Kinteic Energies of particles hitting the walls of a container

I'm still trying to work out why this is, but as far as I can see, both of these calculations are assuming that all particles hit with the same force, which (I think) is incorrect.In summary, the average kinetic energy of all particles in a gas hitting the sides of a container is not equal to 3/2kT, but rather 2kT. This can be derived from the Maxwell-Boltzmann distribution and considering the force exerted by individual molecules on the wall during collisions.
  • #1
mmh37
59
0
I was wondering whether anyone was able to give me a hint on the following problem:

Is the average kinetic energy of all particles in a gas hitting the sides of a container less, equal or more than 3/2kT? And if it is not equal how can you calculate the mean kinetic energy?


I was thinking that since the flux and the pressure is the same everywherein the container, the kinteic energy should be the same as well. Thus the average KE is 3/2kT. I'm not really convinced by my argument here. But I can't really find a counter-argument (except maybe that the wall has 2D instead of 3D, but I'm not sure how and whether that would influence the flux or KE of the particles).

Thanks a lot for any hints and suggestions!
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
mmh37 said:
I was wondering whether anyone was able to give me a hint on the following problem:

Is the average kinetic energy of all particles in a gas hitting the sides of a container less, equal or more than 3/2kT? And if it is not equal how can you calculate the mean kinetic energy?

If the gas is ideal and the Kinetic Theory is applied, the answer is [itex]\frac{3}{2}kT[/itex]

I was thinking that since the flux and the pressure is the same everywherein the container, the kinteic energy should be the same as well. Thus the average KE is 3/2kT. I'm not really convinced by my argument here. But I can't really find a counter-argument (except maybe that the wall has 2D instead of 3D, but I'm not sure how and whether that would influence the flux or KE of the particles).

Thanks a lot for any hints and suggestions!

But how does that give you 1.5kT right away?? In fact, you need to calculate this from the standpoint of momentum transfer to the wall on collision. And the average kinetic energy is the mean kinetic energy. Average and mean imply the same thing.

Ideal gases under the Kinetic Theory model follow Maxwell-Boltzmann Statistics. If you know the distribution function of velocities, you can compute different parameters such as rms speed, most probable speed and average speed (its speed and not velocity). It is not correct that all molecules have the same velocity and the concentration of molecules is homogenous. In fact the number of molecules with a particular velocity is described by the distribution function.

The distribution function is given by

[tex]N(v)dv = 4 \Pi N_{0}(\frac{M}{2RT})^{\frac{3}{2}}e^{-\frac{Mv^2}{2RT}} dv[/tex]

here N(v)dv is the number of molecules with velocity v and [itex]N_{0}[/itex] is the total number of molecules in the container (M is the molar mass. If you use molecular mass m, then replace R by k, the Boltzmann constant).

You can actually derive expressions for pressure and average kinetic energy by purely classical considerations. Consider a molecule traveling in the +x direction just about to hit a well. It undergoes a perfectly elastic collision with the wall which reverses its velocity. Using the (linear) distance [itex]L[/itex] traveled by the molecule between 2 successive collisions, you can find the collision time [itex]t_{coll}[/itex]. It is simply

[tex]\frac{L}{v}[/tex]

Now you can find the force exerted by the molecule on the wall (and hence the force exerted by the wall on the molecule). Repeating the procedure for motion of another molecule along the y-axis and still another along the z-axis (or of an ensemble of particles with velocity components along all the 3 axes), you can get the expression for pressure (considering a cubical container helps). Most of this "derivation" can be found in any general physics textbook describing the Kinetic Theory of Gases.

Molecules hit the wall with random velocities. If the observation time is large then almost all kinds of molecules will hit the wall. By all kinds, I mean molecules with all possible velocities. In that case, the average kinetic energy of molecules striking the wall will be a good measure of the average kinetic energy of the gas itself.
 
Last edited:
  • #3
Hi,

I was searching for this question, and would just like to point out that the given answer is wrong - the probability distribution of molecules actually hitting the side of a container is proportional to v * the Maxwellian Distribution given above (as faster molecules will impact more often than slower ones).

The actual distribution function (for the velocity of molecules hitting) is:

(m^2/(2*k^2*T^2)) * v^3 * exp(-(m*v^2/(2*k*T)))

working out, this gives an actual average energy of 2kT, greater than the 1.5kT average of the entire gas.
 

1. What is kinetic energy and how does it relate to particles hitting the walls of a container?

Kinetic energy is the energy that an object possesses due to its motion. In the context of particles hitting the walls of a container, kinetic energy refers to the energy of the particles as they collide with the walls of the container. As the particles move, they possess kinetic energy, and when they hit the walls, they transfer this energy to the walls.

2. How does the speed of the particles affect the kinetic energy of particles hitting the walls of a container?

The kinetic energy of particles hitting the walls of a container is directly proportional to the speed of the particles. This means that as the speed of the particles increases, their kinetic energy also increases, and vice versa. This is because kinetic energy is calculated using the equation KE = 1/2mv^2, where m is the mass of the particle and v is its velocity.

3. What happens to the kinetic energy of particles when they collide with the walls of a container?

When particles collide with the walls of a container, their kinetic energy is transferred to the walls. This transfer of energy causes the walls to vibrate, which is known as thermal energy. The more particles collide with the walls, the more thermal energy is produced, resulting in an increase in the temperature of the container.

4. How does the temperature of the container affect the kinetic energy of particles hitting the walls?

The temperature of the container is directly related to the kinetic energy of particles hitting the walls. As the temperature of the container increases, the particles will have more kinetic energy and will collide with the walls with greater force. On the other hand, a decrease in temperature will result in a decrease in the kinetic energy of the particles and less forceful collisions with the walls.

5. Is there a maximum kinetic energy that particles can possess when hitting the walls of a container?

According to the laws of thermodynamics, there is no maximum limit to the kinetic energy that particles can possess when hitting the walls of a container. However, the average kinetic energy of particles at a given temperature can be calculated using the Boltzmann distribution. This distribution shows that the majority of particles will have a certain average kinetic energy at a given temperature, but there is a small probability that some particles may have significantly higher kinetic energy.

Similar threads

  • Advanced Physics Homework Help
Replies
4
Views
1K
Replies
1
Views
487
  • Advanced Physics Homework Help
Replies
13
Views
4K
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
3
Views
1K
  • Advanced Physics Homework Help
Replies
1
Views
1K
  • Advanced Physics Homework Help
Replies
1
Views
1K
  • Advanced Physics Homework Help
Replies
1
Views
2K
  • Advanced Physics Homework Help
Replies
2
Views
3K
  • Advanced Physics Homework Help
Replies
4
Views
2K
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
2
Views
1K
Back
Top