I Why does general relativity break down at high energies?

  • I
  • Thread starter Thread starter KleinMoretti
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    General relaivity
KleinMoretti
Messages
112
Reaction score
5
TL;DR Summary
what does it mean for general relativity to break down at high energies
more specifically what does high energies mean in this context, does it actually mean a high amount of energy? I can intuitively understand why it breaks down at small scales where quantum effects take place. for example it is said that high speed collisions produce a lot of energy and general relativity will break down as (part) of the description of such collisions, but why is that
 
Physics news on Phys.org
KleinMoretti said:
what does it mean for general relativity to break down at high energies
Why do you think it does?

KleinMoretti said:
it is said
Where? Please give a reference.
 
  • Like
Likes Vanadium 50
PeterDonis said:
Why do you think it does?
isn't it said that one of the reasons a theory of quantum gravity is needed is because GR breaks down at some point for example singularities
 
KleinMoretti said:
isn't it said
Said where? Again, please give a reference.
 
  • Like
Likes Vanadium 50
KleinMoretti said:
one of the reasons a theory of quantum gravity is needed is because GR breaks down at some point for example singularities
That is a reason that is given for looking for a theory of quantum gravity. But "singularities" is not the same thing as "high energies".
 
PeterDonis said:
But "singularities" is not the same thing as "high energies".
okay but they do signal a failure of the theory and you were asking why I thought GR breaks down, and that's why im asking what does high energies mean in this context
 
PeterDonis said:
Said where? Again, please give a reference.
I meant that as general statement
 
PeterDonis said:
Said where? Again, please give a reference.
'This raises an important point: though we think of general relativity and quantum theory as ‘nice’ theories from the point of view of philosophical investigation, in a very real sense they are not the whole story and break down at extreme scales."

Quantum Gravity

 
KleinMoretti said:
they do signal a failure of the theory
They might. It's not a proven fact, just an opinion.

KleinMoretti said:
that's why im asking what does high energies mean in this context
And until you can give some specific reference that even uses the term "high energies" in this context, there is no point in even asking.

KleinMoretti said:
I meant that as general statement
Vague general statements about what "is said" are not a valid basis for discussion here. If you're going to claim that something "is said", you need to give a specific, valid reference that says it.

KleinMoretti said:
'This raises an important point: though we think of general relativity and quantum theory as ‘nice’ theories from the point of view of philosophical investigation, in a very real sense they are not the whole story and break down at extreme scales."

Quantum Gravity

This is a philosophy website, not a physics textbook or peer-reviewed paper.
 
  • Like
Likes Vanadium 50

Similar threads

Back
Top