New Reply

Quick conceptual question about disconnecting battery!

 
Share Thread
Mar14-12, 09:06 PM   #1
 

Quick conceptual question about disconnecting battery!


If there is a parallel plate capacitor, connected to a battery, which is then disconnected, there is NO voltage now, but "Q" (charge) on the capacitor remains the same. YES OR NO? I think yes.
PhysOrg.com science news on PhysOrg.com

>> New language discovery reveals linguistic insights
>> US official: Solar plane to help ground energy use (Update)
>> Four microphones, computer algorithm enough to produce 3-D model of simple, convex room
Mar14-12, 09:37 PM   #2
 
Recognitions:
Homework Helper Homework Help
Quote by xchococatx View Post
If there is a parallel plate capacitor, connected to a battery, which is then disconnected, there is NO voltage now, but "Q" (charge) on the capacitor remains the same. YES OR NO? I think yes.
What is your reasoning?
Mar14-12, 09:58 PM   #3
 
Well basically I'm thinking that a capacitor stores charges (or energy) so, onces its all charged up by a battery, I don't see how it could lose those charges...even when the battery is disconnected. (immediately anyways, it wouldn't be all gone I don't think) Why I was thinking about this was because if the battery is now disconnected, and you wanted to calculate the work needed to insert a dielectric, fitting perfectly between the 2 plates, since there is no voltage, I don't see how you could calculate the work unless you used the original charge of the capacitor (without dielectric). (By means of E=Q^2/2C) So in order to use the original charge of the capacitor, I figured charge has to stay in the capacitor even if the battery is disconnected.
Mar14-12, 10:17 PM   #4
 
Recognitions:
Homework Helper Homework Help

Quick conceptual question about disconnecting battery!


Quote by xchococatx View Post
Well basically I'm thinking that a capacitor stores charges (or energy) so, onces its all charged up by a battery, I don't see how it could lose those charges...even when the battery is disconnected. (immediately anyways, it wouldn't be all gone I don't think) Why I was thinking about this was because if the battery is now disconnected, and you wanted to calculate the work needed to insert a dielectric, fitting perfectly between the 2 plates, since there is no voltage, I don't see how you could calculate the work unless you used the original charge of the capacitor (without dielectric). (By means of E=Q^2/2C) So in order to use the original charge of the capacitor, I figured charge has to stay in the capacitor even if the battery is disconnected.
Okay, your reasoning is pretty good. Note that the charged capacitor will maintain a voltage (potential difference) according to Q = C*V, even without an external voltage source applied. Of course, if the capacitance changes (due, say, to the insertion of a dielectric) the voltage will change accordingly if the charges have nowhere to go.
New Reply

Similar discussions for: Quick conceptual question about disconnecting battery!
Thread Forum Replies
Quick Battery Question Engineering, Comp Sci, & Technology Homework 0
Just a quick conceptual question Introductory Physics Homework 2
Quick conceptual question about inductance Introductory Physics Homework 3
Circuit Switch Disconnecting Battery Introductory Physics Homework 8
SHM Quick Conceptual Question Introductory Physics Homework 3