Why are astronauts weightless?

  • Thread starter Forge
  • Start date
If they're orbiting Earth, then they're in uniform circular motion. And if they're in uniform circular motion, then they experience a centripetal force (and thus centripetal acceleration) towards the center of Earth. Therefore, they are constantly accelerating (direction changes, magnitude does not change) and you can feel acceleration but it appears that they do not feel any force.
 

HallsofIvy

Science Advisor
Homework Helper
41,683
865
You don't have to go into orbit to be weightless. If you were to go to the "Burj Al Arab" in Dubai, the tallest building on earth, and jump of the top, you would be weightless- until you hit the ground! The force of gravity would still be acting on you but you would not feel any weight because there is nothing pusing up on you.

When astronauts are in orbit, the force of gravity is acting on them and their ship equally. Astronauts and ship are all falling toward the center of the earth. There is no "floor" or "ground" pushing up on them so they feel no weight.
 

jtbell

Mentor
15,334
3,041
You don't have to go into orbit to be weightless. If you were to go to the "Burj Al Arab" in Dubai, the tallest building on earth, and jump of the top, you would be weightless- until you hit the ground!
Or for a safer experience, arrange a ride on the "Vomit Comet". :smile:
 

A.T.

Science Advisor
9,568
1,469
you can feel acceleration but it appears that they do not feel any force.
What you usually feel as a force, is the deformation of your body caused by it. The special thing about the force of gravity is that is is proportional to mass, so it is accelerating small objects almost uniformly, without causing significant deformations. There fore you don't feel it, if it the only force acting on you.
 
When astronauts are in orbit, the force of gravity is acting on them and their ship equally.
So relative to the frame of reference of the ship, the astronauts appear to be weightless, but they are not actually weightless. However, do the astronauts not feel the pull of the force? If you're in an zero-acceleration frame of reference, you cannot tell what velocity you are traveling at. However if you're in an accelerating frame of reference, can't you feel that you are accelerating?

What you usually feel as a force, is the deformation of your body caused by it. The special thing about the force of gravity is that is is proportional to mass, so it is accelerating small objects almost uniformly, without causing significant deformations. There fore you don't feel it, if it the only force acting on you.
So because the force is proportional to mass, the acceleration is constant, right? Doesn't gravity acceleration both small and large objects almost uniformly?
 

A.T.

Science Advisor
9,568
1,469
So because the force is proportional to mass, the acceleration is constant, right? Doesn't gravity acceleration both small and large objects almost uniformly?
If free falling objects are small enough, so gravity gradient is negligible, they are accelerated uniformly along their volume. You cannot "feel" such acceleration, because it doesn't create deformation.
 

Bandersnatch

Science Advisor
2,821
1,663
If all parts of your body are accelerated uniformly, as it happens in the gravitational field(caveat: far away from the source), then no, you can't.

Human beings perceive linear acceleration mostly via the otholitic organ in the inner ear. In it, suspended in viscous fluid are small crystals. Since the crystals are not rigidly connected to the rest of the body, whenever your head experiences acceleration they lag behind the bulk of your tissues due to inertia. Their displacement bends the tiny hairs lining the walls of the organ. These hairs are connected to nerves that then transmit the signal to your brain.

Another, similar in principle, way we feel acceleration is via kinesthesia. I.e., the relative position of our limbs, that also changes due to inertia, as long as the accelerating force is applied non-uniformly.

If the force permeats the space in uniform fashion, all parts of your body change their velocities at the same rate, so neither the crystals in your inner ear, nor your limbs ever lag behind, and so, never produce a neural response in your brain.

So, in a way, one could say you never really feel gravity, even sitting in your chair. It's the ground pushing the chair pushing on your bottom parts that disrupts the uniform acceleration of the gravity, providing localised force that then is transferred to the rest of your body through the tissues, with inertial lag across the board.



Now, IF you are close to the source of gravity, the parts of your body farther from the source experience less acceleration(inverse square law) than the closer ones. These are tidal forces that you could feel as being stretched along one axis and compressed along the two other, providing your total length is significant as compared to the distance to the source and its strength(effect also known under the scientific term of spaghettification).
 
5,598
39
forget about what people may 'feel'....that's too subjective. [I assume you are interested in the physics, not 'feelings']

So relative to the frame of reference of the ship, the astronauts appear to be weightless, but they are not actually weightless. However, do the astronauts not feel the pull of the force? If you're in an zero-acceleration frame of reference, you cannot tell what velocity you are traveling at. However if you're in an accelerating frame of reference, can't you feel that you are accelerating?
The astronauts 'appear' weightless because they ARE actually weightless. Have you ever seen pictures??...they' float' inside a space station and so does, say, a tool they release. Things maintain their relative positions inside...like in free fall because it IS freefall. Everything nearby floats because there are no net forces. An accelerometer shows no acceleration.

[In the context of General Relativity gravitation is space-time curvature and a body in free fall has no force acting on it as it moves along a geodesic.....a particular type curve in spacetime.]


Some interesting Newtonian [not GR] comments here:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Weightlessness
 
1,506
17
The astronauts 'appear' weightless because they ARE actually weightless. Have you ever seen pictures??...they' float' inside a space station and so does, say, a tool they release. Things maintain their relative positions inside...like in free fall because it IS freefall. Everything nearby floats because there are no net forces. An accelerometer shows no acceleration.

