Riemann curvature of a metric defined with a coordinate basis

  • Level: Undergrad 
  • Thread starter Jianbing_Shao
  • Start date
47 replies · 2K views · last reply
pervect said:
For instance, I have some concern that the OP may be conflating vectors with ordered sets of numbers aka tuples. It is true that a tuple is one representation of a vector, but that doesn't make them the same thing.
Unfortunately, physics textbooks often conflate the components of an object with the object itself. E.g. calling ##p^\mu## the momentum 4-vector as well as the ##\mu## component of the momentum 4-vector. Sean Carroll does this with the object ##{e_\mu}^a##. He calls out that it is a matrix of components but then goes on to call it the tetrad/vielbein.

As quoted:
The components ##{e_\mu}^a## form an ##n\times n## invertible matrix. (In accord with our usual practice of blurring the distinction between objects and their components, we will refer to ##{e_\mu}^a## as the tetrad or vielbein, and often plural as "vielbeins."
 
romsofia said:
In a "natural" frame you get $$[\partial_a, \partial_b] = 0.$$

What you wrote is what relativists would say comes from a "moving" frame. I've seen it when we start from a "moving" coframe usually written something like ##\theta^i = a^i_j dx^j, d \theta^i = -\frac{1}{2} C^i_{jk} \theta^j \wedge \theta^k ##. These ##C^i_{jk}## are functions called structure coefficients, and it does take some work to get them into this form.

The duals to this + commutation we get ##[e_i, e_j] = C^{k}_{ij} e_k##. Which is like something you start with.
It is just the definition of a non-coordinate basis.
romsofia said:
In a "natural" frame, you can write the Riemann stuff as $$R_{\alpha\beta}{}^\lambda{}_\mu \equiv \frac{\partial}{\partial x^\alpha} \Gamma^\lambda_{\beta\mu} - \frac{\partial}{\partial x^\beta} \Gamma^\lambda_{\alpha\mu} + \Gamma^\lambda_{\alpha\rho} \Gamma^\rho_{\beta\mu} - \Gamma^\lambda_{\beta\rho} \Gamma^\rho_{\alpha\mu}$$

I've never used Carroll, so not sure about his conventions and all that, but the above notation comes from Choquet Bruhat's intro GR book, and the arbitrary frame formula is exercise I.9.1 if you are able to get access to it.
Thanks a lot, I have found this book, my problem have a close relation with exercise I.9.1. and using 'tetrad' ##e_a^I## we will arrive at a strange result.
My definition of connection:
$$\Gamma_{abc} = \frac{1}{2}(g_{ab,c} + g_{ac,b} - g_{bc,a} + c_{abc} + c_{acb} - c_{bca})$$
So ##{\Gamma^a}_{bc} = g^{ad} \Gamma_{dbc}## is just the connection ##\omega^\alpha_{\mu\beta} ## he difined, with this connection the covariant derivative of the metric is zero;
If we use relation ##g_{ab} = {e_a}^I {e_b}^J \eta_{IJ}## and ##{c_{ab}}^d = 2 {e^d}_J {{e_{[b}}^J}_{,a]}## , We can find that the connection ##{\Gamma^a}_{bc}## is:
$${\Gamma^a}_{bc} = {e^a}_I {{e_b}^I}_{,c}$$
Or we can express it in such a form:
$$\partial_c{{e_b}^I}={e_a}^I{\Gamma^a}_{bc}$$
Then we can calculate the curvature of this connection:
$${R^a}_{bcd} = 2 {e^a}_{I} {{e_b}^I}_{,e} {e^e}_J {{e_{[c}}^J}_{,d]} = -{\Gamma^a}_{be} {c_{cd}}^e$$
So we can draw such a conclusion:
For a coordinate basis ##e_a##, the metric ##g_{ab} = {e_a}^I {e_b}^J \eta_{IJ}## is non-degenerate, but the curvature correspond to it is zero. Is this result a little strange
 
Dale said:
Carroll, unfortunately, jumps back and forth between clear notation and unclear notation (as he admits). Since this is a point of confusion here, I would recommend using exclusively his clear notation. So (when he is being clear) he uses ##\hat e_{(a)}## to represent a tetrad (a set of four orthonormal vectors such that ##g(\hat e_{(a)}, \hat e_{(b)})=\eta_{ab}##). The tetrad ##\hat e_{(a)}## forms a non-coordinate basis, but can be expressed in terms of the coordinate basis ##\hat e_{(\mu)}## as $$\hat e_{(\mu)}=e^a_\mu \hat e_{(a)}$$ where ##e^a_\mu## are the components of the tetrad in the coordinate basis.

