What's is the best way to indicate a vector

  • Thread starter Thread starter SSDdefragger
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Vector
AI Thread Summary
The discussion centers around the various methods of indicating vectors in mathematical notation. The most common methods mentioned include using an arrow above the letter, underlining, and placing a bar on top. Many participants favor the arrow for its efficiency and clarity, noting that it is a standard practice in textbooks. Some express concerns about the potential clutter arrows can create when written quickly, while others prefer underlining or bolding for clarity in typed formats. A few participants recall professors using unique notations, such as tildes, which historically indicated a request for bold type in printed materials. Overall, preferences for vector notation seem to be influenced by individual teaching experiences and the need for quick, recognizable symbols in different contexts.
SSDdefragger
Messages
5
Reaction score
0
Personally I indicate vectors as a putting bar on a letter, but some people just underline it or put an arrow above it. What's your way of doing so?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
arrow on top. works perfectly!
 
I use the arrow and it seems like it's pretty standard notation from all of my textbooks to do it that way, so that's how I do it.
 
SSDdefragger said:
Personally I indicate vectors as a putting bar on a letter, but some people just underline it or put an arrow above it. What's your way of doing so?

Arrow for me, too. Bar on top is also used for the average/mean.
 
I am looking for time efficient and yet easily recognizable and good looking method. Any suggestions?
 
Most of us use the arrow on the top, i don't see a more time efficient method. What do you have in mind? What do you feel is comfortable?
 
It is too tedious to do so, and if you are going too fast they become like an mess on the top of a bar. Arrows are definitely not the best choice for me.
 
Arrow on top. If the arrow is going to get in the way, I capitalize and doublestrike one of the strokes, or bold the lowercase.
 
I also use an arrow on top, I don't see how it can be more time efficient or more easily recognizable.

But instead of an arrow like this --> with a v-shaped head I only give it one stroke to the top like in this picture:
0.jpg


An arrow like this is done in 1 smooth pen-movement, yet obvious and neat.
 
  • Like
Likes Suraj M
  • #10
What people prefer will probably depend on how they were taught in the past.

I always use underlining (W = Fx) in handwriting and bold non-italic font \left( W = \textbf{F} \cdot \textbf{x} \right) when typing.

I've also seen lecturers use a "wavy underline" something like this:

x
~​
 
  • #11
A vector arrow (with arrowhead) is drawn in a specified direction. The vector arrow has a head and a tail.
 
  • Like
Likes nuuskur and Silicon Waffle
  • #12
I give each of them a thought bubble that says "I'm a vector."
 
  • Like
Likes Blackberg
  • #13
That depends on the purpose. What I use:
Calculate something quickly on paper/whiteboard: usually no special mark, unless it would be really confusing without, then they get an arrow (a real one or the one from post 9).
Write something down: \vec: ##\vec{a}##.
 
  • #14
Surprised no one chimed in with "use an [abstract] index": ##v^a##
(Oh, this isn't the Relativity forum :) )
 
  • #15
robphy said:
Surprised no one chimed in with "use an [abstract] index": ##v^a##
(Oh, this isn't the Relativity forum :) )
If we're going to go down that route, there is Dirac notation |\psi\rangle. (Oh, this isn't the Quantum Physics forum.)

And some do not use any special notation at all, using the same typography for vectors and scalars alike. (Oh, this isn't the Linear Algebra forum.)
 
  • #16
I took a class in elasticity in 1982, and the professor always used a curly symbol (a tilda) over the symbols (letters.) which were vectors. I never asked him why, but he was in the minority of the professors who used arrows, bars, over or under the letters. Five years later I was taking electromagnetics with a professor who also used the tildas above the letters. I never asked him about the notation, but one day, he volunteered why he did this.
It seems like in the old days, the tilde over the symbol indicated a request to the (printer) or typesetter to "use bold-faced type". He told me he could send his notes directly to a printer if he so desired, since by learning to use this notation, he was automatically preparing his manuscript to be printed.
 

Similar threads

Replies
3
Views
826
Replies
48
Views
4K
Replies
13
Views
4K
Replies
14
Views
2K
Replies
7
Views
2K
Back
Top