WHY does the sign for B1 and B2 keep CHANGING in this Bnet equation?

  • Thread starter riseofphoenix
  • Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Sign
19 replies · 5K views · last reply
riseofphoenix
Messages
294
Reaction score
2
The two wires shown in the figure below are separated by d = 8.0 cm and carry currents of I = 4.85 A in opposite directions.

Diagram of two vertical parallel wires with currents I in opposite directions: left wire up, right wire down. Points P2 and P1 lie left and right, spaced 2d and d from the wires as labeled.


d = 8 cm = 0.08 m
d = 8 cm = 0.08 m
r = 0.08/2 = 0.04 m
2d = 21.6 cm
I (up) = 4.80 A
I (down) = 4.80 A

(a) Find the magnitude and direction of the net magnetic field at a point midway between the wires.

magnitude: ______ µT
direction: ______

(b) Find the magnitude and direction of the net magnetic field at point P1, 8.0 cm to the right of the wire on the right.

magnitude: ______ µT
direction: ______

(c) Find the magnitude and direction of the net magnetic field at point P2, 2d = 16.0 cm to the left of the wire on the left.

magnitude: ______ µT
direction: ______

_______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

Solution:


Assume that the wire on the right is wire 1 and that on the left is wire 2. Also, choose the positive direction for the magnetic field to be out of the page and negative into the page.

(a) At the point half way between the two wires,

Bnet = -B1 - B2
Bnet = -[(µI1)2πr1 + (µI2)/2πr2]
Bnet = -(µ/2πr)(I1 + I2)
Bnet = [-(4π x 10-7)/2π(0.04 m)](4.85 + 4.85)
Bnet = (-0.000001257/0.251)(9.7)
Bnet = -0.000012193/0.251
Bnet = -4.85 x 10-5 T
or
Bnet = 48.5 µT into the page

QUESTION: the signs for B1 and B2 changed. WHY? I don't understand!


(b) At point P1,

Bnet = +B1 - B2
Bnet = (µ/2π)[(I1/r1) - (I2/r2)]
Bnet = [(4π x 10-7)/6.283][(4.85 A)/(0.08 m) - (4.85 A)/(0.16)]
Bnet = (0.0000002)(60.625 - 30.125)
Bnet = (0.0000002)(30.5)
Bnet = 0.0000061
Bnet = 6 µT out of page

QUESTION: the signs for B1 and B2 changed. WHY? I don't understand!

(c) At point P3

Bnet = -B1 + B2
Bnet = (µ/2π)[-(I1/r1) + (I2/r2)]
Bnet = [(4π x 10-7)/6.283][-(4.85 A)/(0.24 m) + (4.85 A)/(0.16)]
Bnet = (0.0000002)(-20.208 + 30.125)
Bnet = (0.0000002)(9.917)
Bnet = 0.000001983
Bnet = 1.983 µT out of page

QUESTION: the signs for B1 and B2 changed. WHY? I don't understand!
 
In addition to TSny's link, make sure you understand the right hand rule, and how the magnetic field of a long wire fits into that.

And lastly, the sign convention used in the solution was stated at the beginning of the solution,
"Also, choose the positive direction for the magnetic field to be out of the page and negative into the page."​

That last part is an arbitrary convention. You could have chosen the opposite convention and let positive be into the page and negative out. You would end up with the same, final answers in the end. The important thing to do here is to pick a convention, and stick with it consistently throughout the problem.
 
Oh I understand the link TSny gave me, but I still don't understand why the three equations consist of the following..

a) Bnet = -B1 - B2

For instance, for this one, how did they conclude that the magnetic field the wire on the right (B1) is negative? and that the magnetic field for the wire on the left (B2) is also negative? Did they just "say so"? the diagram itself doesn't indicate that nor does the "Right hand grip rule"

b) Bnet = +B1 - B2
c) Bnet = -B1 + B2

And so essentially, you're saying that I still could have gotten the right answer if I did the following??

a) Bnet = +B1 + B2
b) Bnet = -B1 + B2
c) Bnet = +B1 - B2
 
riseofphoenix said:
Oh I understand the link TSny gave me, but I still don't understand why the three equations consist of the following..

a) Bnet = -B1 - B2

For instance, for this one, how did they conclude that the magnetic field the wire on the right (B1) is negative? [/color]
Is it going into the page or out of the page. Use the right hand rule, and the decided upon convention, where negative is into the page (and positive out of the page).
and that the magnetic field for the wire on the left (B2) is also negative? [/color]
Once again, use the right hand rule. Is the magnetic field of B2 into or out of the page?
Did they just "say so"? the diagram itself doesn't indicate that nor does the "Right hand grip rule"
The decided upon convention where positive is out of the page and negative into the page was one of "just said so." It's an arbitrary convention, and could have been the opposite.

