concave mirrors mystery


by djnnt
Tags: concave, mirrors, mystery
djnnt
djnnt is offline
#1
Jun1-08, 03:00 PM
P: 3
ok my doubt is wen i look at a concave mirror(behind focus of mirror) i can see image of my face inverted inside the mirror,,,why does this hapen?? acc to mirror laws i shud get a real image tht too not inside the mirror but outside it!!!
y do i observe an inverted virtual image in case of concave mirror..(u can try it out by just taknin a spoon and look at it u can find ur inverted image inside the spoon)..
wat is the reason behind it???(as far as i knw drawing ray diagrams did not lead to any conclusion)
Phys.Org News Partner Physics news on Phys.org
Information storage for the next generation of plastic computers
Scientists capture ultrafast snapshots of light-driven superconductivity
Progress in the fight against quantum dissipation
Doc Al
Doc Al is offline
#2
Jun1-08, 03:25 PM
Mentor
Doc Al's Avatar
P: 40,875
The real, inverted image is in front of the spoon (looks like it's suspended in air). See this: Concave Mirror Image
aguycalledwil
aguycalledwil is offline
#3
Jun1-08, 03:48 PM
P: 37
Basically, the light is pointed inward, due to the angle of the concave surface. It travels inward until the point where the light crosses, creating an upside down image. If you get close enough to the spoon, you will be the right way around again!

djnnt
djnnt is offline
#4
Jun4-08, 05:29 AM
P: 3

concave mirrors mystery


i still dnt get it... how is it not explained by ray optics? n wat did u mean by "get close enough to the spoon,you ll be the right way around"?
Doc Al
Doc Al is offline
#5
Jun4-08, 06:57 AM
Mentor
Doc Al's Avatar
P: 40,875
Quote Quote by djnnt View Post
how is it not explained by ray optics? n wat did u mean by "get close enough to the spoon,you ll be the right way around"?
It is explained by ray optics. Look at the link I provided for the details. When the object is outside the focal length, the image is real and inverted; when inside the focal length, virtual and right side up.
robertm
robertm is offline
#6
Jun4-08, 09:27 AM
P: 290
Quote Quote by djnnt View Post
i still dnt get it... how is it not explained by ray optics? n wat did u mean by "get close enough to the spoon,you ll be the right way around"?
And if you were able to crawl inside your spoon, i.e. be within the focal length, you will see yourself 'right-side-up'.
Nick89
Nick89 is offline
#7
Jun4-08, 02:31 PM
P: 550
Quote Quote by robertm View Post
And if you were able to crawl inside your spoon, i.e. be within the focal length, you will see yourself 'right-side-up'.
Since a spoon is so small, you can't see this effect (unless you have really good eyes lol). Try a shaving magnefying mirror instead. If you use it like you normally would (at short distance) you are magnified and right side up. If you move away from it, you will turn upside down!
djnnt
djnnt is offline
#8
Jun4-08, 04:11 PM
P: 3
@nick89
thtz wat i exactly wanted to knw y is it tht i can see an inverted image(wh is virtual,since i can see it inside the mirrror) wel thru my ray diagrams i was only able to find out tht i ll get a real image but i dint understand why i m seeing a virtual inverted image!!!
Doc Al
Doc Al is offline
#9
Jun4-08, 04:43 PM
Mentor
Doc Al's Avatar
P: 40,875
Quote Quote by djnnt View Post
...but i dint understand why i m seeing a virtual inverted image!!!
The inverted image is a real image, not a virtual one. Take something small--like the tip of a pen--and move it towards the spoon. At first you'll see a real, inverted image, which if you look carefully enough will appear to be floating in front of the spoon (between object and spoon). When you move it close enough, the image will flip into a virtual image.
mitcha11
mitcha11 is offline
#10
Jun5-08, 07:18 AM
P: 2
is this the reason why they use convex mirrors for security mirrors?
Doc Al
Doc Al is offline
#11
Jun5-08, 11:22 AM
Mentor
Doc Al's Avatar
P: 40,875
Quote Quote by mitcha11 View Post
is this the reason why they use convex mirrors for security mirrors?
Partly. Convex mirrors do form virtual images, which are always right side up and easier to interpret. But the main reason convex mirrors are used for security (and other applications, such as passenger side mirrors in cars) is because of their greater field of view.
Jimlee008
Jimlee008 is offline
#12
May9-10, 04:54 AM
P: 7
Could someone answer the question please? Does a concave mirror focus real rays of light to form a REAL image in front of the mirror, which can only be caught on paper AND at the same time it is seen IN the spoon as a virtual image that is inverted. All texts do not show the ray diagram for this case.
jtbell
jtbell is offline
#13
May9-10, 12:40 PM
Mentor
jtbell's Avatar
P: 11,224
Does a concave mirror focus real rays of light to form a REAL image in front of the mirror, which can only be caught on paper AND at the same time it is seen IN the spoon as a virtual image that is inverted.
You do not get a virtual image and a real image at the same time, from the same object. Depending on the location of the object, you get one or the other of the following:

A. a real image in front of the mirror, which you can either capture on paper, or look at directly provided that you are far enough away from the mirror. In this case the image is inverted.

