What would be the speed of the approaching particle?

Join the discussion
Registration is free. Start your own thread to ask a follow-up.
3 replies · 1K views
anti quark
Messages
4
Reaction score
0
Suppose that 2 particles, A and B, which are far away, are traveling towards each other at a constant equal speed. From A's point of view, will b be having uniform or uniformly accelerated motion? Wouldn't that be same from B's point of view?
And what would happen if A and B are traveling at the speed of light? What would be the speed of the approaching particle then? (here, let's assume A and B are light itself)

Ok. So this was a random thought I had a few days ago..

Thanks in advance guys!
 
Physics news on Phys.org
In the first case, A will observe B to be moving uniformly at twice the velocity of the individual particles; the same would be true for B observing A. This is just Galilean relativity.

In the second case, if A and B are photons, each would observe the other to be traveling at the speed of light, with no doubling of the velocity. This comes from Einstein's postulate of special relativity which says that the observed speed of light is the same in all reference frames. To allow for this, it is the observed passage of time that changes between reference frames.
 
Ok, so in the second case, the passage of time for particle A would be changed?

According to special relativity, the closer we are to light speed, the slower time passes. So for the photon, time is still. Am I right?
 
sk1105 said:
In the second case, if A and B are photons, each would observe the other to be traveling at the speed of light
It is best to avoid describing what a photon experiences. The speed of light is not a valid reference frame. Photons do not experience the passage of time.
anti quark said:
According to special relativity, the closer we are to light speed, the slower time passes.
Yes. It is more meaingful to talk about what happens as we approach the limit.

anti quark said:
So for the photon, time is still. Am I right?
As above.

The best way to express this thought experiment is to discuss massive particles (not photons) moving at near the speed of light. Each particle will observe the other as approaching at near the speed of light.