Why do certain objects reflect certain colors and not others?

  • Context: High School 
  • Thread starter Thread starter alex7245
  • Start date Start date
Click For Summary

Discussion Overview

The discussion revolves around why certain objects reflect specific colors (wavelengths) while absorbing others. Participants explore the relationship between the physical properties of materials and their interaction with light, including concepts of reflection, absorption, and the nature of color perception.

Discussion Character

  • Exploratory
  • Technical explanation
  • Debate/contested

Main Points Raised

  • Some participants propose that the emissivity of a material as a function of wavelength determines which colors are reflected.
  • Others discuss how the absorption and reflection of light relate to the molecular structure of materials, with specific examples like pigments in a red ball and the properties of thin films in soap bubbles.
  • A participant highlights the complexity of color perception, noting that the human-centric view of red, green, and blue may not encompass the full spectrum of visible light.
  • There is mention of the role of atomic bonds in determining which wavelengths are absorbed, with examples of different carbon structures like diamond and graphite illustrating this point.
  • Some participants express confusion about the fundamental criteria that dictate an object's color, seeking a deeper understanding of the underlying physics.
  • Discussion includes the impact of thickness on light reflection and refraction in materials like glass.

Areas of Agreement / Disagreement

Participants generally agree that the reflection and absorption of colors are related to the physical and chemical properties of materials. However, there are multiple competing views on the specifics of how these properties interact with light, and the discussion remains unresolved regarding the fundamental criteria behind these phenomena.

Contextual Notes

Some participants note the ambiguity in the original question, indicating that the relationship between color and material properties can be complex and multifaceted, involving both molecular and physical factors.

alex7245
Messages
2
Reaction score
0
How come certain objects reflect certain colours (wavelengths) but not others?
What is the relationship between the wavelength and the object? I approached my physics teacher and he had no answer and i have been desprete to get and answer, I've checked all over the internet to find one and came out with nothing. All i got was reflection, refraction and defraction, but this still didnt really answer my question

Will be great for an answer
Alex
 
Science news on Phys.org
alex7245 said:
How come certain objects reflect certain colours (wavelengths) but not others?
What is the relationship between the wavelength and the object? I approached my physics teacher and he had no answer and i have been desprete to get and answer, I've checked all over the internet to find one and came out with nothing. All i got was reflection, refraction and defraction, but this still didnt really answer my question

Will be great for an answer
Alex

If the emissivity is a function of wavelength (alternatively, the absorption or transmission), the material will reflect certain colors.

Although we do not yet have a detailed microscopic description that allows us to predict the color a material will appear, we do know a few things: why gold and copper look different than silver, for example.
 
Are you asking how you see an object as red? Or are you asking why does a red object absorb blue and green (and all other wavelengths), but not red?

You see an object as being a certain color b/c it's absorbing all the colors that it isn't reflecting... Okay, that's obviously circular... but here's what i mean... There are additive colors which are in the form of "light" and there are subtractive colors, which are "objects" or pigments. Take the example of using red, green and blue lights in the proper ratio to give white (sort of white, let's not get into the issue about color reproduction with RGB, and it's not 1:1:1 in terms of optical power, it's only 1:1:1 if you account for how our eyes respond to different wavelengths, which units like lumen and candella take that response into account, so 100 lumens of 550nm appears as bright as 100 lumens of 650nm, but the 550nm is less optical power). Anyhow, if you aim "white" light at an object and it appears red, then that roughly means the object is absorbing blue and green (and everything else other than red) so all that's left to "leave" the object is red.

It can get complicated though b/c reproducing colors isn't really as simple as, "all you need to make any color is RGB." but I'm not going to get into that.


Is that what you are asking, why do we see a red object? Or, are you asking the harder question to answer, "How/Why does the red object absorb blue and green, but not red?" (anything I've ever read just says things like, "The phsyical properties of an object determine what colors are absorbed."

Talking about lumens and optical power got me thinking once again that even with all the advancements in high output flourescents, LEDs, and even unconventional microwave-sulfur lamps, we're still very inefficient at creating light. Even the most efficient light sources (like LOW pressure sodium) are around 200 lm/watt, but yet 1 watt of luminous power is over 600 lumens at 555nm.
 
Yes, Alex your question is ambiguous. There are myriad reasons why objects reflect different colours.

For example a red ball is red because it contains red pigements. The pigments are molecules that preferentially absorb most wavelengths except in the red band. Centuries of experimentation has lead us to these few chemical pigments that are pure and stable.

Other objects, such as soap bubbles and oil slicks, have physical properties (thin films) that have effects on colours - the light rays interfere with erach other and cancel out or are reinforced.
 
Last edited:
mp3car said:
Or are you asking why does a red object absorb blue and green (and all other wavelengths), but not red?

It is important to point out that the red/green/blue distinction of light's components is completely human-centric.

We think that red, green and blue are all you need to make the entire rainbow because we have red, green and blue receptors. If all three are stimulated, presto, we see white light.

This is a very narrow view of visible light though.

There is an inifinite range of colours making up light white.
 
Typically, if a particular wavelength is not being reflected, it means that there is an electron somewhere in the substance at the surface that can go to an excited state with the amount of energy equal to the energy of a photon with a given wavelength. But it can be a lot more complicated than that as well.
 
Sorry i didn't make it clear enough, i find it hard to define what i mean :D, i know that objects absorb certain wavelengths and reflect other wavelengths and that's why we see colours.. i want to know the fundimental reason, exactly what are the criteria of an object that allows certain wavelengths to be absorbed and reflect certain wavelengths
I hope this has made it a little more clear to understand
Alex
 
alex7245 said:
Sorry i didn't make it clear enough, i find it hard to define what i mean :D, i know that objects absorb certain wavelengths and reflect other wavelengths and that's why we see colours.. i want to know the fundimental reason, exactly what are the criteria of an object that allows certain wavelengths to be absorbed and reflect certain wavelengths
I hope this has made it a little more clear to understand
Alex

Ah. Certain molecules have atomic bonds that will absorb certain wavelengths of photon.

A molecule might have a bond between two atoms that has some "wiggle-room" to it - the bond might twist or vibrate easily if given a certain kick. That kick will have to match a certain quantum of energy, for example, it might only absorb a photon that's 550nm.
 
  • #10
yes like dave is saying it has to do with the bonds , like diamond will let all colors of light
go through it but graphite will not and they are both made of carbon but there bonds are different , you could make it more complicated by looking at what happens when light hits glass , will it get reflected or go into the glass and get refracted , it turns out it also depends on the thickness of the glass , if you make it thicker you could makes less reflect , but you make it thicker and you could get more to reflect and it keeps going back and fourth when you make the glass thicker .
 

Similar threads

  • · Replies 10 ·
Replies
10
Views
2K
  • · Replies 1 ·
Replies
1
Views
1K
  • · Replies 3 ·
Replies
3
Views
3K
  • · Replies 10 ·
Replies
10
Views
3K
  • · Replies 7 ·
Replies
7
Views
6K
  • · Replies 5 ·
Replies
5
Views
3K
  • · Replies 2 ·
Replies
2
Views
3K
  • · Replies 1 ·
Replies
1
Views
3K
  • · Replies 7 ·
Replies
7
Views
2K