What other information is needed to solve this equation involving b?

Click For Summary

Homework Help Overview

The discussion revolves around a physics problem involving the motion of a mass-spring system with friction, represented by an equation that includes an exponential decay term and a cosine function. Participants are trying to determine the value of the damping coefficient "b" based on given parameters.

Discussion Character

  • Exploratory, Assumption checking, Problem interpretation

Approaches and Questions Raised

  • Participants discuss the nature of the equation and the implications of friction on oscillation periods. There are attempts to clarify the meaning of "clearing for b" and to understand how to manipulate the equation to isolate "b". Questions about the behavior of the system at specific times, particularly at t=0, are raised.

Discussion Status

The conversation is ongoing, with participants exploring different interpretations of the problem and clarifying terminology. Some guidance has been provided regarding the evaluation of the equation at t=0, but no consensus has been reached on the method to isolate "b".

Contextual Notes

There is a language barrier affecting the understanding of the problem, as terms from the original language may not translate directly to the correct mathematical terminology in English. The participants are working with specific values for A, m, k, and φ, but the exact relationship to find "b" remains unclear.

leomarrg
Messages
6
Reaction score
0
Homework Statement
Consider the movement of the mass and spring with friction
A * [e ^ - (b / 2m) t] * cos (sqrt (k / m - (b / 2m) ^ 2)) t + φ)
With A = 2m, k = 3N / m, m = 5Kg and φ = 0, we could change to the value of "b" from zero until the oscillations disappear for the first time and the function does not change to negative values. In this case, the friction now has a very noticeable effect: it lengthens the period of the oscillation so much that no oscillations will be seen (T -> infinity).
The theory indicates when that should happen. Clear for b from the equation and record the predicted value for b = .... (Kg / s) (at least two decimal places to the right of the point)
The question is complete, the exercise is clear for b, I don't get how to do it. The answer is 7.746
Relevant Equations
A * [e ^ - (b / 2m) t] * cos (sqrt (k / m - (b / 2m) ^ 2)) t + φ)
the equation is not equal not to anything (example: 3x = 6) and i don't know how to resolve [e ^ - (b / 2m) t].
 
Physics news on Phys.org
leomarrg said:
Homework Statement:: Consider the movement of the mass and spring with friction
A * [e ^ - (b / 2m) t] * cos (sqrt (k / m - (b / 2m) ^ 2)) t + φ)
With A = 2m, k = 3N / m, m = 5Kg and φ = 0, we could change to the value of "b" from zero until the oscillations disappear for the first time and the function does not change to negative values. In this case, the friction now has a very noticeable effect: it lengthens the period of the oscillation so much that no oscillations will be seen (T -> infinity).
The theory indicates when that should happen. Clear for b from the equation and record the predicted value for b = ... (Kg / s) (at least two decimal places to the right of the point)
The question is complete, the exercise is clear for b, I don't get how to do it. The answer is 7.746
Relevant Equations:: A * [e ^ - (b / 2m) t] * cos (sqrt (k / m - (b / 2m) ^ 2)) t + φ)
leomarrg said:
the equation is not equal not to anything
Then it's not an equation.
 
leomarrg said:
Homework Statement:: Consider the movement of the mass and spring with friction
A * [e ^ - (b / 2m) t] * cos (sqrt (k / m - (b / 2m) ^ 2)) t + φ)
With A = 2m, k = 3N / m, m = 5Kg and φ = 0, we could change to the value of "b" from zero until the oscillations disappear for the first time and the function does not change to negative values. In this case, the friction now has a very noticeable effect: it lengthens the period of the oscillation so much that no oscillations will be seen (T -> infinity).
The theory indicates when that should happen. Clear for b from the equation and record the predicted value for b = ... (Kg / s) (at least two decimal places to the right of the point)
The question is complete, the exercise is clear for b, I don't get how to do it. The answer is 7.746
Relevant Equations:: A * [e ^ - (b / 2m) t] * cos (sqrt (k / m - (b / 2m) ^ 2)) t + φ)

the equation is not equal not to anything (example: 3x = 6) and i don't know how to resolve [e ^ - (b / 2m) t].
Why does the friction change the period of oscillation? When the damped oscillator crosses zero, it is moving faster than at any other point since it last came instantaneously to rest. Yes, the period depends on bb but for a given bb it is constant.

What are you trying to find? If it is b, you need to know the position at some other time or the velocity at ##t=0##.
 
Last edited:
You have ##x(t)=Ae^{-{\frac{b}{m}t}}\cos(\omega t).## What do you get when you substitute ##t=0## in this expression?
 
kuruman said:
You have ##x(t)=Ae^{-{\frac{b}{m}t}}\cos(\omega t).## What do you get when you substitute ##t=0## in this expression?
I get 2
 
leomarrg said:
I get 2

That is incorrect. When you substitute ##t=0##, you get
##x(0)=Ae^{-\frac{b}{m}*0}\cos(\omega*0)##. What does that simplify to?
 
kuruman said:
That is incorrect. When you substitute ##t=0##, you get
##x(0)=Ae^{-\frac{b}{m}*0}\cos(\omega*0)##. What does that simplify to?
my bad, was using the data given in the exercise, A?
 
leomarrg said:
my bad, was using the data given in the exercise, A?
Write the equation to which the equation in post #6 simplifies. ##A## is not an equation.
 
kuruman said:
Write the equation to which the equation in post #6 simplifies. ##A## is not an equation.
x(0) = A?

e^−b/m * 0 = 1, and cos(w * 0) = 1
 
  • #10
leomarrg said:
x(0) = A?

e^−b/m * 0 = 1, and cos(w * 0) = 1
Yes. Now what? What is the question you want us to help you with?
 
  • #11
kuruman said:
Yes. Now what? What is the question you want us to help you with?
A * [e ^ - (b / 2m) t] * cos (sqrt (k / m - (b / 2m) ^ 2)) t + φ)
A = 2m, k = 3N / m, m = 5Kg and φ = 0
clearing this for b. The complete exercise is on the first question. If t = 0 then cos (sqrt (k / m - (b / 2m) ^ 2)) t is going to = 0. the answer is 7.746 but i don't know how to get there...
 
  • #12
I do not understand what "clearing this for b" means. Specifically, what does "clearing" mean and what "this" is that needs to be "cleared". Perhaps you can post an example in which something is "cleared" for b or whatever.
 
  • #13
kuruman said:
I do not understand what "clearing this for b" means. Specifically, what does "clearing" mean and what "this" is that needs to be "cleared". Perhaps you can post an example in which something is "cleared" for b or whatever.
I'm translating this question, it was given on a quiz it's original language is Spanish and i don't know if the correct term is clear for b, but essentially i want to know the value of b. That's what i mean by clear. Already have A, m, k, and φ
 
  • #14
The correct word is "solve" for b. OK, now that we have settled that, what do you know other than
##x(t)=Ae^{-\frac{b}{m}t}\cos(\omega t)## and the values for ##A##, ##m##, ##k## and ##\phi##?
 
Last edited:

Similar threads

  • · Replies 3 ·
Replies
3
Views
1K
Replies
5
Views
2K
  • · Replies 9 ·
Replies
9
Views
2K
  • · Replies 8 ·
Replies
8
Views
1K
Replies
17
Views
3K
  • · Replies 10 ·
Replies
10
Views
2K
  • · Replies 11 ·
Replies
11
Views
2K
  • · Replies 4 ·
Replies
4
Views
1K
  • · Replies 19 ·
Replies
19
Views
2K