Recent content by shalayka

  1. S

    Dark Matter Exists: Evidence from Colliding Clusters

    Perhaps it might be helpful to consider that a modification of Newtonian dynamics (MOND changes the very foundation of acceleration, which is very strange) is not the same as a modification of the source of acceleration (MOG, CDM, which are still strange in a sense, but less "fudgy"). MOND in...
  2. S

    Gravitational time dilation from two or four bodies

    Do you know of an approach that makes sense for calculating the gravitational time dilation experienced by a test particle at the centre of a shell (of radius r)? My common sense says that the gravitational time dilation would be identical to the situation where the shell was changed into a...
  3. S

    Gravitational time dilation from two or four bodies

    How would one go about calculating (as a first-order approximation) the gravitational time dilation generated by multiple point sources? When generated by one point source (M = 1\cdot10^{25}, r = 1, t = 1), I've got it down to: \tau = t \cdot \sqrt{1 - \frac{2GM}{rc^2}} \approx...
  4. S

    Distinguish Fictitious Force: Real Vs. Acceleration

    Perhaps it can be summed up by an analogy of travel in a car: Fictitious force - A driver inside of a car is traveling along a rectilinear path. The car turns left (accelerates, changes direction), but the driver's body attempts to continue along the rectilinear path due to inertia. The driver...
  5. S

    Questions about MTW Brick: Page 29, 101, 142

    Brick is a perfectly suitable analogy. It makes perfect sense in English. No worries.
  6. S

    Can String Theory Accurately Predict Quantum and Relativistic Phenomena?

    I was referring to the fact that arguing the pros/cons of string theory with this person is tantamount to talking to a brick wall. Sorry, I assumed most people prefer not to waste their breath. My bad. There's no need to get defensive on anyone's behalf. My question had nothing to do with...
  7. S

    More evidence for dark matter-another cluster collision

    I find it odd that you say this, considering that Moffat and Brownstein's theoretical work on modified gravity relies on observations exactly like those seen in the Bullet Cluster collision. Not that I necessarily agree with their model, but still... I don't think the statement is entirely accurate.
  8. S

    Can String Theory Accurately Predict Quantum and Relativistic Phenomena?

    You do realize who you're talking to, right?
  9. S

    How can people predict that the graviton is a particle of spin 2?

    http://motls.blogspot.com/2007/05/why-are-there-gravitons-in-string.html
  10. S

    Just a simple question about the speed of light and c^2.

    The metre is a fraction of the distance that light travels in one second. Now that wasn't so hard, was it?
  11. S

    Animation/visualization of galactic rotation rates (dark matter)

    While not video, the book Galactic Dynamics (2008) is very helpful. It shows how the spirals and whatnot form due to something that looks like traffic jams. It's pretty cool stuff.
  12. S

    Was Einstein's Pursuit of Unified Field Theory Fruitful in His Final Years?

    Perhaps it was because change is stress, and stress is something most people tend to avoid.
  13. S

    Was Einstein's Pursuit of Unified Field Theory Fruitful in His Final Years?

    Why don't you ask him yourself when you die? I'm kidding. I don't really know if it's practical to question the things that others spend their time on, let alone Albert Einstein. Why don't you spend some time contributing to lattice QCD? I'm sure you could make some good contributions.
  14. S

    Accelerating universe = conservation of energy?

    The \LambdaCDM model is something to look into. In it you will find that dark matter and luminous matter only make up about 1/4 of the required total energy needed to explain the apparent spatial flatness of the universe -- google for "angular size of microwave anisotropies". It's real science...
  15. S

    Does acceleration cause time dilation?

    Let me guess... you believe that a static axisymmetric body rotating on its axis of symmetry emits gravitational waves? If so, try spinning a disc under water and see how well the disc's edge pushes the water out of the way. Doesn't work quite as well as a spinning stick, does it? PhD? My God...
Back
Top