What kinds of foods give you the winds ?

  • Thread starter Thread starter turbo
  • Start date Start date
Click For Summary

Discussion Overview

The discussion revolves around the types of foods that cause flatulence, with participants sharing personal experiences and opinions on various foods and their effects on gas production. The scope includes anecdotal evidence and humorous reflections on dietary choices.

Discussion Character

  • Exploratory
  • Debate/contested
  • Conceptual clarification
  • Meta-discussion

Main Points Raised

  • Some participants suggest that foods like beans, cabbage, and broccoli are significant contributors to gas production.
  • Others mention personal experiences with specific foods, such as KFC chicken, beer, ice cream, and soda, noting their effects on flatulence.
  • A participant highlights that high concentrations of dry beans can lead to increased gas, while others share that they are less affected by certain foods.
  • There are claims that some foods, like dahl and certain types of ice cream, can also cause gas, with varying degrees of severity among individuals.
  • One participant humorously notes that they enjoy the effects of gas, while another reflects on the social implications of flatulence in public settings.
  • Some participants discuss potential sensitivities to ingredients like MSG and fat content in foods, suggesting these may contribute to digestive issues.
  • There is a mention of ground or whole cumin seeds as potentially aiding digestion and reducing flatulence.

Areas of Agreement / Disagreement

Participants express a variety of opinions on which foods cause gas, with no clear consensus on specific offenders. Many share personal anecdotes, leading to a mix of agreement on certain foods while also highlighting individual differences in reactions.

Contextual Notes

Participants' claims are based on personal experiences and may not account for broader dietary or physiological factors. The discussion reflects subjective interpretations of food effects on digestion.

Who May Find This Useful

Individuals interested in dietary effects on digestion, humor related to food and bodily functions, or those seeking to understand common food-related experiences may find this discussion engaging.

What food(s) make you gassy?

  • Beans, peas, lentils

    Votes: 9 45.0%
  • Cabbage

    Votes: 5 25.0%
  • Broccoli

    Votes: 4 20.0%
  • Whole grains

    Votes: 2 10.0%
  • Dairy products

    Votes: 6 30.0%
  • Salad greens

    Votes: 4 20.0%
  • Fresh fruits (apples, pears, etc)

    Votes: 2 10.0%
  • Nothing makes me gassy.

    Votes: 3 15.0%
  • Everything makes me gassy.

    Votes: 5 25.0%
  • None of your business!!!

    Votes: 2 10.0%

  • Total voters
    20
turbo
Insights Author
Gold Member
Messages
3,181
Reaction score
57
What kinds of foods give you "the winds"?

Since Wolram is exploring the capture and use of human-produced methane I thought it would be interesting to see what foods produce the most gas.
 
Biology news on Phys.org
Just an opinion, but if any of those give you gas it probably means you're on the brink of death and it's a good time to write a will :wink:

I only get gassy when I'm very sick, so I didn't vote for any of those.
 
all of the above! PF smokers: beware of my company in small quarters.
 
Stuff made with high concentrations of dry beans (like the pot of beans baking in the oven right now) can make me gassy, but I'm pretty much bullet proof for most other foods. Even chili doesn't usually get me going. I've got a neighbor that loves apples, but if he eats any more than one, he is a danger to others.:eek:
 
Cabbage is worse thean beans for me. I love cabbage.

And now you know why I live alone. :redface:
 
Last edited:
Dahl, which we have semi-regularly, does it to me.
 
George Jones said:
Dahl, which we have semi-regularly, does it to me.
Ah, yes! The harmless-looking little lentil. My wife makes a hummus/dip from canned black beans, jalapenos, lemon juice, fresh garlic, onion, etc that is pretty deadly.
 
Cabbage and broccoli. And I eat lots of Chinese food (with cabbage and broccoli).
 
The only thing that gets me is KFC chicken, there is something bad in that stuff that just does very horrible things to a person. Luckily I don't have a hard time staying away from it as it is disgusting food anyway.
 
  • #10
Gosh, don't we sound like a bunch of old fogeys talking about what makes us gassy! :smile:

Cabbage, definitely; broccoli to some extent (and I love broccoli too)...makes sense, they're related vegetables. Beans too, but only some, and only if I pig out on them (like when I made a 15 bean soup...yummy, but best consumed when you have no need to be around other people the day after).
 
  • #11
scorpa said:
The only thing that gets me is KFC chicken, there is something bad in that stuff that just does very horrible things to a person. Luckily I don't have a hard time staying away from it as it is disgusting food anyway.
You may have a sensitivity to MSG. That's one of the "secret herbs and spices" in the recipe. If you have similar problems with Lipton Onion Soup mix and stuff made with canned beef or chicken broths, that's about all the confirmation you need. All are very high in MSG, though it is hidden under aliases describing how the glutamates were produced; "autolyzed yeast", hydrolyzed vegetable protein", "modified food starch" and over 50 others, including the ubiquitous "natural flavors".
 
