Yes, that is correct. Good job!

  • Thread starter Thread starter Unkownentity
  • Start date Start date
Click For Summary

Homework Help Overview

The discussion revolves around a physics problem involving the motion of a package dropped from a height and subsequently stopped by a person. The problem requires determining the velocity of the package at a specific point, the acceleration during deceleration, and the force applied by the person stopping the package. The subject area includes concepts from kinematics and dynamics.

Discussion Character

  • Exploratory, Conceptual clarification, Mathematical reasoning, Problem interpretation

Approaches and Questions Raised

  • Participants discuss using conservation of mechanical energy and kinematic equations to solve for the velocity and acceleration. There are attempts to clarify the correct distances to use for calculations and the implications of the problem's wording. Some participants express uncertainty about the formulas and the steps needed to find solutions.

Discussion Status

Several participants have provided insights and guidance on the approach to take, including the use of specific equations. There is an ongoing exploration of the problem, with various interpretations of the distances involved and the correct application of formulas. Some participants have shared their calculations, while others are questioning the reasoning behind certain steps.

Contextual Notes

There is confusion regarding the wording of the problem, particularly about the height at which the package is stopped and the distances to be used in calculations. Participants are also navigating the constraints of their current understanding of the relevant physics concepts.

Unkownentity
Messages
19
Reaction score
0
From a height of 6,00m from the floor a man drops a package weighing 1,3kg. Another man below at the height of 1,60m from the floor stops the package 0,30m from the floor. (We take for granted that the man uses a constant amount of Newton on the package and that there is no air resistance)

A) Determine the velocity of the package when the man stops the package
B) Determine the acceleration of the package during the deceleration
C) Determine the amount of Newtons the man uses on the package during the deceleration

Is there anyone who can help me out with this question showing every step, been sitting with it a while now and don't know anywhere else to turn =/

Thank you in beforehand :)
 
Physics news on Phys.org
Hi, welcome to PF! Someone here would be glad to help, but Forum Rules first require that you list what you think are the relevant equations and then show some attempt at a solution. Note that the low guy stops the package over a distance of 1.6 -0.3 = 1.3 m, by moving his hands down over that distance as he catches the package. You can use energy methods if you are familiar with them.
 
Think of conservation of mechanical energy for the first part.

You will also need the kinematic equations of motion for the second part.
 
Welcome to PF!

Hi Unkownentity! Welcome to PF! :wink:

Try A) first: you have the initial velocity, and the total distance, and you want the final velocity, so what formula or principle do you think you should use? :smile:

EDIT: ooh, PhanthomJay and rockfreak667 both beat me to it!
 
This is as far as i have come

By using Newtons second law F = M * A

and the acceleratoion in this case is the gravity therefore i cna rewrite the formula F = M * G

F = 1,3 * 9,82
F = 12,76

(i'm bad at using symbols over computer, what i mean with V0 is the starting velocity which should be zero in this case)

what i was thinking is by using this formula s = V0 *t * 1/2at^2 shouldn't i be able to get the amount of time it takes for it to fall and then by using (After getting the time) v = V0 + at i can find out the velocity, does that sound reasonable?
 
Hi Unkownentity! :smile:

(you don't need the force … the acceleration is enough :wink:)
Unkownentity said:
what i was thinking is by using this formula s = V0 * t * 1/2at2 shouldn't i be able to get the amount of time it takes for it to fall and then by using (After getting the time) v = v0 + at i can find out the velocity, does that sound reasonable?


Yes, that's the right idea.

But you only seem to know two of the standard constant acceleration equations …

there is a third one, v2 = v02 + 2as :wink:
 
Yeah isn't that the timless formula or something we haven't got to learn that yet since that goes more in depth in the next course :P but otherwise my other idea was right?
 
Unkownentity said:
Yeah isn't that the timless formula or something we haven't got to learn that yet since that goes more in depth in the next course :P but otherwise my other idea was right?

(it's not the tiny-timless formula :blushing:)

Yes, those two equations together will work fine. :smile:

ok, next try B) … you have the initial and final velocity, and the distance, and you want the acceleration. :wink:
 
i got that the answer on A was 10,50 m/s

V0 = 0
V1 = 10,5 m/s

since we only want to know the acceleration during the deceleration should i instead use the distance 0,3m? then i could use S = 1/2 (V0 + V1) *t to get the time and then use S = V0 *t + 1/2at^2 and leave the acceleration unknown does this work?
 
  • #10
You're not reading the question properly :redface:

the package does not stop at the floor, it stops at 0.30m (and the deceleration started at 1.60m).

But your method is correct: you can use the same equations "backwards" as in A), because the same four variables are involved. :wink:
 
  • #11
Oh okey so i just need to switch the distance, so i use 1,6 instead of using 0,3?
 
  • #12
Unkownentity said:
Oh okey so i just need to switch the distance, so i use 1,6 instead of using 0,3?

In part A), yes. :smile:
 
  • #13
shouldn't the distance on part A be 5,70 meters since the man stops it at that height?
 
