Why Does the Balance Arm Rotate if the Total Torque Is Zero?

  • Thread starter Saitama
  • Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Torque Zero
10 replies · 4K views · last reply
Saitama
Messages
4,244
Reaction score
93

Homework Statement


When a body is weighed on an ordinary balance we demand that arm should be horizontal if the weights on two pans are equal. Suppose equal weights are put on two pans, the arm is kept at an angle with the horizontal and released. Is the torque of the two weights about the middle point (point of support) zero? Is the total torque zero? If so, why does the arm rotate and become horizontal?

Homework Equations


The Attempt at a Solution


Here's what i think so far:-
Diagram of an unequal-looking balance arm tilted at angle Θ, with two identical pans of mass m hanging from each end by strings; each pan has a downward arrow labelled mg, and dashed horizontal reference lines show distance r from the pivot on each side.


(Sorry for a bad drawing :) )

For the first part, individual torque is not zero. For each weight the torque is mgrcosθ.
For the second part, the total torque is zero since the torques of weight are in opposite direction.
Now i am confused in third part. Since the net torque is zero, the balance should not move but that's not observed. Then why does it come to the horizontal position? :confused:
 
I think you'll find that real equal-arm balances have the pivot point located slightly above the center line of the arms. Try drawing the arm as a triangle with a wide base (the span of the arms) and the pivot at the apex.
 
gneill said:
I think you'll find that real equal-arm balances have the pivot point located slightly above the center line of the arms. Try drawing the arm as a triangle with a wide base (the span of the arms) and the pivot at the apex.

Do you mean something likr this:-
Meme with Abe Simpson from The Simpsons pointing at the viewer, captioned: I used to be 'with it.' But then they changed what 'it' was. Now what I'm 'with' isn't 'it' and what's 'it' seems weird and scary to me... IT'LL HAPPEN TO YOU.


Can you explain a bit more?
 
Schematically something like this:

Schematic of a balance arm pivoting at a point above a horizontal bar, with two pans hanging from the ends each labelled mg, and dashed lines showing the arm tilted.


Real scales often have ornately shaped arms that tend to disguise the offset of the pivot from the horizontal line joining the pan attachment points.

If you take the torques about the actual picot point, I think you'll see a difference in the contributions from each pan when the arm is at an angle to the horizontal.
 
Attachments
  • Schematic of a balance arm pivoting at a point above a horizontal beam, with two hanging pans each loaded with mg and dashed lines showing the arm tilted to each side.
    Fig1.gif
    1.8 KB · Views: 756
I still don't get it.
I am having problems taking the perpendicular distances.
Maybe i am not able to visualize when the arm is kept at an angle.
Can you please show me a figure to help me?

Thanks! :smile:
 
Pranav-Arora said:
I still don't get it.
I am having problems taking the perpendicular distances.
Maybe i am not able to visualize when the arm is kept at an angle.
Can you please show me a figure to help me?

Thanks! :smile:

Here's a diagram. I've indicated the appropriate angles for the left hand pan. You should work out the angles for the right hand pan yourself.

Two-panel diagram of a balance arm pivoting about a central pivot point, with arm length L, angle alpha, and masses mg hanging from each end; lower panel shows the arm tilted by a further angle beta, with the left pan angle labelled alpha plus beta.
 
Attachments
  • Two diagrams of a balance arm with a central pivot point and two pans hung by lengths L, each pan carrying a weight mg; the second shows the arm tilted by angle alpha plus beta with angles marked.
    Fig1.gif
    10.9 KB · Views: 869
I am sorry for asking stupid questions but what does those red arrows represent. :rolleyes:
 
Pranav-Arora said:
I am sorry for asking stupid questions but what does those red arrows represent. :rolleyes:

They are perpendicular to the line joining the pivot point to the point of application of the force. What do you think they might represent?
 
I've also made a picture. :shy:

Diagram of a tilted rigid beam pivoting on a triangular fulcrum at its center, with supports at both ends. Dimension arrows show 2.25 inches from the left end to the pivot and 3.25 inches from the pivot to the right end.
 
Attachments
  • Diagram of a tilted brown beam resting on two blue triangular supports, with a blue pivot post on top of the beam; dimension arrows show 2.25 inch from the left pivot point and 3.25 inch from the right support.
    scales.gif
    8.9 KB · Views: 704
gneill said:
Here's a diagram. I've indicated the appropriate angles for the left hand pan. You should work out the angles for the right hand pan yourself.

Two diagrams of a balance with a pivot point at the top and two arms of length L, each holding a mass mg; red arrows show forces at the arm ends, and angle alpha and alpha plus beta mark the tilt of the arms.

I am assuming the red ones are the forces causing torque ... but the one on the right is not really perpendicular to arm as the left one ... why?
 
cupid.callin said:
I am assuming the red ones are the forces causing torque ... but the one on the right is not really perpendicular to arm as the left one ... why?

It is perpendicular to the arm. The arms are also in red.