When the integral of total derivative[tex] \oint d U = 0 [/tex]?,

  • Level: Graduate 
  • Thread starter Thread starter alejandrito29
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Integral
Join the discussion
Registration is free. Start your own thread to ask a follow-up.
8 replies · 4K views
alejandrito29
Messages
148
Reaction score
0
when the integral of total derivative[tex]\oint d U = 0[/tex]?,

when the integral of total derivative
[tex]\oint d U = 0[/tex]?, and ¿why is zero?

and,

when

[tex]\oint d U \neq 0[/tex] ??
 
Physics news on Phys.org


Alex: are you integrating the identity? And, what is the region over which you are
integrating?
 


The closed line integral dU = 0 if dU is an exact differential. U is then a state function and by definition if you end up where you started you get zero.

Think of a closed line integral of gravitational or electrostatic force.
 


An example , a classical one, I think, of a form that is not exact is that of w=dz/z

defined on the circle |z|=1, embedded in R-{(0,0)}, or C-{(0,0)} .
 


Bacle said:
Alex: are you integrating the identity? And, what is the region over which you are
integrating?

my problem is

[tex]\oint d( \frac{dA}{dy} exp(A) )[/tex]

where [tex]A=|y|[/tex]
but, y is a angular coordinate...between [tex])-\infty, \infty([/tex]
but my problem is that
[tex]\frac{d|y|}{dy} = -1 , y \in )-\pi,0(, )\pi,2\pi(, etc[/tex]
[tex]\frac{d|y|}{dy} = 1 , y \in )0,\pi(, )2\pi,3\pi(, etc[/tex]
[tex]\frac{d|y|}{dy} = undefinided , y =-\pi,0,\pi...k \cdot \pi[/tex]
........................
but, if i integrate

[tex]\oint exp(|y|)[/tex] ¿why is it Non zero, if i too started and end in the same point (0 and 2pi por example)
 
Last edited:


Alex:
By a theorem; I think Stokes or one of its corollaries, your last integral equals zero iff , f (exp|y| , in our case) as a differential form, is exact, or, equivalently, if there is an F
in the region of definition, with dF= exp|y|.

I'm sorry, I still don't fully understand why y is positive in some regions, and negative in others. Do you have an explicit formula for it?

Still, if you know that your y is defined as you said, the only reason I can see for why
it is not zero, is that , it does not have a global antiderivative.
 


question :

can i to say [tex]d \theta = \frac{1}{x^2+y^2} (-y dx +x dy )[/tex]
since i am to integrate on a circle, and , since

[tex]x = 1 \cdot \cos (\theta) ; y = 1 \cdot \sin (\theta)[/tex]

and then

[tex]\oint e^{|\theta|} d \theta = \oint e^{| \sin^{-1} y|} \frac{1}{x^2+y^2} (-y dx +x dy ) \neq 0[/tex] , since is not globally defined in [tex]x, y = 0,0[/tex] ?
 
Last edited:


The standard way (the one I know : ) ) of doing line integrals/ contour integration is
by parametrizing the contour:

x=cosθ , so that dx=cosθdθ

y=sinθ , so that dy=sinθdθ

And then integrate from 0 to 2∏ ; since the singularity happens at (0,0), which is
not in the contour, you don't need to worry about this. Still, another way of testing
whether:

dθ:= (xdy -ydy)/(x2+y2)

is exact, is by integrating around a close contour. If the form is exact, it would then
integrate to 0, by an extension of the fundamental theorem of calculus.
 


firts , sorry by many questions,

in my case, i need to integrate on te circle

but in a text says:

[tex](xdy -ydy)/(x^ 2+y^ 2)[/tex] it is not exact, since its integral along the unit circle is not 0... [tex]\int ^\pi_{-\pi} d\theta = 2 \pi[/tex]...
this is a argument for says that [tex]\oint e^{|\theta|} d\theta[/tex] is not zero??