Would you rather hit another car or a tree?

  • Thread starter Dmitri10
  • Start date
  • Tags
    Car Tree
In summary, if you hit the other car, you'll end up with a higher velocity than if you hit the tree. This is because the other car has lost momentum, while the tree doesn't.
  • #1
Dmitri10
19
0
I'm not really a bad student, but I just can't come up with an answer for this question: "You are driving along the highway and encounter an unavoidable situation. You must hit either an identical car moving toward you at the same velocity, or a large tree. Which do you choose?" Obviously, I need to determine which will exert a smaller force. However, because of Newton's third law, the tree will exert an equal force on the vehicle, and so will the other car. Can anyone help me out? Any advice would be appreciated.
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
I'm not sure what they are looking for.
Of course the collision will not be elastic. But in the case of an inelastic collision, your change of momentum is the same in both situations.

Maybe they want something along these lines:
The tree is rooted to the ground, so consider it's mass infinite.
Now consider an elastic collision: what is the change in momentum you'd undergo in each situation?
I'll leave the math to you of course, but this would indeed lead to preferring one over the other. (EDIT: Sorry, thinking this over again, I am not sure this is true. It looks like they'd be the same as well.)

Oviously it is the acceleration (force) that matters, not the change in momentum, but it is not really possible with the provided info to calculate anything but the impulse. So you'll probably have to stick to using impulse instead of force.
 
Last edited:
  • #3
I believe the question is asking you to consider the total energy in each system.
 
  • #4
Norman said:
I believe the question is asking you to consider the total energy in each system.
In an inelastic collision, the energy lost by the car is the same in both situations. Remember that in the two car collision, while there may be more total energy, each car gets damaged and each loses the same amount of energy as if it hit an immobile wall.

I don't think this is a question about energy.
 
  • #5
The 3rd law says the force on the tree will equal the force on the car. It doesn't say anything about the relative size of the forces in the tree and two-car collisions. You might arrive at an answer by imagining the two cars hitting opposite sides of the tree simultaneously and then shrinking the tree down to a mere shrub.

What about the relative width of the tree and car? Would you get more collapse length from one or the other, affecting the duration of the collision? The answer may depend on the design of the car.

Are you liable for damage to the tree or other car!?
 
  • #6
I don't believe this is a homework question. If you hit the other car, then there's a chance that you'll injure/kill an innocent driver, whereas if you hit the tree it is only you that will feel the consequences of your own bad driving.
 
  • #7
JustinLevy said:
In an inelastic collision, the energy lost by the car is the same in both situations. Remember that in the two car collision, while there may be more total energy, each car gets damaged and each loses the same amount of energy as if it hit an immobile wall.

I agree and I think you just answered the question.
 
  • #8
One way to answer the question is to consider the other driver, and ignore physics.

But if we are to take the physics approach, consider the following:

1. For colliding with the other car, what does conservation-of-momentum tell you about your velocity after the collision?

2. If the tree is not so large that it may be uprooted or at least knocked over in the collision, what does that tell you about your velocity after the collision?

Of 1 and 2, which result is more desirable from your point of view?
 

1. Would hitting another car or a tree cause more damage to my vehicle?

The amount of damage done to your vehicle in a collision depends on a variety of factors such as the speed and angle of impact, the make and model of your vehicle, and the condition of the other car or tree. In general, hitting a tree may cause more significant damage as trees are more solid and less forgiving than cars which are designed to crumple on impact.

2. Is it safer to hit another car or a tree?

Both scenarios can be dangerous, but it may be safer to hit another car in some situations. If the other car is moving at a similar speed, the impact will be less severe compared to hitting a stationary tree. However, hitting another car can also increase the risk of a multi-vehicle collision and potential injuries to other passengers involved.

3. Will my insurance cover the damage if I hit another car or a tree?

In most cases, your insurance will cover the damage caused by a collision with another car or a tree. However, the amount of coverage may vary depending on your insurance policy and the specific circumstances of the accident. It is always best to check with your insurance provider for more information.

4. Can hitting a tree or another car cause injuries?

Yes, both scenarios can result in injuries depending on the force of impact and the location of the collision. Hitting a tree may cause more severe injuries due to the lack of give in the object, while hitting another car may result in injuries to multiple passengers involved in the collision.

5. How can I prevent hitting another car or a tree while driving?

The best way to prevent a collision with another car or a tree is to practice safe driving habits such as following speed limits, maintaining a safe distance from other vehicles, and avoiding distractions while driving. It is also important to be aware of your surroundings and adjust your driving in adverse weather conditions or when visibility is limited.

Similar threads

  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
4
Views
1K
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
4
Views
763
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
2
Views
3K
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
9
Views
1K
Replies
13
Views
1K
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
5
Views
1K
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
9
Views
2K
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
21
Views
3K
Replies
5
Views
7K
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
15
Views
3K
Back
Top