Recent content by E8(8)

  1. E

    Finally, Garrett's model with 3 generations

    First of all, it is not a criticism, it is a fact. The fact that Garret refers to a Cartan geometry as a "deforming Lie group" is misleading to the point of being absurd. Writing an abstract saying "The universe is a deforming Lie group" is a joke, plain and simple. It is like if someone writes...
  2. E

    Finally, Garrett's model with 3 generations

    You are not generalizing anything. You are just using Cartan geometry and you are not even doing that right. The fact that you are calling "deforming Lie group" a Cartan geometry, which is something very classical and very well known, is simply absurd, ridiculous. The abstract of your paper...
  3. E

    Finally, Garrett's model with 3 generations

    I am obviously not asking about the mathematical formulation of Cartan geometry. I know that is a solid theory of mathematics, and I know Sharpe's book. You are obviously evading the question. I will repeat it: What do you mean by "deforming a Lie group"? What do you mean by "variations of the...
  4. E

    Finally, Garrett's model with 3 generations

    My objection is not vague. What do you mean by "variations of the Maurer-Cartan form"? How is that related to deforming the underlying Lie group? Can you give a mathematical reference were such concept is defined and explored?
  5. E

    Finally, Garrett's model with 3 generations

    Can you give a a precise definition of what you mean by "deformation of E_8"? What you just said does not seem to have any sense. Can you at least point out to a mathematical reference where such concept is defined and explored?
  6. E

    Finally, Garrett's model with 3 generations

    Can you give a precise sensible mathematical definition of what you mean by "deformation of E_8"?
  7. E

    Finally, Garrett's model with 3 generations

    What do you mean by a "deformation of E_8"?
  8. E

    Finally, Garrett's model with 3 generations

    http://inspirehep.net/record/1236254 shows that this paper: http://inspirehep.net/record/859554?ln=en is incorrect. That is clear even from the abstract of http://inspirehep.net/record/1236254. So first of all, Lisi has sent a completely incorrect paper to arxiv. Then, they fix Lisi's...
  9. E

    Finally, Garrett's model with 3 generations

    This is not a serious paper, that it is easy to see in a first lecture: it is inconsistent an incorrect. About this other paper of Garret Lisi: http://inspirehep.net/record/859554?ln=en It has been shown to be incorrect here: http://inspirehep.net/record/1236254 So end of discussion. I am...
Back
Top