Recent content by Sambuco
-
Graduate Why is Bell’s theorem still considered controversial?
Do you have any reference for that last point? Lucas.- Sambuco
- Post #27
- Forum: Quantum Interpretations and Foundations
-
Graduate Why is Bell’s theorem still considered controversial?
Okay, I see. What would be different in QFT compared to the non-relativistic case? I’m referring to the many-worlds interpretation and the branch selection. As an aside, it often happens that one perceives interpretations other than one’s own preferred one as being too closely tied to classical...- Sambuco
- Post #18
- Forum: Quantum Interpretations and Foundations
-
Graduate Why is Bell’s theorem still considered controversial?
Does "wavefunction realism" imply a ##\psi##-ontic interpretation? In that case, there are interpretations consistent with this, such as many-worlds, but many people remain unsatisfied and, therefore, opt for other alternatives. Lucas.- Sambuco
- Post #16
- Forum: Quantum Interpretations and Foundations
-
Undergrad Gerard 't Hooft on the incompleteness of quantum mechanics
For those interested, there is a very recent paper (from two weeks ago) that analyzes how many derivations of the Born rule, which start from the other non-probabilistic postulates, require the introduction of additional postulates that, in one way or another, possess intrinsic probabilistic...- Sambuco
- Post #87
- Forum: Quantum Interpretations and Foundations
-
Undergrad Spatial separation of entangled particles implies physical separability?
I would go a bit further and say that this is, perhaps, the first no-go theorem, in the vein of many others that emerged later (Bell, Kochen-Specker, PBR, FR, “local friendliness”). Regarding Bohr’s response, I like this paper by Wiseman. Lucas.- Sambuco
- Post #46
- Forum: Quantum Interpretations and Foundations
-
Graduate How many interpretations of QM do you speak?
Beyond my response in post #179, I recalled that, instead of measuring the friend + system composite in a complementary basis, it is equivalent to first reverse the time evolution of the friend + system composite and then measure only the system (see section II.E in this paper). Does this help...- Sambuco
- Post #192
- Forum: Quantum Interpretations and Foundations
-
Graduate How many interpretations of QM do you speak?
From 3 a.m. to 6 a.m.: The best time to think about potential physical paradoxes! :smile: That is a valid point! From my perspective, it remains possible to analyze the thought experiment, much in the same way that we analyze how the erasure of the information stored by Maxwell’s demon is...- Sambuco
- Post #179
- Forum: Quantum Interpretations and Foundations
-
Graduate How many interpretations of QM do you speak?
Okay, now I think I understand your proposal. However, there is something I find problematic, so to speak. You argue that, since the friend's laboratory is screened off from the outside (the rest of the universe), the systems within the laboratory (including the friend) must be treated as...- Sambuco
- Post #177
- Forum: Quantum Interpretations and Foundations
-
Graduate How many interpretations of QM do you speak?
Okay, it's clear to me that your proposal/interpretation doesn't violate NSD or L. If you don't mind, I have another question regarding the gedanken version. In the paper, you say: "Technically, one would have to keep Wigner's friend and his entire lab from interacting with the universe, e.g...- Sambuco
- Post #167
- Forum: Quantum Interpretations and Foundations
-
Graduate How many interpretations of QM do you speak?
Immediately after the definition of NSD, the authors say: "In the EWFS, this implies that c and d are independent of the choices x and y: • NSD (in the EWFS and under Assumption 1): P(cd∣xy) = P(cd) ∀ c, d, x, y" which means there are no hidden variables involved in this scenario. As I...- Sambuco
- Post #165
- Forum: Quantum Interpretations and Foundations
-
Graduate How many interpretations of QM do you speak?
I think it is because, ultimately, it is not really an "interpretation," since it proposes that the evolution is non-unitary as a consequence of limitations in measuring time with real clocks. Lucas.- Sambuco
- Post #152
- Forum: Quantum Interpretations and Foundations
-
Graduate How many interpretations of QM do you speak?
In these extended Wigner's friend scenarios, that role is played by the outcomes of the measurements performed by the friends located inside the laboratories. This is stated explicitly in Bong's paper: "Within the definitions of L and NSD, c, d play the formal role of the hidden variables λ in...- Sambuco
- Post #151
- Forum: Quantum Interpretations and Foundations
-
Graduate How many interpretations of QM do you speak?
Absolutely! I agree that it isn't a groundbreaking paper, but I think it has some merit (I explain a bit more below). Since one has to start somewhere, the author adopts an initial stance based on certain "classical" intuitions and sees where that leads, and... ...upon observing that this...- Sambuco
- Post #149
- Forum: Quantum Interpretations and Foundations
-
Graduate How many interpretations of QM do you speak?
I read that in the paper and it caught my attention, given that the assumptions behind the LF theorem are mathematically less restrictive than those for Bell's theorem, i.e., there are situations where Bell's inequalities are violated but the LF inequalities are satisfied. Of course, I agree...- Sambuco
- Post #145
- Forum: Quantum Interpretations and Foundations
-
Graduate How many interpretations of QM do you speak?
Thanks again @RUTA for your reply! I read the paper, but I still can't fully grasp how your approach overcome the local friendliness (LF) no-go theorem. In your paper, you rightly point out that the theorem is based on four assumptions: absoluteness of observed events (AOE), locality (L), non...- Sambuco
- Post #140
- Forum: Quantum Interpretations and Foundations