Why is ro = 0.2255 in fluid dynamics vortices?

5 replies · 2K views · last reply
yecko
Gold Member
Messages
275
Reaction score
15
Homework Statement
A closed cylindrical tank of 4 m in height and 2 m in diameter contains water to a depth of 3 m. When the cylinder is rotated at a constant angular velocity of 40 rad/s, show that nearly 0.71 m2 of the bottom surface of the tank is uncovered.
Relevant Equations
pressure surface, Bernoulli's equation
Handwritten derivation on a whiteboard for a rotating fluid in a cylinder: free-surface equation z = z0 + (w^2/2g)(r^2 - r0^2), volume integral set to 1 = pi times the integral from 0 to 4 of (8gz/w^2 + r0^2) dz, boxed result 64g/w^2 + 4r0^2 = 1, and r0 = 0.2255 boxed in red.

why is ro = 0.2255?
Calculation showing (1 - (64 · 9.81) / 40²) divided by 4, with the result given as = 0.1519.


Thank you
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: Delta2
yecko said:
Homework Statement:: A closed cylindrical tank of 4 m in height and 2 m in diameter contains water to a depth of 3 m. When the cylinder is rotated at a constant angular velocity of 40 rad/s, show that nearly 0.71 m2 of the bottom surface of the tank is uncovered.
Relevant Equations:: pressure surface, Bernoulli's equation

View attachment 273668
why is ro = 0.2255?
View attachment 273669

Thank you
I would have assumed the handwritten calculation was yours, but your question implies it is someone else's. Please clarify.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: Delta2
Sorry for being unclear.
The handwritten one is the answer written by prof. And the answer is same as final model answer in textbook.
However, when I substitute the number in the red bracket, I can only obtain 0.1519 from calculator instead of prof‘s answer 0.2255.
Have I done anything wrong? Thank you.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: Delta2
yecko said:
Sorry for being unclear.
The handwritten one is the answer written by prof. And the answer is same as final model answer in textbook.
However, when I substitute the number in the red bracket, I can only obtain 0.1519 from calculator instead of prof‘s answer 0.2255.
Have I done anything wrong? Thank you.
OK, but you'll have to decipher the scrawl for me. It looks like ##\frac{64g}{\zeta^2}+4r_0^2=1##. If so, what is ##\zeta##?
 
Textbook page 141 titled Role of Viscosity in Rotational and Irrotational Vortices, with equations for solid-body rotation including the viscous stress expression, Euler equations in polar coordinates (5.4), and pressure difference relations (5.5).

From Kundu, by comparing the formula "Surfaces of constant pressure are given by ...", ζ written by Prof should be ω here, which implicates angular velocity. However, when I substite 40 rad/s, the answer is wrong. Am I having any misunderstanding with ζ?
 
for reference, this question is utilising the approach of "constant pressure surface"
Lecture slide titled 7.2 Ideal Rotational Vortex showing equations of motion for a rotating fluid, pressure relations, a constant pressure surface equation, Bernoulli equation, and circulation; a sketch of a rotating free surface with pressure contours and omega marked.