B. a virtual image behind the mirror, which you cannot capture on paper, but you can look at it directly. In this case the image is upright.
Jimlee008
Jimlee008 is offline
#14
May9-10, 10:12 PM
P: 7
Hi JTBELL:

I'm a UofT Physics Major and now a highschool physics teacher (obviously not a very good one:). I know what the ray diagrams are suppose to look like but just like the guy/gal who started this thread, I think the question has been miscommunicated. Let's try again:

When the object is between C and F, the ray diagram puts the image underneath the PA, and it's larger and clearly REAL. If a piece of paper is put there, this REAl image will be caught. If a piece of paper is NOT placed there what would an observer, behind the object, see in the concave mirror. Everyone would agree that he would see a virtual image of the object inside the mirror, inverted and larger.

This appears to be in conflict with the 5 or so possible ray diagrams for objects between C and F.

Another way of stating this is how could the real inverted image that is formed in front of the concave mirror same side as the object, "floating" as DOC Al puts it, be viewed in the concave mirror as an inverted larger image - that's what i see:)

Thanks ALL
Doc Al
Doc Al is offline
#15
May10-10, 07:15 AM
Mentor
Doc Al's Avatar
P: 40,875
Quote Quote by Jimlee008 View Post
When the object is between C and F, the ray diagram puts the image underneath the PA, and it's larger and clearly REAL. If a piece of paper is put there, this REAl image will be caught.
OK.
If a piece of paper is NOT placed there what would an observer, behind the object, see in the concave mirror.
Assuming the observer is far enough back that the image is in front of him, he'd see that real image.
Everyone would agree that he would see a virtual image of the object inside the mirror, inverted and larger.
No, why would you think that?
jtbell
jtbell is offline
#16
May10-10, 07:39 AM
Mentor
jtbell's Avatar
P: 11,224
Quote Quote by Jimlee008 View Post
When the object is between C and F, the ray diagram puts the image underneath the PA, and it's larger and clearly REAL. If a piece of paper is put there, this REAl image will be caught.
Correct.

If a piece of paper is NOT placed there what would an observer, behind the object, see in the concave mirror. Everyone would agree that he would see a virtual image of the object inside the mirror, inverted and larger.
No, he would see the same real image, floating in front of the mirror. You can verify that the image is actually located in front of the mirror as follows.

First put the screen in place and focus the image. Position a pencil or other pointer-like object so it's touching the image. Remove the screen without moving the pencil. It helps if you have the pencil mounted on a stand or support so you can keep it fixed in the same position. Now look into the mirror so you see the image and the pencil simultaneously (the actual pencil, not its image in the mirror). As you move your head from side to side, the image appears to be "stuck" to the pencil. Furthermore, if you're close enough to the image that your eyes' 3-D depth perception works, you can actually see that the image is floating in front of the mirror because your eyes will focus on it at that location.
sophiecentaur
sophiecentaur is offline
#17
May10-10, 08:08 AM
Sci Advisor
PF Gold
sophiecentaur's Avatar
P: 11,352
If you want to prove to yourself whether or not the image in front of the mirror is real, use some tissue paper just off axis and you will find that you can focus an image of the Sun on it. If it focuses, it's real.
Jimlee008
Jimlee008 is offline
#18
May10-10, 03:11 PM
P: 7
Re: Doc Al's comment ...why do you think its virtual?

Thanks Doc and JT for the response.

When you draw the ray diagram for an object between C and F, you get a REAL image, larger and inverted.

When I look into the mirror it sure appears that the image is being projected from behind the mirror, so obviously one would conclude the image is VIRTUAL.

If I understand what you and JT are getting at, when we look at the mirror we are actually seeing the REAL image as predicted by optics to be in front of the mirror. How can we see this real image if there is no paper to catch it??? Are we seeing a REAL image that is floating in mid air like a hologram.

Hope you see the confusion:)


Register to reply

Related Discussions
Concave Parabolic Mirrors Introductory Physics Homework 3
concave mirrors Introductory Physics Homework 1
Concave/Convex-lens and mirrors Introductory Physics Homework 2
Curved Mirrors (concave) Introductory Physics Homework 3