  • #12
turbo-1 said:
You may have a sensitivity to MSG.
Could just be the amount of fat in it too.
If you have similar problems with Lipton Onion Soup mix
Umm..usually it's the onions that are the culprit in that. :wink:
and stuff made with canned beef or chicken broths, that's about all the confirmation you need.
That would be more of a smoking gun.
 
  • #13
I voted for all of them, because I love to fart. Its funny.
 
  • #14
cyrusabdollahi said:
I voted for all of them, because I love to fart. Its funny.
Hey, Cy! Pull my finger!
 
  • #15
My worst offenders aren't on the list. They are:

1) Beer
2) Ice cream
3) Soda

There's no way you'll ever catch me getting wasted on a case of beer. More than two beers in a night will make me feel so bloated I think I'm going to rupture something, and then... well, the next day's "winds" are usually so unpleasant I can barely stand to be around myself. Trust me, cyrus, it's only funny for the first four hours. :rolleyes:

Cheaper ice creams contain a lot of air, which is mixed very thoroughly into the cream in order to achieve a nice fluffy texture. The downside is that you almost cannot avoid swallowing a large amount of this air, even if you let the ice cream completely melt in your mouth before swallowing. Denser, premium ice creams like Ben & Jerry's are less of a problem.

Soda's pretty self-explanatory. What goes in must go out.

- Warren
 
  • #16
Maybe for the first four hours. But during those four hours its still FUN-NAY!

I always belch out soda fizz. Thats funny too.
 
  • #17
Ground or whole cumin seeds aids good digestion, reducing flatulence!
 
  • #18
chroot said:
My worst offenders aren't on the list. They are:

1) Beer
2) Ice cream
3) Soda

There's no way you'll ever catch me getting wasted on a case of beer. More than two beers in a night will make me feel so bloated I think I'm going to rupture something, and then... well, the next day's "winds" are usually so unpleasant I can barely stand to be around myself. Trust me, cyrus, it's only funny for the first four hours. :rolleyes:

Cheaper ice creams contain a lot of air, which is mixed very thoroughly into the cream in order to achieve a nice fluffy texture. The downside is that you almost cannot avoid swallowing a large amount of this air, even if you let the ice cream completely melt in your mouth before swallowing. Denser, premium ice creams like Ben & Jerry's are less of a problem.

Soda's pretty self-explanatory. What goes in must go out.

- Warren
Ooh, sorry! I had room for only 10 choices and never got to the whipped/air rich stuff that we might eat. Obviously, carbonated beverages can be a problem, but (not so obviously) whipped-up light ice creams with lots of air can be deadly. That air is cold, low-volume, and evenly dispersed in the ice cream, but when it hits your gut, warms, expands, and collects in pockets... well the possibilities can be exciting. Maybe that's why eating deep-fried breaded ice cream after a bean-heavy dinner at a "Mexican" restaurant is not a real good idea.:bugeye:
 
  • #19
chroot said:
My worst offenders aren't on the list. They are:

1) Beer
2) Ice cream
3) Soda

There's no way you'll ever catch me getting wasted on a case of beer. More than two beers in a night will make me feel so bloated I think I'm going to rupture something, and then... well, the next day's "winds" are usually so unpleasant I can barely stand to be around myself. Trust me, cyrus, it's only funny for the first four hours. :rolleyes:

Cheaper ice creams contain a lot of air, which is mixed very thoroughly into the cream in order to achieve a nice fluffy texture. The downside is that you almost cannot avoid swallowing a large amount of this air, even if you let the ice cream completely melt in your mouth before swallowing. Denser, premium ice creams like Ben & Jerry's are less of a problem.

Soda's pretty self-explanatory. What goes in must go out.

- Warren

Hmm...I've never had a problem with ice cream. Beer and soda just make me burp. I guess if you don't burp enough, it has to get out the other way.
 
  • #20
After I started my first job out of college, I celebrated with some friends and some beer. The next day, I was first confronted with a novel question, the answer to which still eludes me: if I fart in my cubicle, can the person in the next cube smell it?

Do the cubicle walls somehow act to contain the fart? Do the ceiling-mounted vents encourage the fart upwards, away from neighbors' noses? I may never know.

I did learn one thing that day, though. That afternoon, I unleashed a suffocating demon of a fart into the closed-cell foam of my office chair. No more than ten seconds later, by some terrible coincidence, the incredibly cute HR girl who did my hiring paperwork showed up at my cubicle to introduce herself and welcome me to the company. All the while, the beast was slowly leaking out, sinking to the floor and filling the cubicle.

I saw it: her nose crinkled. Her eyes narrowed slightly, and she withdrew her hand from mine. She looked at me for a second, steadily. Her face betrayed her thoughts: You're a disgusting animal, aren't you? Did you really just fart right in front of me? Good lord, what the hell did you eat? She cut the conversation a bit shorter than you'd expect and left me alone to ponder my abysmal luck.

I never gathered the courage to explain to her that no, I hadn't farted in her presence; that it was just trapped in the cushion from a moment before she arrived. Something tells me that information wouldn't have done much to improve her opinion of me, anyway.

