Classical Mechanics: Why can we cancel the derivative of dt from these equations?

In summary, the problem in the book "Classical Mechanics" by Goldstein is related to the cancellation of the derivative of dt in equations involving trigonometric functions. The reason for this is due to the connection between tangent bundles and differential forms. In simpler terms, it is because it works. However, the explanation of this connection is not trivial and can be better understood through L'Hôpital's rule.
  • #1
Another
104
5
CM 1.png


CM 2.png

problem in this book : classical mechanics goldstein

Why can we cancel the derivative of dt from these equations?

e.g.
##\frac{d(x)}{dt} + \frac{b sin\theta}{2} \frac{d(\theta)}{dt} = asin\theta \frac{d(\phi)}{dt}##
## x +\frac{b \theta sin\theta}{2} = a \phi sin\theta ##

because I think
##\frac{d(x)}{dt} + \frac{b sin\theta}{2} \frac{d(\theta)}{dt} = asin\theta \frac{d(\phi)}{dt}##
##\frac{d}{dt}(x - (b/2) cos\theta) = asin\theta \frac{d(\phi)}{dt}## due to ##sin\theta ## dependent on t. we can't cancel dt

Or it is just only divider. So We can cancel
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
The short answer is: because it works.
The long answer is: because of the connection between tangent bundles and differential forms.

The long answer is not really trivial and I'm not sure I can explain it without making mistakes.

Let's consider an easy case: ##\dot{x}=\dot{y}.## If we treat the expressions ##\dfrac{dx}{dt}## as ordinary quotients, then ##dx=dy## is obvious. We could either imagine that the infinitesimals are tiny distances, which is rigorously seen wrong, or we could invoke L'Hôpital's rule, which is a bit better, since ##\frac{dx}{dt}## is an abbreviation of a limit process.

Let's see what ##dx=dy## tells us. Integration yields ##\int dx = \int dy## and thus ##x=y+C##, which is what we would expect from ##\dot{x}=\dot{y}.##
 
  • Like
Likes vanhees71

1. Why can we cancel the derivative of dt from these equations?

The derivative of dt can be cancelled because it represents the infinitesimal change in time, which is considered to be a constant in classical mechanics. Therefore, it does not affect the overall calculation and can be disregarded.

2. Is it always valid to cancel the derivative of dt in classical mechanics equations?

In most cases, yes. However, there are certain situations where the derivative of dt cannot be cancelled, such as when dealing with time-dependent variables or when using non-inertial reference frames. It is important to carefully consider the context and assumptions of the problem before cancelling the derivative of dt.

3. What is the significance of cancelling the derivative of dt in classical mechanics?

Cancelling the derivative of dt allows us to simplify equations and make them easier to solve. It also helps to eliminate any potential errors that may arise from differentiating with respect to time.

4. Can we cancel other derivatives in classical mechanics equations?

Yes, we can cancel other derivatives as long as they are considered to be constants in the context of the problem. However, it is important to be cautious and make sure that the cancellation is valid and does not affect the accuracy of the solution.

5. Are there any other mathematical simplifications that can be made in classical mechanics equations?

Yes, there are various mathematical simplifications that can be made in classical mechanics equations, such as using trigonometric identities, simplifying fractions, and using the properties of logarithms. These simplifications can help to make the equations more manageable and easier to solve.

Similar threads

  • Mechanics
Replies
17
Views
187
Replies
12
Views
2K
Replies
2
Views
869
Replies
45
Views
2K
Replies
14
Views
2K
Replies
2
Views
1K
Replies
8
Views
407
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
6
Views
2K
Replies
8
Views
240
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
10
Views
268
Back
Top