But once it is chosen, consistency is vital. Once a convention is chosen, it must be followed consistently from start to finish.
b) Bnet = +B1 - B2
c) Bnet = -B1 + B2

And so essentially, you're saying that I still could have gotten the right answer if I did the following??

a) Bnet = +B1 + B2
b) Bnet = -B1 + B2
c) Bnet = +B1 - B2
Yes, as long as you are consistent about how define positive/negative going into or out of the page. Consistency is the important part.
 
collinsmark said:
Is it going into the page or out of the page. Use the right hand rule, and the decided upon convention, where negative is into the page (and positive out of the page).

That's the thing though! I have NO idea if the magnetic field is going into the page or out of the page... :(:(

Right Hand Grip Rule diagram: a hand wraps a vertical wire carrying current upward, thumb pointing up along the current, fingers curling counterclockwise to show the circular magnetic field lines around the wire.


That diagram only indicates it going CCW.

Can't I just say this instead?

Magnetic field is going CCW: -B
Magnetic field going CW: +B
 
riseofphoenix said:
That diagram only indicates it going CCW.
Can't I just say this instead?
Magnetic field is going CCW: -B
Magnetic field going CW: +B

At point a in the diagram is the field coming out at you or away from you?

How about at point b?
 
Attachments
  • Right Hand Grip Rule diagram: a right hand grips a vertical wire carrying current upward, thumb pointing up along the current, fingers curling around it, with concentric circular field lines around the wire and points a and b marked on either side.
    B Field Current.jpg
    10.5 KB · Views: 943
TSny said:
At point a in the diagram is the field coming out at you or away from you?

How about at point b?

At point a, it's moving away from me. At point b, it's coming out at me.
 
riseofphoenix said:
is that right?

No. You can see the little arrows on the circular magnetic field lines that tell you the direction of the field lines (CCW). Suppose a little bug walked CCW around the circular field line that contains points a and b. When the bug reaches point a would the bug be walking toward you or away from you?
 
Here's a pic that shows a top view. Note that the field line goes CCW in the top view, but the B field points in opposite directions at P1 and P2.
 
Attachments
  • Top view diagram of a circular blue loop with counterclockwise arrows, a gray dot at the center, and red arrows labeled B at points P1 on the right and P2 on the left, pointing in opposite directions.
    B Field Current2.jpg
    14.3 KB · Views: 990
riseofphoenix said:
Toward me?

Yes, the bug would be walking toward you (out of the page) at point a.
 
TSny said:
Yes, the bug would be walking toward you (out of the page) at point a.

Ohh...whenever I come across a problem like this,

1) Pay attention to what direction the current is going (up or down)
2) Use the right hand grip rule.

Right hand grip rule diagram: a right hand wraps around a vertical wire carrying a current labelled Current, thumb pointing up along the current, with curved arrow showing the other fingers giving the direction of the magnetic field around the wire, shown as concentric circles below.


3) Determine whether the magnetic field direction is clockwise or counterclockwise

Two diagrams of concentric circular magnetic field lines around a straight wire: left shows a dot for current out of the plane, right shows a cross for current into the plane, with the field circulating counterclockwise and clockwise respectively.


4) Label 2 points on the magnetic field on each, opposite side of your right hand that you are (supposedly) using to hold the wire with

Right hand grip rule diagram: a right hand wraps a vertical wire with the thumb pointing up along the current, and the curled fingers showing the circular field direction around the wire, with points a and b marked on either side of the wire.


5) The magnetic field vectors (B) are tangent to these points on the circular plane/magnetic field lines and is either going OUT OF THE PAGE (towards you) or INTO THE PAGE (away from you)

Two-panel diagram: left side shows a vertical wire carrying current I upward with a circular loop around it, points P2 and P1 at distances 2d and d from the wire; right side is a top view of the loop with B arrows at P2 pointing down and at P1 pointing up.
 
Last edited:
Right. Magnetic field vectors are always tangent to magnetic field lines.
 
So back to the problem...
I know that Bnet = B1 (right wire) + B2 (left wire)

Diagram of two long parallel wires shown end-on, with arrows marking current I up in the left wire and down in the right wire, and points P2 and P1 on the left and right, with distances 2d, d and d marked along the horizontal line.


PART A

Looking at B1 (right wire)
1) Current is going down
2) Using right hand grip rule (with my thumb pointing down), the magnetic field is going clockwise
3) Looking at the wire from the top, I draw 2 points on the right side of my hand and on the left side of my hand on the outermost circle. On the right, B1 is going OUT of the page (to me) and on the left, B1 is going INTO of the page (away from me), But am I'm only interested in the right point?

Looking at B2 (left wire)
1) Current is going up
2) Using right hand grip rule (with my thumb pointing up), the magnetic field is going counterclockwise
3) Looking at the wire from the top, I draw 2 points on the right side of my hand and on the left side of my hand on the outermost circle. On the right, B2 is coming OUT of the page (to me) and on the left, B2 is going INTO the page (away from me), But am I'm only interested in the LEFT point?