Note carefully the distinction. ##\hat e_{(a)}## is the tetrad, a set of four vectors forming a non-coordinate basis, and ##e^a_\mu## are the components of those vectors in the coordinate basis.
Yes ,you are right, I didn't distinguish the difference between the two。 ##\hat e_{(a)}## and ##e^a_\mu## are just some vectors and the components of these vectors.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: Dale
pervect said:
My $.02 and advice to the original poster. ##e_a = e_a{}^I \frac{\partial}{\partial x^I}## is not a coordinate basis, it's something more complicated.
Yes if we define such a basis, in most caese it can not be a coordinate basis if:
$${c_{ab}}^c e_c = [e_a, e_b]$$
$$
{c_{ab}}^c {e_c}^K \frac{\partial}{\partial x^K}
= {e_a}^I {{e_b}^J}_{,I} \frac{\partial}{\partial x^J}
+ {e_a}^I {e_b}^J \frac{\partial^2}{\partial x^I \partial x^J}
- {e_b}^I {{e_a}^J}_{,I} \frac{\partial}{\partial x^J}
- {e_b}^I {e_a}^J \frac{\partial^2}{\partial x^I \partial x^J}
$$
$${c_{ab}}^c {e_c}^J = 2 {e_{[a}}^I {{e_{b]}}^J}_{,I}$$
only when ##{c_{ab}}^c## is zero, then ##e_a## is a coordinate basis. In schutz's "A First Course in General Relativity"(5.5 Noncoordinate bases), He said only when ##e_a^I## must satisfy ‘integrability conditions’ then ##e_a## is coordinate basis.
 
PeterDonis said:
No. I already told you what your result actually means in post #10. It's not strange at all.
I just start from a arbitrary ##e_a^I##, there is no constrain on it, but according to your opnion, ##e_a^I## only can be ##\delta_a^I##, In fact, if you demand ##g_{ab}=\eta_{ab}##, ##e_a^I## also can be arbitrary element of group ##SO(1.3)## , but in my calculation the choose of ##e_a^I## is arbitrary.
 
Last edited:
Jianbing_Shao said:
I just start from a arbitrary ##e_a^I##, there is no constrain on it
Yes, there is. You assume that the basis you are defining is a tetrad basis, but then you also assume it's a coordinate basis. Those two things can only both be true of the same basis if spacetime is flat. That is what your math is showing. You are simply obfuscating this from yourself by using strange notation and failing to understand the implications of the various steps you are taking.
 
PeterDonis said:
Yes, there is. You assume that the basis you are defining is a tetrad basis, but then you also assume it's a coordinate basis.
Ok, I just suggest if we start from a arbitrary basis ##e_a##, so ##e_a^I## is arbitrary, from the definition of coordinate basis. it just means commutation coefficients ##{c_{ab}}^c## is not always zero. then we calculate the cuvature, it is not strange the curvature involve the term ##{c_{ab}}^c##, then I suggest if the basis is coordinate basis, then ##{c_{ab}}^c## is zero, we find the curvature is zero. This is my logic.
 
Jianbing_Shao said:
if we start from a arbitrary basis
A basis can't be arbitrary if it's a tetrad basis. Nor can it be arbitrary if it's a coordinate basis. Both of those conditions impose constraints on the basis; there are many possible choices of basis that do not satisfy either of those conditions. And if you impose both of those constraints on the same basis, you find that you can only do it if spacetime is flat.

Jianbing_Shao said:
This is my logic.
Yes, your logic is correct in that it shows that the statement I just made above is true. But I don't think you yourself fully understand the logic you are actually using. You are not using logic that applies to an "arbitrary" basis. It only applies to a basis that is both a tetrad basis and a coordinate basis, because you imposed both of those conditions.
 
PeterDonis said:
A basis can't be arbitrary if it's a tetrad basis. Nor can it be arbitrary if it's a coordinate basis.
From the discussion above, I just follow the notation in Carroll's book, He call ##e_a^I## a tetrad, and he didn't say it only can take values in ##SO(1,3)## group, So I think it can be chosen arbitrary. In fact in the calculation there is no need to put such a constrain on it.
 
