Why can't appendicitis be treated with just antibiotics?

In summary, the person had appendicitis and it woke them up with pain and nausea. The pain was at a 4 on a scale of 1 to 10 and the nausea was at a 6. They took pepto-bismol for the nausea and despite the fact that it had salicylic acid which is the prodrug of aspirin and releives pain by affecting genetic expression of the COX enzyme, it didn't help with the pain. The pain was at a 6 and approaching an 8 and the only clue that the doctors had was that the person was nauseous and in pain at a steady 6. The CT scan showed an infection at the tip of the appendix with the rest of the appendix looking normal. The person had an append
  • #1
caters
229
9
I started having appendicitis 3 nights ago. It woke me up from sleep with lots of pain and nausea. I took pepto-bismol for the nausea but despite the fact that it had salicylic acid which is the prodrug of aspirin and releives pain by affecting genetic expression of the COX enzyme that forms prostaglandins, it didn't help with the pain at all. The pain was low when I went back to sleep(about a 4 on a scale of 1 to 10, bad enough that I knew something was up, but not so bad I couldn't sleep. My momma told my dad that I was worried that this pain was appendicitis.

My right lower quadrant was also very tender. I woke up with pain that was even worse. It was at a 6 and approaching an 8. I was on the verge of crying in pain. I texted my dad and then woke up my momma and went to the hospital. They did a bunch of tests, all of which except the C reactive protein and CT were normal, even my temperature was normal.

The only clue that they had from the exam was that I was nauseous and in pain at a steady 6 with tenderness and guarding. The CT scan showed an infection at the tip of my appendix with the rest of the appendix looking normal. This meant that I was in a very early stage of appendicitis.

I stayed in the hospital for the night and had an appendectomy done the next morning. They did it laproscopically because my appendix was intact. The nausea and other symptoms went away after I woke up from the anesthesia. My throat was and still is sore because they had to put a breathing tube in while they were taking out my appendix.

When I went home that evening I immediately threw up which is normal after an appendectomy. I only threw up once and my stomach calmed down in minutes.

It is kind of a shame that the appendix is known by scientists to help recolonise the digestive system with good bacteria after vomiting or having diarrhea, yet appendicitis still has to be treated with an appendectomy.

Why can't appendicitis just be treated with antibiotics or if the appendix is obstructed, a colonoscopy be done to take out the obstruction that is causing the appendicitis? I mean, that sounds much better than getting rid of your appendix and I could still do situps or swim afterwards without waiting for a week or 2 until my abdomen heals. Nevertheless, despite there being some successes with just antibiotics(and I bet a lot of those are with people in early appendicitis like I was), most doctors agree that even in early appendicitis, appendectomy is the way to go.
 
Biology news on Phys.org
  • #2
I am not a doctor, but many sources suggest that most cases of appendicitis can be treated only with antibiotics (e.g. see http://www.webmd.com/digestive-diso...citis-can-often-be-treated-with-antibiotics#1). However, doctors and the hospitals they work for probably get paid more for appendectomy than for prescribing antibiotics. Many have argued these perverse incentives are why the healthcare costs in the US are vastly higher than in other countries (see for example, http://www.nytimes.com/2013/06/02/h...ld-in-health-expenditures.html?pagewanted=all)
 
  • Like
Likes Steelwolf
  • #3
I suspect a factor is the danger that the appendix will burst, that is, have structural damage that antibiotics cannot repair. If that happens, the abdominal cavity is flooded with bacteria and you are in serious trouble.
 
  • Like
Likes Steelwolf
  • #4
caters said:
I stayed in the hospital for the night and had an appendectomy done the next morning. They did it laproscopically because my appendix was intact. The nausea and other symptoms went away after I woke up from the anesthesia. My throat was and still is sore because they had to put a breathing tube in while they were taking out my appendix.
Very glad that you are okay now, @caters :smile: And yeah, the sore throat from the intubation is very common.
 
  • Like
Likes Steelwolf
  • #5
If people KNOW what it is that is bothering them then they can get effective treatment often involving a goodly run of antibiotics. However, that being said, most people are generally clueless about most things medical and do not know specific signs of such problem: They rely on doctors to tell them what is wrong. Thus, by the time the Problem is far enough along and the person reports, generally to a Hospital, the infection has progressed enough that the appendix is enlarged, inflamed and usually well along the infection arc, so it is easiest, as well as most expedient, to remove the appendix at this point. I had that happen to me in the Navy, and even though I Knew it was appendicitis it was hard convincing the Navy Docs till my fever went thru the roof, for sure it was no fun experience, thank you! I certainly feel for you Caters, hope you heal quickly and get back on your feet and to doing active things again. Be Safe, Be Well!
 
  • #6
Appendicitis can be treated with antibiotics and this has been a regular subject of studies, generally the results are inconsistent. Its generally thought that a blockage precedes the infection and so recurrence is more likely, interestingly as the infection worsens and an abdominal mass can be felt the usual management is antibiotics followed by surgery. There seems to be support for using antibiotics as first line treatment in children but generally until the evidence becomes clearer, surgery is considered the gold standard in most countries. For a little light reading;
https://www.evidence.nhs.uk/search?q=appendicitis+antibiotics
 

Related to Why can't appendicitis be treated with just antibiotics?

1. Why can't appendicitis be treated with just antibiotics?

Appendicitis is a condition in which the appendix becomes inflamed and infected, often leading to severe abdominal pain. Antibiotics are effective in treating infections, but they are not sufficient to treat appendicitis.

2. Can't antibiotics kill the bacteria causing appendicitis?

While antibiotics can kill the bacteria causing the infection, they cannot remove the inflamed and infected appendix, which is the root cause of appendicitis. Surgery is necessary to remove the appendix to completely treat appendicitis.

3. What happens if appendicitis is left untreated?

If appendicitis is left untreated, the inflamed appendix can burst, causing the infection to spread to the abdominal cavity. This can lead to a life-threatening condition called peritonitis, which requires immediate surgery and antibiotics to treat.

4. Are there any cases where antibiotics alone can treat appendicitis?

In rare cases, antibiotics may be used as a temporary treatment for appendicitis, especially if the patient is unable to undergo surgery immediately. However, surgery is still necessary to remove the inflamed appendix and prevent future episodes of appendicitis.

5. Can lifestyle changes prevent appendicitis?

While there is no definitive evidence that lifestyle changes can prevent appendicitis, maintaining a healthy diet and regular exercise may help to reduce the risk of developing the condition. However, appendicitis can occur in anyone, regardless of their lifestyle habits.

Similar threads

  • Biology and Medical
9
Replies
287
Views
20K
Replies
1
Views
4K
Replies
2
Views
3K
  • General Discussion
2
Replies
44
Views
25K
  • General Discussion
26
Replies
895
Views
88K
  • Biology and Medical
Replies
6
Views
3K
  • General Discussion
Replies
34
Views
7K
Replies
2
Views
7K
Replies
2
Views
2K
  • General Discussion
2
Replies
44
Views
13K
Back
Top