Wing loading. more complex than weight/area?

  • Thread starter MotoMike
  • Start date
  • Tags
    Complex
In summary, Mike was discussing how wing loading affects airplane performance and how it can be a determining factor for whether a plane is flyable or not. He was also discussing the topic with other pilots and found that not everyone is aware of this scale factor.
  • #1
MotoMike
30
2
Hi

Once again the intricacies of flight seem to be escaping me.

I have taken up model flying as I think I mentioned in my "Lift- more complex than Bernoulli?" thread. So far I have been flying models with wingspans in the 60 to 70 inch range. When choosing airplanes, I noticed that in planes of this size wing loadings of 18 to 23oz per square foot were more manageable than those with higher wing loadings. That I could land them slower giving me more time to react.

I recently read an article about a large model with 110 inch wingspan and wing loading of 60oz per square foot. My initial thought was that the airplane would be unflyable for all but the most experienced pilots, if at all. Of course it is for a more advanced pilot, but clearly many of them are out there being flown every day. The author made mention that on a smaller plane this wing loading would be a problem, but with the size of his plane it was nothing to be concerned about.

Of course this has led me to discuss it with other pilots who are ill prepared to describe why it is different. One told me that it had to do with Wing Cube Loading, but could not really explain what it was and how I could estimate if a plane will "fly light" or "fly heavy"

Any discussion on this topic would be appreciated.

Kind regards,
Mike
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
The wing loading gives you somewhat of an idea of the required speed for landing and take off and normal flight. Note that lift and drag for a given angle of attack increase relative to speed2, so doubling the wing loading correlates to an increase of speed of sqrt(2) ~= 1.4142. There's also a scale factor for velocity (link to article about this below).

For example, the landing speed of a full scale Cessna 182 is about 70 to 75 mph = 112 kph to 120 kph, with a wing loading of 285 oz / ft2. So a scale Cessna 182 with 20 oz / ft2 wing loading would land at about 70 (20/285)2 ~= 18.5 mph. For very small models, Reynold number will have some effect (mentioned in the article linked to below).

The "cubic" factor is probably a reference to scale. Volume is related to length x width x height, so a 1/4 scale model should weigh (1/4)3 as much as the full size model if density were to remain the same. There's also the issue of getting a model to fly at "scale speed". Link to an article:

scale_speed.htm
 
Last edited:
  • #4
Thanks for the quick responses. It appears I might be biting off more than I can chew.

regards,
Mike
 
  • #5
CWaters
thanks for the recommendation. found one and have it ordered.

Mike
 

What is wing loading and why is it important in aviation?

Wing loading is the measure of how much weight an aircraft's wing can support per unit area. It is important in aviation because it affects the performance and handling of an aircraft, as well as its ability to take off and land safely.

How is wing loading calculated?

Wing loading is calculated by dividing the weight of the aircraft by the total wing area. The resulting number is usually expressed in pounds per square foot or kilograms per square meter.

What is the relationship between wing loading and aircraft design?

The wing loading of an aircraft is closely related to its design and purpose. High wing loading is typically seen in fighter jets, which require fast and agile maneuverability, while low wing loading is common in commercial airliners, which prioritize stability and fuel efficiency.

How does wing loading affect the stall speed of an aircraft?

Higher wing loading results in a higher stall speed, meaning the aircraft needs to maintain a faster speed to stay in the air. This is why aircraft with high wing loading, such as fighter jets, have higher takeoff and landing speeds than those with lower wing loading.

What are some factors that can affect wing loading?

The weight of the aircraft, the size and shape of the wing, and the amount of lift generated by the wing all play a role in determining wing loading. Additionally, factors like altitude, air density, and speed can also affect wing loading.

Similar threads

Replies
81
Views
8K
  • Mechanics
Replies
7
Views
2K
  • Mechanics
Replies
23
Views
4K
Replies
2
Views
1K
  • General Engineering
Replies
8
Views
2K
Replies
13
Views
1K
Replies
10
Views
3K
  • Aerospace Engineering
Replies
11
Views
2K
  • Mechanical Engineering
Replies
6
Views
302
  • General Math
Replies
2
Views
937
Back
Top