- #1
MathematicalPhysicist
Gold Member
- 4,699
- 371
I see a Math challenge, but why don't we have a Physics challenge in physicsforums?
Good idea. Want to do it?MathematicalPhysicist said:I see a Math challenge, but why don't we have a Physics challenge in physicsforums?
Always wanted a physics version! We just need a few volunteers to head it.DrClaude said:Good idea. Want to do it?
Does @fresh_42 look at problems from books and articles or does he "cook" the problems from his head?DrClaude said:Good idea. Want to do it?
These challenges take quite a bit of work and we are grateful to @fresh_42 for handling the math challenges. We have no one willing and able to do it for physics.
Cooking sounds easier than it actually is. I mainly take questions from exams, because I want to add more value to the questions than just some sophisticated puzzles. They could probably be found by some Google searches, but I take German exams .MathematicalPhysicist said:Does @fresh_42 look at problems from books and articles or does he "cook" the problems from his head?
Well I can post questions from my exams in QFT II, I guess you can search them in the web; I myself would like to know their solutions...fresh_42 said:Cooking sounds easier than it actually is. I mainly take questions from exams, because I want to add more value to the questions than just some sophisticated puzzles. They could probably be found by some Google searches, but I take German exams .
I had some cooked ones, too, but it is difficult to close all possible loopholes, and or to find interesting subjects.
We need someone to lead it.Hamiltonian299792458 said:so is this happening or not?
Yes, it does seem a bit of hard to have a physics monthly problem challenge.fresh_42 said:Such a problem of the day would at least solve the main problem with physics challenges. This is:
If we do not have a clear true - false situation or a mathematical calculation, then any physics question is likely a more or less long description of a kind of experiment. I predict that an inevitable implication will be an annoying discussion about understanding, details, which laws should be applied, etc. The reason is, that other than in a real exam or tutorial, we have no natural authority. An actual exercise is as it is, nobody will question what the professor wrote or posed. This is different here. People discuss, question, and doubt everything all the time. A short glimpse into the QM Interpretation forum will show what I mean. Math is easier in this respect.
There are a few reasons why there are no Physics challenges in PF. Firstly, Physics is a complex and challenging subject that requires a strong foundation in mathematics and other sciences. Therefore, it may not be suitable for all participants in PF. Additionally, creating Physics challenges that are both engaging and accurate can be difficult and time-consuming. Finally, PF may have chosen to focus on other subjects or topics that are more popular among its users.
It is difficult to predict the future plans of PF, but it is possible that there may be Physics challenges in the future. However, this would depend on the demand and interest from the PF community, as well as the availability of resources and expertise to create and maintain these challenges.
Yes, you can always suggest new ideas and topics for challenges in PF. The platform values user feedback and suggestions, and it is always looking for ways to improve and expand its content. You can reach out to the PF team through their website or social media channels to share your ideas.
Yes, there are many other platforms and websites that offer Physics challenges and resources. Some popular ones include Khan Academy, Brilliant, and Physics Stack Exchange. These platforms may have a wider range of Physics challenges and topics compared to PF.
There are many ways to improve your Physics skills without challenges in PF. You can read textbooks, watch educational videos, attend lectures or workshops, and practice solving problems on your own. You can also join online forums or communities where you can ask questions and discuss Physics concepts with others. Additionally, you can seek guidance from a mentor or tutor who can provide personalized support and feedback.