How Does Non-Ergodicity Impact the Resting State of Living Cells?

AI Thread Summary
The discussion focuses on the physical analysis of living cells, emphasizing the significance of non-ergodicity in understanding their resting state. The resting state, as described by Gilbert Ling, is characterized by lower entropy due to bound quasi-crystallized water, which is crucial for cellular energy storage. The authors propose a new thermodynamic approach that aligns with Ling's model while incorporating non-ergodicity to explain physiological phenomena. However, skepticism exists regarding the concept of structured water, which lacks empirical support despite its prominence in discussions about cellular dynamics. The conversation highlights the need for further exploration and validation of these theories within the context of biological physics.
Vladimir Matveev
Messages
23
Reaction score
7
Dear Colleagues,

I would like to submit to your court the article in which we attempt a physical analysis of living matter. Biology is a very difficult field for physics as a result errors are very likely. We would appreciate guidance on possible errors.

Prokhorenko DV and Matveev VV. The significance of non-ergodic property of statistical mechanics systems for understanding resting state of a living cell. British Journal of Mathematics & Computer Science. 2011;1(2):46-86.Abstract

A better grasp of the physical foundations of life is necessary before we can understand the processes occurring inside a living cell. In his physical theory of the cell, American physiologist Gilbert Ling introduced an important notion of the resting state of the cell. He describes this state as an independent stable thermodynamic state of a living substance in which it has stored all the energy it needs to perform all kinds of biological work. This state is characterized by lower entropy of the system than in an active state. The main contribution to this reduction in entropy is made by the cellular water (the dominant component with a concentration of 14 M) which remains in a bound quasi-crystallized state in a resting cell. When the cell becomes active the water gets desorbed and the system’s entropy goes up sharply while the free energy of the system decreases as it is used up for biological work. However, Ling’s approach is primarily qualitative in terms of thermodynamics and it needs to be characterized more specifically. To this end, we propose a new thermodynamic approach to studying Ling’s model of the living cell (Ling’s cell), the centrepiece off which is the non-ergodicity property which has recently been proved for a wide range of systems in statistical mechanics (Prokhorenko, 2009). In many ways this new thermodynamics overlaps with the standard quasi-stationary thermodynamics and is therefore compatible with the principles of the Ling cell, however a number of new specific results take into account the existence of several non-trivial motion integrals communicating with each other, whose existence follows from the nonergodicity of the system (Ling’s cell). These results allowed us to develop general thermodynamic approaches to explaining some of the well-known physiological phenomena, which can be used for further physical analysis of these phenomena using specific physical models.

Full text: http://vladimirmatveev.ru
 
Last edited:
Physics news on Phys.org


Vladimir Matveev said:
Dear Colleagues,

I would like to submit to your court the article in which we attempt a physical analysis of living matter. Biology is a very difficult field for physics as a result errors are very likely. We would appreciate guidance on possible errors.

"Structured Water" (which seems to be the main central theme) has been proposed many times to account for cellular dynamics- Ling's papers and ideas are featured prominently in Pollack's "Cells, Gels, and the Engines of Life".

Unfortunately, there is no evidence for structured water.

This does not discount the useful themes of non-ergodicity and the glass transition in describing cellular dynamics. Paul Janmey, in particular, has done some nice work along these lines.
 


Andy Resnick said:
"Structured Water" (which seems to be the main central theme) has been proposed many times to account for cellular dynamics- Ling's papers and ideas are featured prominently in Pollack's "Cells, Gels, and the Engines of Life".

Unfortunately, there is no evidence for structured water.

This does not discount the useful themes of non-ergodicity and the glass transition in describing cellular dynamics. Paul Janmey, in particular, has done some nice work along these lines.
Several strong evidences for existence of structured water you may find in the Pollack's presentation:
 
Last edited by a moderator:
I have recently been really interested in the derivation of Hamiltons Principle. On my research I found that with the term ##m \cdot \frac{d}{dt} (\frac{dr}{dt} \cdot \delta r) = 0## (1) one may derivate ##\delta \int (T - V) dt = 0## (2). The derivation itself I understood quiet good, but what I don't understand is where the equation (1) came from, because in my research it was just given and not derived from anywhere. Does anybody know where (1) comes from or why from it the...
Back
Top