Doppler Shift and photons with a wavelength of one Plank length

AI Thread Summary
The discussion revolves around the detection of a photon with a wavelength of one Planck length and the implications of its Doppler shift when a machine moves toward it. It questions whether the machine would register a wavelength shorter than one Planck length and explores the consequences for String Theory and the concept of a smallest unit of length. The conversation emphasizes that quantum mechanics, rather than classical physics, must be applied to understand these phenomena. It argues that the expectation value of length is what contracts, not the spectrum of values of the operators involved. This highlights the complexity of reconciling quantum mechanics with theories of fundamental lengths.
l3un1t
Messages
1
Reaction score
0
If this is the wrong place to be posting this, feel free to lock this thread. I wasn't sure if this belonged in "classical physics" or "quantum physics"; this seemed like the appropriate place, but I'm not 100% certain, as it does involve subatomic particles.

Anyways, to get to the matter at hand.

Suppose I had a machine that could detect the wavelength of a photon. If this machine moved directly toward a photon with a wavelength of one Plank length ( so that the photon and the machine would collide perpendicularly), what wavelength would the machine register? Would it register a wavelength of less than one Plank length?

If so, does this have any implications for the validity of String Theory? If not, why?
 
Science news on Phys.org
I don't think anyone would assert that the plank length is the smallest unit of length, so smaller is certainly okay. There are theories of quantum gravity that predict a discrete spectrum of lengths, with there being a fundamental one. This thought experiment was thought to discredit the idea of having a smallest unit of length, but it is not the case. This is because we must treat the situation quantum mechanically, not classically. Then what is contracted in the expectation value of the length, not the spectrum of values of the operators.
 
I would like to use a pentaprism with some amount of magnification. The pentaprism will be used to reflect a real image at 90 degrees angle but I also want the reflected image to appear larger. The distance between the prism and the real image is about 70cm. The pentaprism has two reflecting sides (surfaces) with mirrored coating and two refracting sides. I understand that one of the four sides needs to be curved (spherical curvature) to achieve the magnification effect. But which of the...
Back
Top