What Makes Herman Melville's Writing Captivating?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Dembadon
  • Start date Start date
AI Thread Summary
The discussion centers around Herman Melville's short story "Bartleby, the Scrivener," with participants expressing their appreciation for Melville's writing style and storytelling. One participant highlights their enjoyment of "Bartleby" and expresses interest in reading more of Melville's works, particularly "Moby-Dick," which is noted for its literary significance despite Melville's perceived underachievement as a writer. The conversation touches on the true story of Mocha Dick, a sperm whale that inspired elements of "Moby-Dick," including themes of revenge and survival. Participants also discuss the irony present in classic literature, particularly in the context of the Essex whaling tragedy, which is linked to Melville's narrative. Recommendations for other Melville works like "White Jacket" and "Typee" are made, emphasizing their autobiographical nature and literary merit. Overall, the thread reflects a strong appreciation for Melville's contributions to literature and invites further exploration of his works.
Dembadon
Gold Member
Messages
658
Reaction score
89
I have just finished an assignment for which Herman Melville's short story "Bartleby, the Scrivener" was the story we had to explicate. I really enjoyed this story and I would recommend it to anyone, whether or not you're a Melville fan.

I find his writing style to be highly entertaining. I have not read any of his other works, Moby-Dick probably being the most well-known, but if they are anything like "Bartleby, the Scrivener," I'm sure that I'll enjoy them.

The http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Herman_Melville" page for Melville suggested that Melville did not live up to his potential as a writer, yet Moby-Dick is widely regarded as one of the greatest novels in the English language.

Are there any fans of Mr. Melville on PF? What do you like/dislike about his prose?
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Physics news on Phys.org
Bartleby the Scrivener was a good one. I enjoyed Moby Dick too, even more so after I found out that Melville based it on the true story of Mocha Dick. Mocha Dick was a white sperm whale that attacked ships around his territory (the Mocha Islands) and intentionally rammed and sank the whaler Essex after whale boats from the Essex attacked his pod. Many of the crew didn't make it back - lost to starvation, dehydration and cannibalism as they tried to make it to South America in their small whale-boats. Ironically, they were afraid to head for the Marquesas (nearby islands) because they were scared of cannibals.
 
turbo-1 said:
Bartleby the Scrivener was a good one. I enjoyed Moby Dick too, even more so after I found out that Melville based it on the true story of Mocha Dick. Mocha Dick was a white sperm whale that attacked ships around his territory (the Mocha Islands) and intentionally rammed and sank the whaler Essex after whale boats from the Essex attacked his pod. Many of the crew didn't make it back - lost to starvation, dehydration and cannibalism as they tried to make it to South America in their small whale-boats. Ironically, they were afraid to head for the Marquesas (nearby islands) because they were scared of cannibals.

I'll have to make some time to read it. The cannibal situation makes me laugh. What would classic literature be without heaps of irony? I think I'll enjoy it. :biggrin:
 
Bartleby is a fantastic story, but I have yet to read anything more by Melville. For a literature major, that's pretty bad!
 
Dembadon said:
I'll have to make some time to read it. The cannibal situation makes me laugh. What would classic literature be without heaps of irony? I think I'll enjoy it. :biggrin:
The cannibalism angle was in the TRUE story of the Essex. That's not a real factor in Moby Dick. Melville found out about the Essex details by shipping out with a nephew (IIR) of the Essex's first mate. Drawing from this, he came up with a character who was a whaling-captain who was driven, personally enraged (by a whale), and bent on revenge.

BTW, the whaling-ships sailing out of Massachusetts seemed to have a lot of Quakers as owners. Whaling required large up-front investments in ships, gear, supplies, provisions, crews, and might only pay back after your ship came back well-loaded after a cruise of a couple of years or more. That's a pretty scary business model.
 
Dembadon said:
... Moby-Dick is widely regarded as one of the greatest novels in the English language.

Are there any fans of Mr. Melville on PF? What do you like/dislike about his prose?
Well I only read Moby Dick in high school, and what irritates me about literature is that it sometimes takes a 1000 pages to get across a point so simple it could be done in a sonnet.
 
I love Melville. I think I've read everything he wrote. If you liked Moby Dick, I recommend White Jacket, his other sea voyage book, and also Typee, the story of his adoption by unspoiled South Sea Islanders on one of the Marquesas Islands. Both these books are believed to be essentially autobiographical accounts. They're not as dramatic as Moby Dick, but great reads anyway.
 

Similar threads

Can an AI write a credible novel with Wikipedia and YouTube?
Replies
3
Views
3K
Who is your favorite author and why?
Replies
2
Views
2K
The Scientist as Hero - or not
Replies
1
Views
3K
What can I do with my BS in physics?
Replies
3
Views
2K

Hot Threads

Recent Insights

Back
Top