According to this scientific report ( https://www.nature.com/articles/s41598-017-17526-4 ) written in 2017 : " The construction of a relativistic thermodynamics theory is still controversial after more than 110 years. To the date there is no agreement on which set of relativistic transformations...
To my knowledge, pentadimensional theories have been around in physics for decades. There are even theories which use a spacetime having a dimension greater than 5. The de Sitter relativity, which is discussed in the preprint, for instance, have a pentadimensional background. But it is true that...
Thank you for your reaction. My goal is to have "objective opinions" on the scientific content of this preprint with a critical thinking. If people give opinion against it and i see that there are probably scientific flaws in these opinions, as a scientist and researcher, it is natural for me...
Thank you! I studied physics... and now I am preparing my doctorate. I am looking for a good fresh topic. I am particularly interested in theories beyond the Standard Model but of course I have to limit myself to things I could handle :)
Thank you for your answer , it really helps me in analyzing it. However after reading your arguments, I read the paper again and it seems like your first and second arguments against them are not very fair if i can say that :)
1-"They seem to use a naive relativistic version of the canonical...
Hello everyone,
This is my introduction. I am a young student-researcher in physics and i am interested in all areas of science and technology. Wishing to have good exchange with you.
Hello everyone,
I looked for the best physics forum to ask this question because the subject interests me a lot. The authors of this preprint (https://arxiv.org/abs/1804.10053) seem to claim that their approach (using linear canonical transformations) is a new alternative way for the...