- Warren
 
  • #21
I say we kidnap warren and duct tape a couple 40s of Olde English 800 to his hands. Then let him lose to terrorize the streets. :biggrin:
 
Last edited:
  • #22
Greg Bernhardt said:
I say we kidnap warren and duct tape a couple 40s of old english 800 to his hands. Then let him lose to terrorize the streets. :biggrin:

Would I qualify as a smart bomb?

- Warren
 
  • #23
  • #24
Moonbear said:
Hmm...I've never had a problem with ice cream. Beer and soda just make me burp. I guess if you don't burp enough, it has to get out the other way.
I'm with you on this one! Once you let ingested gases get past the stomach, it can be a free-for-all, changing the rate of progression of nutrients and unbalancing the absorption of liquids and fats (and the vitamins dissolved in them). Burping is healthy and should not be suppressed. This doesn't mean that you have to burp the alphabet (like my cute little niece could pull off after swallowing enough air), but if there is undue pressure, it's got to come out one way or another. If it comes out early in the process, it may be healthier than suppressing that release and living with the consequences of holding it back.
 
  • #25
chroot said:
After I started my first job out of college, I celebrated with some friends and some beer. The next day, I was first confronted with a novel question, the answer to which still eludes me: if I fart in my cubicle, can the person in the next cube smell it?

Do the cubicle walls somehow act to contain the fart? Do the ceiling-mounted vents encourage the fart upwards, away from neighbors' noses? I may never know.

I did learn one thing that day, though. That afternoon, I unleashed a suffocating demon of a fart into the closed-cell foam of my office chair. No more than ten seconds later, by some terrible coincidence, the incredibly cute HR girl who did my hiring paperwork showed up at my cubicle to introduce herself and welcome me to the company. All the while, the beast was slowly leaking out, sinking to the floor and filling the cubicle.

I saw it: her nose crinkled. Her eyes narrowed slightly, and she withdrew her hand from mine. She looked at me for a second, steadily. Her face betrayed her thoughts: You're a disgusting animal, aren't you? Did you really just fart right in front of me? Good lord, what the hell did you eat? She cut the conversation a bit shorter than you'd expect and left me alone to ponder my abysmal luck.

I never gathered the courage to explain to her that no, I hadn't farted in her presence; that it was just trapped in the cushion from a moment before she arrived. Something tells me that information wouldn't have done much to improve her opinion of me, anyway.

- Warren
:smile: :smile: :smile: too bad they don't let mentors win guru awards, that's got to be the funniest thing I've ever heard.
 
  • #26
Maybe they could reverse-engineer the formula for cyrus' benefit, and call it Onaeb.

By the same token, I always wondered how much money they could make by relabeling the Where's Waldo? books to Where Isn't Waldo?, subtitled For less-gifted children.

- Warren
 
  • #27
chroot said:
I did learn one thing that day, though. That afternoon, I unleashed a suffocating demon of a fart into the closed-cell foam of my office chair. No more than ten seconds later, by some terrible coincidence, the incredibly cute HR girl who did my hiring paperwork showed up at my cubicle to introduce herself and welcome me to the company. All the while, the beast was slowly leaking out, sinking to the floor and filling the cubicle.
It could have been worse! She could have said "let me show you how to access 'xyz' system", so you would have had to get out of that chair and she would have sat down it in, unleashing a fresh essence of the person who is you.:smile:
 
Last edited:
  • #28
Why do I have a sudden urge to send Warren a case of beer for Christmas? :devil:
 
  • #29
Moonbear said:
Why do I have a sudden urge to send Warren a case of beer for Christmas? :devil:
Make it a heavy beer, like Guiness Stout, and send along some cheese and nuts. Take out life insurance policies on his family, and you might come out of this ahead.
 
  • #30
Breaking wind (zirt, fart), like belching (itkerreh), was considered by Arab and Hindoo as an act of purification; for it sought to drive all evil spirits from the body. Zirteh, a loud discharge was highly civil and proper in the company of others; but insidious fesweh (fizzle, creeper), with stench, was regarded as an insult. Many an Arab died because of it, especially when vented in the presence of royalty. Such an individual was termed Fezwaun (Fizzler) whereas his counterpart, a man of purity and esteem, was venerably entitled Eboo-ez-Zirteh (Father of Farts). Simojeh-el-Hewweh (Breaker of Wind) was the appellation granted an Egyptian bean-eater who could break wind in tune, a favourite accomplishment of fellaheen boys.
 

Similar threads

  • · Replies 3 ·
Replies
3
Views
5K
Replies
3
Views
2K
Replies
6
Views
3K
  • · Replies 5 ·
Replies
5
Views
8K
  • · Replies 13 ·
Replies
13
Views
4K
  • · Replies 4 ·
Replies
4
Views
2K
  • · Replies 8 ·
Replies
8
Views
7K
Replies
2
Views
1K
  • · Replies 21 ·
Replies
21
Views
2K
  • · Replies 6 ·
Replies
6
Views
2K