Quick Question about Acceleration/Gravity

  • Thread starter Thread starter nukeman
  • Start date Start date
AI Thread Summary
The discussion revolves around calculating acceleration due to gravity using the formula d = 1/2at², with specific values for distance and time provided for two objects. The calculations revealed inaccuracies in the measured times, leading to unrealistic acceleration values of 18.04 m/s² and 14.16 m/s², prompting a suggestion to aim for a more accurate time of around 0.95 seconds. The importance of human error in timing was acknowledged, especially in a lab setting. Additionally, a follow-up question about calculating the expected value of gravitational acceleration using Earth's mass and radius was posed, with the derived value being 9.53 m/s², close to the expected 9.81 m/s². Overall, the discussion emphasizes the significance of accurate measurements and calculations in physics experiments.
nukeman
Messages
651
Reaction score
0

Homework Statement



Ok, I have 2 calculations I need help with.

First: For an object dropped from rest, the distance of fall "d" is related to the time of fall "t" and acceleration due to gravity "a" by

d = 1/2at2 (2 as in squared)

So, DISTANCE is 4.42 meters and time of fall for object 1 is .70 seconds and object 2 is .79 seconds

Lets first get through that one, but just incase, ill add in the 2nd problem I must figure out:

2)if we measure "d" and "t" we can solve for the accerlation, "a":

a = 2d/t squared

Homework Equations





The Attempt at a Solution

 
Physics news on Phys.org
As you were told recently, you're meant to have an attempt and show people what your stuck on.
Q1
2*4.42/(.7^2)=a
now put that in your calculator as is and it will tell you what the acceleration is!
If this was part of a lab or something your values are fairly inaccurate..
 
pat666 said:
As you were told recently, you're meant to have an attempt and show people what your stuck on.
Q1
2*4.42/(.7^2)=a
now put that in your calculator as is and it will tell you what the acceleration is!
If this was part of a lab or something your values are fairly inaccurate..

Yes it is apart of a lab. Can you help me out? Maybe add something extra to this calculation?

Yes I thought so too about the variables: should they not be pretty much the same? It was time with a stop watch, so I am assuming its human error. Correct?

Did I do this right for: a = 2d/t squared


Answer is: a = 4.33
 
Last edited:
nothing extra can be added, certainly this experiment will be very inaccurate but your teacher will expect that. look up human reaction times etc for things to write about.
Also you could do what I used to do which is to find what the answer should be and mold the results around that, its a bit questionable but it makes your experimental procedure look very accurate.
eg for this experiment you know that a is 9.81m/s^2 so 9.81=2*4.42/t^2 and from that the time you should have is 0.949 seconds. In this experiment you would NEVER get a result that accurate but perhaps say you timed 0.85seconds or something. Also you should have repeated your drop time at least 5 times for this not twice!
 
PhanthomJay said:
Please do not double post.

https://www.physicsforums.com/showthread.php?t=434973

Fortunately, Pat666 picked up on this again. Otherwise, if someone else responded, you'd be back to square 1 again.

Sorry, I did not explain my self properly in my first post, so I thought I would just start a new one. I did not start it because I was not satisfied with the result. Sorry If I broke the rules.

So...should I continue to add in this thread or go to my old thread?>
 
This one
 
Thanks,

Did I do this right for: a = 2d/t squared


Answer is: a = 4.33
 
NO, write out exactly what you put in your calculator
 
  • #10
pat666 said:
NO, write out exactly what you put in your calculator

hmmm..

2*4.42/(.7^2)=a


So I went first (.7 ^2) = 0.49

Then I went 2 x 4.42 = 8.84

8.84 / 0.49 = 18.04

Ahh wait, I messed up on first calculation, is the above answer right this time?
 
  • #11
with t=0.7
a=2*4.42/(.7^2)
a=18.04m/s^2 correct

with t=0.79
a=14.16m/s^2

Those are terrible values for the acceleration due to gravity on Earth, I would really consider altering your time closer to 0.95s.
 
  • #12
pat666 said:
with t=0.7
a=2*4.42/(.7^2)
a=18.04m/s^2 correct

with t=0.79
a=14.16m/s^2

Those are terrible values for the acceleration due to gravity on Earth, I would really consider altering your time closer to 0.95s.

lol, ok so I got that correct.

Yes, seems my lab partner did not work the stop watch correct.

We had to drop a wood ball, and a lead ball. Now, it should be the exact same time correct?

So your saying a better time would be around .95s ?
 
  • #13
only assuming the two balls had close to the same physical dimensions and assuming that you dropped from a low enough height (which you did) that the lighter ball did not reach terminal velocity. Just though I'd mention that because a lot of people seem to think two objects dropped from the same height will always take the same amount of time to fall regardless of mass and shape, this is not true but IN YOUR CASE IT IS.

Yes 0.95 seconds will give you the exact answer but like I said this experiment will never yield that, I'd go for a time like 0.865 seconds or something but if you do TELL YOUR LAB PARTNER.
 
  • #14
Hey thanks, really appreciate this help!

Just 1 thing I am having alittle trouble doing:

Question: Use the equation g = G Me/r^2 to calculate the expexted calue of the accelaeration, g (in m/s2). The mass and radius of Earth are 5.7974 x 10^24 kg and 6.37 x 10^6 m, respectively.

?

pat666 said:
only assuming the two balls had close to the same physical dimensions and assuming that you dropped from a low enough height (which you did) that the lighter ball did not reach terminal velocity. Just though I'd mention that because a lot of people seem to think two objects dropped from the same height will always take the same amount of time to fall regardless of mass and shape, this is not true but IN YOUR CASE IT IS.

Yes 0.95 seconds will give you the exact answer but like I said this experiment will never yield that, I'd go for a time like 0.865 seconds or something but if you do TELL YOUR LAB PARTNER.
 
  • #15
again its a simple matter of subbing in your constants,
This formula is derived from Newtons law of gravitation, F=Gm1m2/r^2
anyway G=6.67*10^-11Nm^2/Kg^2
so g=6.67*10^-11*5.7974 x 10^24/(6.37 x 10^6)^2
so g = 9.53m/s^2
obviously g should be 9.81m/s^2 its just rounding errors.
 
Back
Top