when ice melts in a full glass of water, will the water overflow


by bobsmith76
Tags: glass, melts, overflow, water
bobsmith76
bobsmith76 is offline
#1
Mar21-12, 05:43 PM
P: 339
If you have an ice cube in a full glass of water when the ice cube melts will the water flow over, be the same, or decrease? My book says the answer is stay the same, but I can't figure out why. Ice was less dense than water which is why is floats. Using this equation:

B = ρVg which when solved for V becomes

B/(ρg) = V

I would think the buoyancy would stay the same as the ice cube melts so the density ρ increases as the ice melts, so if you increase the denominator, the whole number decreases. So the water should decrease, not stay the same, unless the increase in density is compensated for by an increase in Buoyancy.
Phys.Org News Partner Physics news on Phys.org
The hemihelix: Scientists discover a new shape using rubber bands (w/ video)
Mapping the road to quantum gravity
Chameleon crystals could enable active camouflage (w/ video)
DaveC426913
DaveC426913 is offline
#2
Mar21-12, 05:49 PM
DaveC426913's Avatar
P: 15,325
I shouldn't just hand this to you, I should walk you through it, but you're made some effort - and the diagram is right there...

fluidistic
fluidistic is offline
#3
Mar21-12, 05:52 PM
PF Gold
fluidistic's Avatar
P: 3,173
An also interesting question would be why the melting of icebergs increase the level of oceans (I think it does, but I could be wrong).

bobsmith76
bobsmith76 is offline
#4
Mar21-12, 06:11 PM
P: 339

when ice melts in a full glass of water, will the water overflow


Ok, I'm using this equation now

ρwaterAh = ρcubeVcube

As the volume decreases so too does the area and the height.
rcgldr
rcgldr is offline
#5
Mar21-12, 06:22 PM
HW Helper
P: 6,931
Quote Quote by bobsmith76 View Post
If you have an ice cube in a full glass of water when the ice cube melts will the water flow over, be the same, or decrease?
As already posted the same.

One somewhat novel exception is that that if you had a higher density form of ice, such as ice III (or higher stage of ice), it would be resting on the bottom of the glass instead of floating. In this case, as it melts, the density would decrease and the water level would rise.

Quote Quote by fluidistic View Post
An also interesting question would be why the melting of icebergs increase the level of oceans.
It's the melting of glaciers which are currently supported by land masses, not the oceans. As they melt, the water eventually runs off into the oceans.
fluidistic
fluidistic is offline
#6
Mar21-12, 06:55 PM
PF Gold
fluidistic's Avatar
P: 3,173
Ok thanks rcgldr!
thoreaulylazy
thoreaulylazy is offline
#7
Mar21-12, 07:15 PM
P: 1
If the ice cube was chained to the base of the glass, then as it melts, it turns into denser water, so the water level will lower.

If the ice cube is buoyant, then the amount of water it displaces is equal to its own WEIGHT (not mass as someone else wrote); as it melts, the water level remains the same. The ice cube is less dense than water, so it will be "sticking up" above the water, and as it melts, it turns into denser water, occupying the same volume as the submerged portion of the ice cube.

If the ice cube had helium bubbles in it, then the helium would add even greater buoyancy, as it has negative weight against the atmosphere, and as the helium leaked out, the ice cube would WEIGH more (even though, without the helium bubbles, it has less mass), and so the water level will rise.

It is important to distinguish weight and mass. There's only a notion of "displacing" water because there's a force applied on the water to _prevent_ it from natural displacement (brownian motion). In this case, gravity and the contours of the glass. The water has a downward force keeping it from naturally flying out of the glass (gravity) - a weigh scale can measure this force. A buoyant object also applies a downward force - again measurable by a weigh scale. The water moves /upward/ in the presence of the buoyant object trying to go /downward/ because of the contours of the glass. If the glass were a pipe, you've just re-invented a pipe-cleaner and helped the liquid move further down the pipe. Because the glass has a strong bottom, the /bottom/ of the glass applies an upward force against the water. The water level then rises as the buoyant object submerges. If the only forces involved are gravity, then you'll get the same answer whether you use mass or weight, but if you introduce any other forces, the upward force on helium, or the downward force of a magnetic field tugging a buoyant object down, you'll get the incorrect answer using mass. For example, if you have an iron warship and a magnetic field pushing it downward, it will displace more water than an iron warship of equal mass without that additional downward force.
Causetic
Causetic is offline
#8
Mar21-12, 09:53 PM
P: 4
Your diagram is sublime :D
Nugatory
Nugatory is offline
#9
Mar22-12, 12:17 AM
Sci Advisor
Thanks
P: 2,965
Would it be mischievous to point out that the melting of the ice cube will change the temperature of the water, and hence its volume?

Of course this effect will be temporary; eventually the whole thing returns to ambient temperature.
ryan albery
ryan albery is offline
#10
Mar22-12, 01:03 AM
P: 69
Think of a boat filled with ice that's floating in a lake. The ice in the boat melts, but the mass doesn't change, and the waterline stays the same.
A.T.
A.T. is offline
#11
Mar22-12, 07:29 AM
P: 3,551
There are some modifications to that question:

What happens to the water level during melting if the ice has...

a) ... a cavity with air inside?

b) ... a cavity with molten water inside?

c) ... a piece of lead inside?
DaveC426913
DaveC426913 is offline
#12
Mar22-12, 08:18 AM
DaveC426913's Avatar
P: 15,325
Quote Quote by Nugatory View Post
Would it be mischievous to point out that the melting of the ice cube will change the temperature of the water, and hence its volume?

Of course this effect will be temporary; eventually the whole thing returns to ambient temperature.
No, that is already covered by the temperature causing the water to be ice. Think of the water and ice as a closed system and consider the average temperature of this system.


Register to reply

Related Discussions
Change in internal energy when ice melts to water at 0C General Physics 18
Cooling hot water by adding in cool water and draining out the hot water - Formulae General Physics 5
What wavelengths of Infrared light are blocked by water, glass and {water and glass}? Electrical Engineering 0
Using snell's law, observations thru a glass of water & glass of air Introductory Physics Homework 2
help calculating water flow into an overflow... General Engineering 4