Why isn't ClF3 trigonal planar?

  • Thread starter prakhargupta3301
  • Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Structural
3 replies · 12K views · last reply
prakhargupta3301
Messages
58
Reaction score
1
Two Lewis structures of ClF3 drawn with Cl at the centre: structure 1 has two F atoms in the axial positions and one F equatorial, with two lone pairs equatorial; structure 2 has three F atoms in a planar arrangement and two lone pairs on the axial positions, labelled 1 and 2.

I know ClF3 has triagonal bi-pyramidal arrangement and T-shape molecular geometry. (as shown in first diag.). However, it can also be 2nd case. In this one, the shape will be triagonal planar. Also, electrons will be farthest. So why isn't ClF3 like second case?
 
Attachments
  • Two Lewis structures of ClF3 drawn with Cl at the centre: structure 1 has two F atoms in the axial positions and one F equatorial, with two lone pairs equatorial; structure 2 has three F atoms in a planar arrangement and two lone pairs on the axial positions, labelled 1 and 2.
    JTvl45.png
    955 bytes · Views: 19,155
In VSEPR theory, non-bonding electron pairs are sterically more demanding than bound electron pairs. In the first formula, each non-bonding electron pair has only two neighbours in a 90 degree separation while in the 2nd one, each has 3. Whether the distance between the two non-bonding pairs is 120 or 180 degrees will be rather irrelevant compared to the next neighbour repulsion.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: prakhargupta3301
I get what you mean. Thank you.
But would you be kind enough to explain what
DrDu said:
'sterically more demanding than bound electron pairs'
means?
[I did look up the meaning of steric but the meaning still isn't clear]
Thanks.