.

The thing to remember is that general relativity describes 4d spacetime, and space at any given time is a 3d slice through that. So what we mean when we say that "space is expanding" is that there is a particular way to slice spacetime so that everything looks more or less the same everywhere in a slice, and when we do that, in each successive slice galaxies are slightly further apart. Nothing is expanding into anything because nothing is really expanding - things are just further apart in different slices of spacetime.

 

[sbrothy]

Summary:: If it is everything then what is it expanding into?

As we know universe is everything having every matter and energy. From the observation using Hubble's law it was said that the galaxies are moving away from the Earth which means the universe is expanding. If it is everything then what is it expanding into. Is there some outer edge that it can expand into or any center it is expanding from? Is it infinite?

Doesn't he expansion which basically started at the big bang been create the fime/space continuum in the process? Ex nihilo so to say. It's pretty difficult wrapping ones head around...

Explaining this to someone is pretty steeply up-hill. There are many misconceptions surfacing again and again. Some of the more annoying are people thinking that an explosion in vacuum looks exactly like a fireball in an atmosphere. Also that black holes basically works like a giant vacuum cleaner, gobbling up everything within it's gravitational sphere of influence. I'm sure there are tons of others.

Regards.

 

[DennisN]

Doesn't he expansion which basically started at the big bang been create the fime/space continuum in the process?

This is currently not known.

 

[weirdoguy]

This is currently not known.

What would it even mean to "create time/space continuum"?

 

[PeterDonis]

Doesn't he expansion which basically started at the big bang been create the fime/space continuum in the process?

No. Spacetime doesn't get "created"; it just is. It is a 4-dimensional geometry that already contains all of the information about "time".

This is currently not known.

Yes, it is; the answer is no. See above.