It depends on what you mean by 'weightless'
If 'weight' is the force due to gravity then they are NOT weightless. There is a resultant force on the astronaut and the spacecraft....centripetal force.

How do you 'experience'/'feel' (this is not subjective) weight?....It is the upwards force on your feet/backside as indicated on a weighing machine. The astronaut experiences no force between himself/herself and any weighing machine.
They EXPERIENCE weightlessness

A fish 'floats' in water....is it weightless....does a fish experience the force due to gravity?...have you seen pictures of fish floating....there ARE NO NET forces on a fish !!!!
What is the difference between a fish and an astronaut??

Draw a freebody diagram of forces on an astronaut and forces on a fish...use this diagram to explain 'weightlessness' (do not refer to GR)
 
Last edited:

A.T.

Science Advisor
9,568
1,469
Everything nearby floats because there are no net forces.
The astronaut is undergoing centripetal acceleration, so there obviously is a net force on him. Bringing GR into it will probably just confuse the OP.
 
1,506
17
forget about what people may 'feel'....that's too subjective. [I assume you are interested in the physics, not 'feelings']



The astronauts 'appear' weightless because they ARE actually weightless. Have you ever seen pictures??...they' float' inside a space station and so does, say, a tool they release. Things maintain their relative positions inside...like in free fall because it IS freefall. Everything nearby floats because there are no net forces. An accelerometer shows no acceleration.

[In the context of General Relativity gravitation is space-time curvature and a body in free fall has no force acting on it as it moves along a geodesic.....a particular type curve in spacetime.]


Some interesting Newtonian [not GR] comments here:


http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Weightlessness
These are ridiculous statements, completely contrary to conventional teaching and text book explanations.
This is not physics !!!!
Someone with some authority should check posts like this.
 

Drakkith

Staff Emeritus
Science Advisor
2018 Award
20,563
4,274
Someone with some authority should check posts like this.
This is a forum, not a scientific journal. We don't really appeal to an authority. If you feel someones post is incorrect, then correct them. If you are right, then you're right.
 
79
6
There is a difference between mass and weight I think that's what he is missing.
 
1,506
17
The rules of these forums dictate that posts should be in line with current/text book explanations.
What is stated here is plane wrong........ in my opinion.
As far as I understand it these are not 'opinion' forums
Anything else should be backed up by some sort of references that can be checked.
The 'report' option is only for spam, advertising, etc.
 
79
6
The rules of these forums dictate that posts should be in line with current/text book explanations.
What is stated here is plane wrong........ in my opinion.
As far as I understand it these are not 'opinion' forums
Anything else should be backed up by some sort of references that can be checked.
The 'report' option is only for spam, advertising, etc.
It's not really wrong, they are [just about] weightless in microgravity. Their mass doesn't change but their weight changes with gravity.
 
Don't astronauts feel weightless due to the equivalence principle? Technically, above earth, in space, the gravity is around 9/10 as strong as on the ground. The reason that causes weightlessness is because the station astronauts are in, is travelling so fast that the earth curves away under the ship. So they are not weightless, they are constantly falling, but due to the speed of their orbit, the earth curves away below them just as fast that they never seem to fall relative to the ship: thus, causing what they feel as weightlessness.
 
1,506
17
What is 'microgravity'...cant find it in the index of my text book !!!!
How does weight change with gravity (I think I have the answer to this but I am interested in your view)
 
1,506
17
juzzagon....you are not wrong
 

A.T.

Science Advisor
9,568
1,469
Don't astronauts feel weightless due to the equivalence principle?
That's just a another way to say the same thing:

force proportional to mass -> force can be seen as an inertial force -> equivalence principle
 

A.T.

Science Advisor
9,568
1,469
It's not really wrong, .
It's not really wrong, in the context of GR. That should be made clear, otherwise it will confuse.

The general explanation (Newton or GR): Gravity is a force (real or inertial) that accelerates everything by the same amount. So it doesn't cause deformation of the body and cannot be felt.
 
1,506
17
What's the difference between
1) a fish floating
2) A skydiver with parachute not open
3) A skydiver with parachute open
4) A passenger in a free falling lift
5) an astronaut in the space station

Which of the above could be described as 'weightless'?
 
79
6
It doesn't matter if the reason is they are falling constantly the net gravity is near zero and therefore they are just about weightless. I am not sure if LEO is 9/10ths when your not at the right speed (zero instead of 17,000 mph or so depending on alt). Either way it is irrelevant because the net force is basically null.
 

A.T.

Science Advisor
9,568
1,469
It doesn't matter if the reason is they are falling constantly the net gravity is near zero
What is "net gravity" and how do you compute it exactly for an orbiting astronaut?
 
1,506
17
When is 'net gravity' near to zero.?
When is the net force basically null?

You need to make statements like this absolutely clear.....
 
1,506
17
From post #8 this has degenerated into .....I do not know.....it is time for someone to close this thread.
I am not coming back.
 

Related Threads for: Why are astronauts weightless?

Replies
6
Views
5K
  • Posted
Replies
5
Views
669
Replies
3
Views
700
Replies
10
Views
7K

Physics Forums Values

We Value Quality
• Topics based on mainstream science
• Proper English grammar and spelling
We Value Civility
• Positive and compassionate attitudes
• Patience while debating
We Value Productivity
• Disciplined to remain on-topic
• Recognition of own weaknesses
• Solo and co-op problem solving
Top