  • #14
Unkownentity said:
shouldn't the distance on part A be 5,70 meters since the man stops it at that height?

hmm … it's a badly-worded question :frown:
Unkownentity said:
From a height of 6,00m from the floor a man drops a package weighing 1,3kg. Another man below at the height of 1,60m from the floor stops the package 0,30m from the floor. (We take for granted that the man uses a constant amount of Newton on the package and that there is no air resistance)

A) Determine the velocity of the package when the man stops the package

Part A) can't mean what it says (ie at 0.30m), because the velocity when he stops it is obviously zero :rolleyes:, so the first part must mean that he starts stopping it at 1.60m, and stops stopping it at 0.30m … and A) is asking for the velocity when he starts stopping it. :smile:
 
  • #15
i think he wrote it wrong i think he means that

A) Determine the velocity of the package when the man grabs the package
 
  • #16
Unkownentity said:
i think he wrote it wrong i think he means that

A) Determine the velocity of the package when the man grabs the package

Yes, at 1.60m. :smile:
 
  • #17
Okey so i got a veloity of 0,59m/s on A) does that sound reasonable?

But what i don't understand is what distance I'm supposed to use on B) =/
 
  • #18
Unkownentity said:
Okey so i got a veloity of 0,59m/s on A) does that sound reasonable?

How do you get that?
But what i don't understand is what distance I'm supposed to use on B)

1.60m - 0.30m = 1.30m.
 
  • #19
V = X
A = 9,82
t = 0,06

V = V0 + at by incorperating the numbers into the formula i got V = 0,59m/s
----------------------------------------------------------------
S = 1,6m
V0 = 0m/s
t = X

S = V0 *t + 1/2at^2

Here i did the same thing but with "T" so i could ge the time. (T = 0,06s)

thats how i did it
 
Last edited:
  • #20
Hi Unkownentity :smile:

(just got up :zzz: …)
Unkownentity said:
V = X
A = 9,82
t = 0,06

V = V0 + at by incorperating the numbers into the formula i got V = 0,59m/s
----------------------------------------------------------------
S = 1,6m
V0 = 0m/s
t = X

S = V0 *t + 1/2at^2

Here i did the same thing but with "T" so i could ge the time. (T = 0,06s)

thats how i did it

where does 0.06 come from?

where does 1.6m come from? :confused:
 
  • #21
Question:

From a height of 6,00m from the floor a man drops a package weighing 1,3kg. Another man below at the height of 1,60m from the floor stops the package 0,30m from the floor. (We take for granted that the man uses a constant amount of Newton on the package and that there is no air resistance)

A) Determine the velocity of the package when the man grabs the package
B) Determine the acceleration of the package during the deceleration
C) Determine the amount of Newtons the man uses on the package during the deceleration

Answer:

A) S = V0*t + 1/2at^2
1,6 = 0,5(9,82) * t^2
1,6 = 4,91t^2
0,56 = t

V = V0 + at
V = 0 + 9,82 * 0,56
V = 5,5 m/s
The velocity was: 5,5m/s

B) S = 1/2(V0 + V1) *t
S = V0 * t + 1/2at^2
1,3 = 1/2(5,5) * t
1,3 = 5,50t
0,23 = t

1,3 = 1/2(a) * 0,23^2
1,3 = 0,5a * 0,05
26 = = 0,5a
13 = a

Acceleration was: 13m/s^2

C) F = ma (Newtons second law)
F = 1,3 * 13
F = 16,9N

Force was: 16,9N

Is there anywhere i have done wrong? if so where?
 
Last edited:
  • #22
Hi Unkownentity! :smile:

(please use the X2 and X2 tags just above the Reply box :wink:)
Unkownentity said:
A) S = V0*t + 1/2at^2 V = V0 + at
1,6 = 0,5(9,82) * t^2 V = 0 + 9,82 * 0,56
1,6 = 4,91t^2 V = 5,5 m/s
0,56 = t
The velocity was: 5,5m/s

(why are you writing two separate things on the same line?? solve one equation first, then solve the next equation underneath it)

No, you're using s = 1.6m, you need to use the difference in height, which is 4.4m. :redface:
B) S = 1/2(V0 + V1) *t S = V0 * t + 1/2at^2
1,3 = 1/2(5,5) * t 1,3 = 1/2(a) * 0,23^2
1,3 = 5,50t 1,3 = 0,5a * 0,05
0,23 = t 26 = = 0,5a
13 = a
Acceleration was: 13m/s^2

Sorry, but S = 1/2(V0 + V1) *t is not one of the constant acceleration equations.

You need to use V = V0 + at, same as in part A).
 
  • #23
hmm okey but if i use the formula you showed before V^2 = V0^2 + 2as

5.5^2 = 2a * 2,6
30,25 = 2a * 2,6
11,63 = 2a
5,81 = a

acceleration is 5,81 m/s^2

This should be correct right?
 

Similar threads

  • · Replies 8 ·
Replies
8
Views
3K
  • · Replies 10 ·
Replies
10
Views
2K
  • · Replies 14 ·
Replies
14
Views
4K
  • · Replies 7 ·
Replies
7
Views
1K
  • · Replies 15 ·
Replies
15
Views
4K
  • · Replies 1 ·
Replies
1
Views
2K
  • · Replies 4 ·
Replies
4
Views
4K
  • · Replies 7 ·
Replies
7
Views
2K
Replies
3
Views
4K
Replies
5
Views
6K