Recent content by Smattering

  1. Smattering

    What distinguishes a theory from a framework in physics?

    If the result changes, then we are not speaking of rederivation anymore. You can rederive the same results as many times as you want: The rederivation never becomes the original derivation.
  2. Smattering

    Randall Munroe Explains General Relativity

    But at least "part" is among the most common words. So, you probably would have to go for "smallest parts that all things are made of" or something like this.
  3. Smattering

    Randall Munroe Explains General Relativity

    That was really nice. So probably you study epigenetics?
  4. Smattering

    Randall Munroe Explains General Relativity

    I do get the overall meaning, but I am still wondering what you are referring to by "sky bag air".
  5. Smattering

    What does expand: Space or Spacetime?

    I was just wondering about the simplest way to describe the existing observations. And if the density per unit volume stays constant, although space continuously expands, then it seems to me that the simplest description might actually be to treat it as an intrinsic property of space.
  6. Smattering

    What does expand: Space or Spacetime?

    So, the tendency to expand can be considered an intrinsic property of space, as long as there are no other interference factors that compensate this tendency to expand?
  7. Smattering

    What distinguishes a theory from a framework in physics?

    That's true. But you cannot change the original derivation of something at a later point in time. If a result was originally derived in a certain way, that will will stay the way it was originally derived until the end of time. It might turn out that there are additional ways to derive the same...
  8. Smattering

    What does expand: Space or Spacetime?

    @HunterThomson: So did the amount of dark energy increase?
  9. Smattering

    What does expand: Space or Spacetime?

    This is what I always thought, but then I saw a feature with a German astrophysicist where he argued that in the big bang, not only space but rather space time expanded. The statement appeared a bit strange to me, because expansion clearly seems to be a temporal process. You compare some...
  10. Smattering

    What does expand: Space or Spacetime?

    Hello everybody, When we say that the universe expands, what exactly do we refer to: Space or space time? Is it only a spatial expansion or also a temporal expansion? If it is also a temporal expansion , what are the implications w.r.t. to inflation and accelerating expansion?Robert
  11. Smattering

    Why is the hierarchy problem a problem?

    Is naturalness anything else than a pure aesthetic argument? Why should we expect nature to be elegant?
  12. Smattering

    Is science fiction really more fantastical than science fantasy?

    As a reader I do take it seriously, because I am one of those who do not like fantasy at all--at least not when it comes to reading. I can watch something like Star Wars as a movie, but I would not be able to finish a book written in the same style. Thus, SF/fantasy is a warning for me not to...
  13. Smattering

    Is science fiction really more fantastical than science fantasy?

    Yes, but then Star Wars ends at SF/Fantasy which is exactly where it belongs.
  14. Smattering

    Is science fiction really more fantastical than science fantasy?

    Space Opera and Steampunk are clearly cross-over genres and *not* pure SF subgenres.
Back
Top