Which is Better for Gaming: Xbox 360 or PC?

Click For Summary

Discussion Overview

The discussion centers around the comparison of gaming performance between the Xbox 360 and a specified personal computer. Participants explore various aspects of gaming capabilities, hardware specifications, and the intended use of each platform.

Discussion Character

  • Debate/contested
  • Technical explanation
  • Exploratory

Main Points Raised

  • One participant argues that the Xbox 360 is superior for gaming because it is specifically designed for that purpose, while PCs serve multiple functions beyond gaming.
  • Another participant suggests that high-end gaming rigs are necessary for faithful emulation of modern consoles, implying that not all PCs can match the performance of the Xbox 360 without significant investment.
  • There is a challenge to specify a PC configuration that could outperform the Xbox 360, with one participant suggesting that it would require top-tier components such as dual SLI graphics cards and high-performance processors.
  • One participant expresses a personal opinion that the Xbox is better for gaming, citing the limitations of the graphics card in the discussed PC.
  • A comparison is made regarding input methods, with one participant stating that a mouse and keyboard setup is superior to the Xbox 360 controller for gaming.
  • There is mention of the PlayStation 3 as a competitor to the Xbox 360, with some participants expressing differing views on its performance relative to the Xbox.

Areas of Agreement / Disagreement

Participants do not reach a consensus, as there are multiple competing views regarding the superiority of the Xbox 360 versus the PC for gaming. Some participants firmly support the Xbox 360, while others highlight the potential of high-end PCs.

Contextual Notes

The discussion includes varying assumptions about hardware capabilities and gaming performance, with no definitive specifications provided for the PC that could match or exceed the Xbox 360's gaming performance.

Tom McCurdy
Messages
1,021
Reaction score
1
Alright I am having an argumetn about the xb0x 360 vs my computer

who is better for gamming
and more powerful

my comp

ADAPTER: Universal AC-DC Adapter
BATTERY: Li-Ion Battery Pack 14.8V x 4400mAH 4 hours Runtime
CPU: Intel(R) Pentium(R) M Processor 760 @ 2.0GHz 533FSB 2MB Cache ~ CNB812 [+60]
CD: 16X/4X CD-RW/DVD+RW COMBO DRIVE [+90]
FLASHMEDIA: Built-In 3in1 Media Reader
HDD: 80GB 5400RPM ULTRA ATA 100 HARD DRIVE [+21]
INVERTER: NONE
IEEE_CARD: BUILT-IN 1394 IEEE FIREWIRE PORT
KEYBOARD: BUILT-IN KEYBOARD
MOUSE: BUILT-IN TOUCHPAD
MODEM: BUILT-IN 56K V.92 FAX MODEM
MOTHERBOARD: Intel Alviso 915PM & ICH6-M Chipset Mainboard
MEMORY: 1GB PC4200 DDR2-533 SODIMM MEMORY [+82]
MONITOR: 15.4" WSXGA TFT LCD DISPLAY 1680x1050
MP3PLAYER: NONE
NB_TRAVELKIT: NONE
NB_HEADSET: NONE
NOTEBOOK_COVER: Xplorer S4-5500 Notebook Cover (ORIGINAL SILVER COLOR)
NETWORK: BUILT-IN 10/100 NETWORK CARD
OS: Microsoft(R) Windows(R) XP Professional w/ Service Pack 2 [+46]
PCMCIA: (1)Type II PCMCIA 32-Bit PC Card Bus
PRINTER: None
PRINTER_CABLE: None
RUSH: NO; READY TO SHIP IN 5~10 BUSINESS DAYS
SCANNER: NONE
SERVICE: STANDARD 1-YEAR LIMITED WARRANTY + 24/7 PHONE SUPPORT
SOFT: Microsoft(R) Works 7.0
SOUND: BUILT-IN AC 97 SOUND
SPEAKERS: BUILT-IN STEREO SPEAKERS SYSTEM
UPS: None
USB: 3 x USB2.0 PORT CONNECTORS
USB_PENDRIVE: NONE
VIDEOCAMERA: NONE
VIDEO: 16X PCI-Express NVIDIA Geforce GO 6600 128MB Video
WIRELESSPOINT: NONE
WIRELESSCARD: Intel PRO2915 A/B/G Wireless 802.11G 54Mbs MiniPCI Card [+3]


vs xbox 360
 
Computer science news on Phys.org
Xbox 360, no question. PC's are meant to do a LOT of things, gaming just being one of them. It must do word processing, handle an operating system, be highly adaptable, run god knows how many different languages and protocols... etc etc. The xbox 360 is made ONLY for games thus it will blow away almost any computer.
 
Take a look at http://forums.ngemu.com/pcsx2-official-forum/25836-problems-ps2-emulators.html to see why completely faithful emulation of modern consoles on a PC requires a high-end gaming rig.
 
sdf

Spec out a machine that would beat a 360
 
Tom McCurdy said:
Spec out a machine that would beat a 360

You're probably talking about ... top end dual SLI 7800GTX's and dual cores and raptors and insane stuff like that. I mean you're asking for a tow-truck that could outdo a ferrari while at the same time still being able to haul cars all over the place...
 
In my opinion, Xbox prevails over your computer for gaming purposes only. Your graphics card gives it all away.

The real question though is how PS3, the real nemesis of Xbox, will differ. Some say it'll be better, others disagree and argue it down. What are the differences?
 
Mouse + key board > XBox 360 controller