IATF
Why does green laser light reflect off a red object?
- Context: High School
- Thread starter IATF
- Start date
Join the discussion
Registration is free. Ask a follow-up in this thread, or start your own.
7 replies · 2K views
Discussion
Physics news on Phys.org
Mentor
- 23,210
- 7,696
No object is a perfect absorber of any wavelength, let alone a broad range. A black piece of paper merely absorbs a much larger percentage of the incoming light than a white piece of paper. The same is true of all other objects. A red apple reflects more light in the red end of the spectrum than the rest, but it does not absorb all of the non-red light falling on it.
IATF
Is the percentage of light absorbed proportional to the amount of light falling on it, or the value is predetermined for the object?
Science Advisor
Homework Helper
- 30,561
- 7,536
What is your opinion about that?IATF said:Is the percentage of light absorbed proportional to the amount of light falling on it, or the value is predetermined for the object?
Human colour vision is very clever and also very limited at the same time so you cannot rely on what you 'see' to answer your question.
IATF
I asked this question because we know that anything seems brighter and more detailed in more light, and concluded that that light reflected out could be proportional to light absorbed. What's your opinion towards this?
Science Advisor
Homework Helper
- 30,561
- 7,536
I have no reason to think that the proportion of light reflected from a surface would change according to the amount of light (with the same spectrum) falling on it. That simple relationship could well change if the level of light energy were high enough to alter the surface (e.g. change its temperature to red hot). What your eyes / brain make of a scene is not related in any simple way to the actual situation; the retina is not a simple linear detector, for instance and visual acuity depends upon incident light levels.
My "opinion" is based on standard teaching and personal measurements. Have you read the standard stuff about reflectivity of light? It's always a good idea to start with some reading before asking questions.
My "opinion" is based on standard teaching and personal measurements. Have you read the standard stuff about reflectivity of light? It's always a good idea to start with some reading before asking questions.
- 32,819
- 4,724
IATF said:I asked this question because we know that anything seems brighter and more detailed in more light, and concluded that that light reflected out could be proportional to light absorbed. What's your opinion towards this?
This is not necessarily true, because you are forgetting one thing: the sensitivity of the eye for a particular wavelength.
I wrote about the shortcoming of the human eye as a detector already. It is possible that an incoming light may be in the range that the eye is less sensitive to, while the reflected light is in the range that the eye is more sensitive to. This then will make it appear that the reflected light is brighter than the incident light. While not strictly in the same physics, blacklight reflection is one such example.
The ONLY way to do this objectively (i.e. not to include the shortcoming of our eye into the equation) is to look at UV-VIS-type experiments. Otherwise, you will always be questioned on whether your eye is deceiving you with what you think you saw.
Zz.
my2cts
- 362
- 26
@OP
What laws of reflection are you talking about and how are they "contrary" ?
What laws of reflection are you talking about and how are they "contrary" ?
Similar threads
Undergrad Why does green laser have wider output than red and violet?
- TRB8985
- · Replies 6 ·
- Optics
- Replies
- 6
Graduate Why does light reflect off a mirror at the same angle it arrives?
- fbs7
- · Replies 5 ·
- Optics
- Replies
- 5
Undergrad Why does a laser reflect off a mirror but fire doesn't?
- Raj Harsh
- · Replies 26 ·
- Optics
- Replies
- 26
High School Why does a red laser beam reflect off objects that don't reflect red light?
- helpmeplz!
- · Replies 5 ·
- Optics
- Replies
- 5
High School Does light reflect off the surface of a lens?
- haha1234
- · Replies 3 ·
- Optics
- Replies
- 3
Undergrad Why does light reflect off glass cracks if refractive indices are equal?
- Hypatio
- · Replies 2 ·
- Optics
- Replies
- 2
High School Why Does Light Reflect Off a Mirror at the Same Angle It Hits?
- cragar
- · Replies 14 ·
- Optics
- Replies
- 14
High School Why does light reflect off a shiny surface?
- Tom H
- · Replies 5 ·
- Optics
- Replies
- 5
Undergrad How does light reflect off surfaces and why at the same angle?
- wildman
- · Replies 5 ·
- Optics
- Replies
- 5
Undergrad How does light reflect off a material surface?
- jeebs
- · Replies 10 ·
- Quantum Physics
- Replies
- 10