4) Choose direction of B
If B is going INTO the page: -B
If B is coming OUT of the page: +B

5) Bnet = +B1 (right wire) + -B2 (left wire)
 
OK wait...im confusing myself...

I get the whole figuring about whether or not the magnetic field is going into the page or out of the page...
But to save time (since this is going to be on the test), all I need to know is that I can either do one of the following methods

First method
a) Bnet = -B1 - B2
b) Bnet = +B1 - B2
c) Bnet = -B1 + B2

Alternative method
a) Bnet = +B1 + B2
b) Bnet = -B1 + B2
c) Bnet = +B1 - B2
 
riseofphoenix said:
So back to the problem...
I know that Bnet = B1 (right wire) + B2 (left wire)

Diagram of two vertical wires carrying currents: left wire with upward arrow labeled I, right wire with downward arrow labeled I. Points P2 and P1 sit left and right, with spacings 2d, d and d marked along a horizontal line.


PART A

Looking at B1 (right wire)
1) Current is going down
2) Using right hand grip rule (with my thumb pointing down), the magnetic field is going clockwise
3) Looking at the wire from the top, I draw 2 points on the right side of my hand and on the left side of my hand on the outermost circle. On the right, B1 is going OUT of the page (to me) and on the left, B1 is going INTO of the page (away from me), But am I'm only interested in the right point?
I don't think that's the point you're concerned with. (Although I'm not quite sure I'm following you here.)

Since this is part a), you're concerned about the point that is "midway between the wires." (Because that is what was specified in part a).

So it's a point to the left of the rightmost wire (which is at the midpoint between the wires).

Looking at B2 (left wire)
1) Current is going up
2) Using right hand grip rule (with my thumb pointing up), the magnetic field is going counterclockwise
3) Looking at the wire from the top, I draw 2 points on the right side of my hand and on the left side of my hand on the outermost circle. On the right, B2 is coming OUT of the page (to me) and on the left, B2 is going INTO the page (away from me), But am I'm only interested in the LEFT point?

Since we're still on part a, you are interested in a point to the right of the leftmost wire.
 
riseofphoenix said:
OK wait...im confusing myself...

I get the whole figuring about whether or not the magnetic field is going into the page or out of the page...
But to save time (since this is going to be on the test), all I need to know is that I can either do one of the following methods

First method
a) Bnet = -B1 - B2
b) Bnet = +B1 - B2
c) Bnet = -B1 + B2
This is correct for this particular problem if you are following the convention that into the page is negative and out of the page is positive.
Alternative method
a) Bnet = +B1 + B2
b) Bnet = -B1 + B2
c) Bnet = +B1 - B2
This is correct for this particular problem if (unlike the convention used in the posted solution), into the page is positive and out of the page is negative.

Both are correct, as long as consistency is maintained. Both methods yield identical answers about whether the net magnetic fields are pointing into our out of the page (again though, as long as consistency is maintained).

But I wouldn't bother memorizing those formula though. If the instructor changes the problem around, memorizing the relationship won't help.

Perhaps I can explain this better if I use an analogy. Do you remember in more basic physics, where you calculated the velocity of a rock falling off a cliff? If so, you may recall that it was up to you if you wanted to label the down direction as positive or negative. If you labeled down as negative and the final answer was a large negative number it meant the rock was falling down. If you chose the down direction to be positive, and the final [STRIKE]speed[/STRIKE] velocity of the rock was a large positive value, it still meant the rock was falling down. Either way, the final answer was the same, as long as you were consistent. It's the same idea here. You get to choose whether into the page is positive or negative (unless your instructor/textbook explicitly tells you to use a particular convention). Once you choose a convention just stick with it from beginning to end and it will all work out.
 
Last edited:
collinsmark said:
This is correct for this particular problem if you are following the convention that into the page is negative and out of the page is positive.

This is correct for this particular problem if (unlike the convention used in the posted solution), into the page is positive and out of the page is negative.

Both are correct, as long as consistency is maintained. Both methods yield identical answers about whether the net magnetic fields are pointing into our out of the page (again though, as long as consistency is maintained).

But I wouldn't bother memorizing those formula though. If the instructor changes the problem around, memorizing the relationship won't help.

Perhaps I can explain this better if I use an analogy. Do you remember in more basic physics, where you calculated the velocity of a rock falling off a cliff? If so, you may recall that it was up to you if you wanted to label the down direction as positive or negative. If you labeled down as negative and the final answer was a large negative number it meant the rock was falling down. If you chose the down direction to be positive, and the final speed of the rock was a large positive value, it still meant the rock was falling down. Either way, the final answer was the same, as long as you were consistent. It's the same idea here. You get to choose whether into the page is positive or negative (unless your instructor/textbook explicitly tells you to use a particular convention). Once you choose a convention just stick with it from beginning to end and it will all work out.

Ohhh! Ok. that makes sense!
Thanks a BUNCH! And sorry for all of the confusion xD