Recent content by Ideassimples

  1. I

    B Doubt about the relativity of simultaneity

    You're right! I don't even know what I'm doing anymore.
  2. I

    B Doubt about the relativity of simultaneity

    I think you are joking, the average is: [f*(x/y)+f*(y/x)]/2=f
  3. I

    B Doubt about the relativity of simultaneity

    It is as simple as understanding this: (x / y) * (y / x) = 1 If you measure the CMB above the mean in a certain direction, it gives below the mean in the same proportion in the opposite direction.
  4. I

    B Doubt about the relativity of simultaneity

    I thought this was clear since Penzias and Wilson discovered the CMB in 1965.
  5. I

    B Doubt about the relativity of simultaneity

    At no point do I question that the universe is isotropic and homogeneous.
  6. I

    B Doubt about the relativity of simultaneity

    When an observer measures the mean temperature of the CMB he only gets a number. Even so. If the mean temperature of the CMB did not change, the universe did not expand, or it expanded and contracted in different regions, which could not have happened. In any case, it is an irrelevant question...
  7. I

    B Doubt about the relativity of simultaneity

    We agree that there is a frame of reference in which the same temperature of the cosmic microwave background is seen in all directions. If an observer sees different temperatures of the CMB in different directions, it is because it is moving relative to the first reference frame. I understand...
  8. I

    B Doubt about the relativity of simultaneity

    The postulate that the entire universe is just as old seems difficult to question. Obviously general relativity does not need this assumption.
  9. I

    B Doubt about the relativity of simultaneity

    If the mean temperature of the cosmic microwave background is the same, the size of the universe is the same. I understand that if different parts of the universe expanded to different degrees, then some parts expanded and others contracted, which cannot have happened. It is an interesting...
  10. I

    B Doubt about the relativity of simultaneity

    I believe that it is true. If we start from the postulate that the entire universe is just as old at any given time, the only difference between measurements is due to the Doppler effect. An observer can see the temperature of the CMB more or less hot in a certain direction by its relative...
  11. I

    B Doubt about the relativity of simultaneity

    Observer B need not be surprised by the measurement data, he simply interprets it. I start from the postulate that the whole universe is just as old, from this it follows that the temperature of the CMB is the same everywhere at any given time. However, observer B sees that the temperature of...
  12. I

    B Doubt about the relativity of simultaneity

    Yes, observer B understands that both radio telescopes obtain the same result because from THEIR reference systems (radio telescope reference systems) they make the measurements at the same time. But that both radio telescopes get exactly the same result indicates that the universe was exactly...
  13. I

    B Doubt about the relativity of simultaneity

    (I hope my English is understood). Hello, I have a question regarding the relativity of simultaneity. The mean temperature of the cosmic microwave background tells us how big the universe is with respect to the recombination epoch. If I now measure that the mean temperature of the cosmic...
  14. I

    Spanish Scientist Interested in Physics: Joining the Forum

    Hello, I am a new member of the forum. I am Spanish, my English is very bad, I hope I can express myself clearly. I am not a physicist, I am simply interested in physics. Nice to be here with you. A greeting.
Back
Top