Register to reply

The diffrence between refraction of sound and light

by Sjonsjon
Tags: diffrence, light, refraction, sound
Share this thread:
Sjonsjon
#1
Nov21-12, 09:56 AM
P: 3
I was thinking about refraction of waves and Im a little unsure. I wanted to run my understanding through you guys to make sure Im right.

So

The general rule is when a wave goes from a slower medium to a faster medium the wave should turn sligtly away from the faster medium when it enters it. And we can turn it around and say when a wave goes from a faster medium to a slower medium the wave should turn slightly towards the medium when it enters it.

Something like this:
http://hyperphysics.phy-astr.gsu.edu...oopt/refr.html

So when a light wave goes from air to water the light should bend towards the water because it going from faster to a slower medium. But it should be the opposite with sound, when sound goes from air to water then the wave is going from a slower medium to a faster medium so it should bend away from the water when it enters it.

Am I right about this? And if I am right than this picture must be wrong wich confused me alot.
http://learn.uci.edu/oo/getOCWPage.p...ic=003&page=14
Phys.Org News Partner Physics news on Phys.org
Mapping the optimal route between two quantum states
Spin-based electronics: New material successfully tested
Verifying the future of quantum computing
mfb
#2
Nov21-12, 01:28 PM
Mentor
P: 11,631
But it should be the opposite with sound
Why? Sound is just like light in that respect.

It is different for matter waves, but that is quantum mechanics.
Sjonsjon
#3
Nov21-12, 03:13 PM
P: 3
Quote Quote by mfb View Post
Why? Sound is just like light in that respect.

It is different for matter waves, but that is quantum mechanics.
Sound refracts the opposite way as opposed to light because when sound is entering water from air it is going from a slower to faster medium, but when light is entering water from air it is going from faster to a slower medium and should refract the opposite way. Right?

That is why I said sound should be the opposite because i was refering to sound refracting in the opposite direction as opposed to light when entering water.

nasu
#4
Nov21-12, 03:43 PM
P: 1,969
The diffrence between refraction of sound and light

The image you show is indeed not realistic for sound waves.
When sound enters water from air the angle between the normal and the beam increases.

Here is a nice site where you can experiment (virtualy):
http://www.ndt-ed.org/EducationResou...tionsnells.htm

I think the problem may originate in the author of the site reproducing an image from Dr Russell's site (they give a link to it, in blue) without realizing that that specific image illustrates refraction of light.
mfb
#5
Nov21-12, 05:13 PM
Mentor
P: 11,631
Quote Quote by Sjonsjon View Post
That is why I said sound should be the opposite because i was refering to sound refracting in the opposite direction as opposed to light when entering water.
Ah ok, your remark was specific to water/air and not related to the general concept. Well, that is right.
Sjonsjon
#6
Nov21-12, 06:21 PM
P: 3
Quote Quote by nasu View Post
The image you show is indeed not realistic for sound waves.
When sound enters water from air the angle between the normal and the beam increases.

Here is a nice site where you can experiment (virtualy):
http://www.ndt-ed.org/EducationResou...tionsnells.htm

I think the problem may originate in the author of the site reproducing an image from Dr Russell's site (they give a link to it, in blue) without realizing that that specific image illustrates refraction of light.
Thanks for the reply. I think you are right, must have been an oversight on there part, but it confused the hell out of me.
harrylin
#7
Nov22-12, 06:35 AM
P: 3,185
Quote Quote by Sjonsjon View Post
I was thinking about refraction of waves and Im a little unsure. I wanted to run my understanding through you guys to make sure Im right.

So

The general rule is when a wave goes from a slower medium to a faster medium the wave should turn sligtly away from the faster medium when it enters it. And we can turn it around and say when a wave goes from a faster medium to a slower medium the wave should turn slightly towards the medium when it enters it. [..]
Hi Sjonson, welcome to physics forums!

It is the same for all waves. And instead of learning it with words, it is much more useful to understand it with the Huygens construction:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Huygens%27_principle
sophiecentaur
#8
Nov22-12, 07:28 AM
Sci Advisor
PF Gold
sophiecentaur's Avatar
P: 11,948
The angles involved depend on the Wavelength - which, of course, relates to speed. In water, the wavelength of sound is about fifteen times the speed in air so it would be quite difficult to do a scale diagram what would make immediate sense. Of course, 'that diagram' is the wrong way round and, imo, a rather sloppy bit of presentation - if it is trying to be helpful.

There is another very important issue with the passage of sound from air into water. When waves pass from one medium to another, there is always some reflection of energy (a reflected wave). The greater the difference in refractive index, the more is reflected. In the case of Air into Water - or the other way, the mis-match is huge and most of the sound energy is reflected. That's one reason why it all goes quiet when we stick out heads under water.
nasu
#9
Nov22-12, 07:39 AM
P: 1,969
Quote Quote by sophiecentaur View Post
In water, the wavelength of sound is about fifteen times the speed in air so it would be quite difficult to do a scale diagram what would make immediate sense.
This did not come out very well.
The speed in water is about 4 times the speed in air (a little more than 4).
So the wavelength in water is about 4-5 times larger than the wavelength in air (for the same frequency, of course).
sophiecentaur
#10
Nov22-12, 08:54 AM
Sci Advisor
PF Gold
sophiecentaur's Avatar
P: 11,948
Quote Quote by nasu View Post
This did not come out very well.
The speed in water is about 4 times the speed in air (a little more than 4).
So the wavelength in water is about 4-5 times larger than the wavelength in air (for the same frequency, of course).
Whoops - I was quoting the water speed in ft/s Durrrr. Why can we still encounter those pesky Imperial Units on the Webb?

The other bit was correct though!


Register to reply

Related Discussions
What is the formula for sound refraction? General Physics 25
Refraction of sound General Physics 1
Refraction of sound and light General Physics 7
Refraction of light Introductory Physics Homework 6
Refraction of light! help General Physics 14