Jianbing_Shao said:
From the discussion above, I just follow the notation in Carroll's book
Unfortunately, you don't. I pointed out to you how you don't follow his notation in posts #25 and #29 but you have not changed your faulty notation in any way. Nor have you followed Dale's advice to rewrite your equations to actually conform to Carroll's notation.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: Dale and PeterDonis
Matterwave said:
Unfortunately, you don't. I pointed out to you how you don't follow his notation in posts #25 and #29 but you have not changed your faulty notation in any way. Nor have you followed Dale's advice to rewrite your equations to actually conform to Carroll's notation.
Sorry, I just don't how to rewrite it, I seems that I have no right to do make some correction.
 
  • Sad
Likes   Reactions: Matterwave
Jianbing_Shao said:
he didn't say
What he did or didn't say is irrelevant. You said that you wanted the basis to be a tetrad basis, and you said you wanted to calculate the consequences if it's a coordinate basis. So you are the one imposing constraints on the basis, not Carroll.
 
PeterDonis said:
What he did or didn't say is irrelevant. You said that you wanted the basis to be a tetrad basis, and you said you wanted to calculate the consequences if it's a coordinate basis. So you are the one imposing constraints on the basis, not Carroll.
Sorry, I have repeated several times, ##e_a## can also be a non-coordinate basis, and ##e_a^I## is arbitrary, no matter how you would like to call it. and no constrain on it.
 
Jianbing_Shao said:
##e_a^I## is arbitrary, no matter how you would like to call it. and no constrain on it.
Then where does this relation come from?
Jianbing_Shao said:
If we use relation ##g_{ab} = {e_a}^I {e_b}^J \eta_{IJ}##
To make a really obvious counter-example, suppose we are in a Schwarzschild spacetime so ##g_{ab}## is the Schwarzschild metric and ##e_a^I=0## then it is clearly false.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: Matterwave
Jianbing_Shao said:
$$e_a = {e_a}^I \frac{\partial}{\partial x^I}$$
...
We can define the metric field:
$$g_{ab} = {e_a}^I {e_b}^J \eta_{IJ}$$

Maybe I will try one last time to get through. These two equations^^^ can't be simultaneously true (unless, as Peter has pointed out many times now, you're just in flat spacetime). If you define ##{e_a}^I## via the first equation, your second equation must be written:

Matterwave said:
Using your ##I,J## but Carroll's more consistent index spacing, to stay consistent with how you defined ##{e_a}^I## you would need to write:
$$g_{IJ}={e_I}^a {e_J}^b \eta_{ab}$$

You can not swap a matrix for its inverse and expect to get sensible results. Probably you also made other errors in the derivation as well, but at least fix this one first.
 
Last edited:
Jianbing_Shao said:
Sorry, I have repeated several times, ##e_a## can also be a non-coordinate basis, and ##e_a^I## is arbitrary, no matter how you would like to call it. and no constrain on it.
Sorry, but you presented math specifically assuming that ##e_a## was (a) a tetrad basis, and (b) a coordinate basis. Apparently you don't understand what you yourself have posted.

Thread closed for moderation.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: Matterwave
PeterDonis said:
you presented math specifically assuming that ##e_a## was (a) a tetrad basis, and (b) a coordinate basis.
For the record, here are examples of the math referred to (similar math was posted several times in the thread, I'm just picking examples from the latest post that has it). This...

Jianbing_Shao said:
If we use relation ##g_{ab} = {e_a}^I {e_b}^J \eta_{IJ}##
...defines a tetrad basis. And this...

Jianbing_Shao said:
For a coordinate basis ##e_a##, the metric ##g_{ab} = {e_a}^I {e_b}^J \eta_{IJ}## is non-degenerate, but the curvature correspond to it is zero.
...assumes a coordinate basis. In other words, this math shows that, as has already been posted, a tetrad basis can only be a coordinate basis in flat spacetime.

As might have been mentioned previously in this thread, Wald, Section 3.4, is a good brief reference for the tetrad formalism. The statement that a tetrad basis can only be a coordinate basis in flat spacetime occurs in the first paragraph of that section.

And with that, this thread will remain closed.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: berkeman, Dale and Matterwave