How to solve 2nd order d.e ? Is this the right start?

  • Thread starter Thread starter laura_a
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    2nd order
Click For Summary

Homework Help Overview

The discussion revolves around finding the general solution of the first-order differential equation y' = (y + y^2)/(x + x^2). Participants are exploring various methods and approaches to solve this equation, including integration and separation of variables.

Discussion Character

  • Exploratory, Mathematical reasoning, Problem interpretation

Approaches and Questions Raised

  • The original poster attempts to manipulate the equation by multiplying through by (x + x^2) and expresses confusion about obtaining a form suitable for integration. They also explore the possibility of separating variables but encounter difficulties with the resulting expressions.
  • Another participant suggests a separation of variables approach and provides a transformation of the equation, leading to a logarithmic form. However, they note that the original poster's request for "the right start" was not fully addressed.
  • Further discussion includes a participant questioning the classification of the equation as a second-order differential equation, clarifying that it is indeed first-order.
  • Another participant expresses frustration about isolating y in their derived expression and considers using the initial condition y(2) = 1 to find a specific solution.
  • Hints are offered to simplify the expression involving y, suggesting a potential path to isolate y more effectively.

Discussion Status

Contextual Notes

Participants are working under the constraints of a homework assignment, which may limit the methods they can use. The original poster is studying through correspondence and indicates a lack of familiarity with the material, which adds to the challenge of the discussion.

laura_a
Messages
64
Reaction score
0

Homework Statement


find the general solution of
y' = (y + y^2)/(x + x^2)




The Attempt at a Solution



I've tried a number of ways the first most obvious way I figured was to multiply the x+x^2 over so I did that but then when I expand I end up with a y' in both of the terms and I can't find any form of expression who's d/dx has two y' in it, because I believe it's impossible? Anyway, what I really want help with is, is there a trick to these, because this is my first look at them for many years and I just can't pick up what to do with them in order to put them in a position where you can intergrate and then solve...

My other idea for a solution was

y'(1+x) = [y(1+y)]/x

But then when I expand I still get y' on both of the LHS terms ... Is this a separable equation? I am studying this via correspondance so I've only learned as far as I've read tonight and I'm totally lost... any help will be greatly appreciated



***Extra

I've just tried one method from my textbook but it seems totally different to the first method I used of direct integration

ANyways I've got

(x+x^2)y' - (y + y^2) = 0
[(x^2)/2 + (x^3)/3]y' - [(y^2)/2 + (y^3)/3]y' = 0
y'(x^2/2 + x^3/3 - y^2/2 - y^3/3) = 0 (not sure if I can just do this or not, but it's worth a try)
so I ended up with a nicer looking eqn which was

1/6(3x^2 + 2x^3 - 3y^2 - 2y^3) = c

Clearly I have no idea what I'm doing, but I thought that was worth a shot... I still don't understand how it seems in the textbook you can just use that method instead of the other method where you have to set it up in terms of something that looks like the differential of something else and then integrate it...?
 
Last edited:
Physics news on Phys.org
y' = (y + y^2)/(x + x^2)

dy/(y + y^2)=dx/(x + x^2)
dy/y(y+1)=dx/x(x+1)

lets first see the right hand side
dy*(1/y-1/y+1)
dy/y-dy/(y+1)
integrating,
ln(y)-ln(y+1)+c1
ln(y/y+1)+c1

similarly on right hand side
ln(x/x+1)+c2
equating we get
ln(y(x+1)/x(y+1))=c
y(x+1)/x(y+1)=e^c

e^c as constant k
y(x+1)/x(y+1)=k
 
Hints are best!

vipulsilwal said:
y' = (y + y^2)/(x + x^2)

dy/(y + y^2)=dx/(x + x^2)
dy/y(y+1)=dx/x(x+1)

Hi vipulsilwal! :smile:

Very nice. :smile:

But the OP asked for "the right start", and you've given the whole answer.

Hint: If you'd stopped where I've quoted to, it would just have been a hint. :wink:
 
And that is NOT a "second order" differential equation.
 
I've been working on this question for ages now

And I have to find the solution for which y(2)=1
This is the last line of working out
\frac{y(x+1)}{x(y+1)} =k

The problem is, I've got an expression with x's and y's in it. In all of the examples in my textbook you always end up with y= something with x's and k's in it. But I can't solve that for y, I've tried and end up with a big mess. I assumed I need to use that fact that y(2)=1 and perhaps get simulataneous equations going? One of the problems I really have is that I don't know what y is so I can't find y(2)=1

Should I go back to

ln \frac{y}{y+1} + C_1 = ln \frac{x}{x+1} + C_2

I was thinking maybe I should split them up before taking the e of both sides

Can/SHould I do

ln(y) - ln(y+1) + C_1 = ln(x) - ln(x+1) +C_2

?

Thanks
 
Last edited:
laura_a said:
I've been working on this question for ages now

And I have to find the solution for which y(2)=1
This is the last line of working out
\frac{y(x+1)}{x(y+1)} =k

The problem is, I've got an expression with x's and y's in it. In all of the examples in my textbook you always end up with y= something with x's and k's in it. But I can't solve that for y, I've tried and end up with a big mess. I assumed I need to use that fact that y(2)=1 and perhaps get simulataneous equations going? One of the problems I really have is that I don't know what y is so I can't find y(2)=1

Hi laura! :smile:

Trick: just simplify the y bit, to get one y on its own:

(y+1)/y = 1 + 1/y.

So 1 + 1/y = (x + 1)/kx,

so k = … ? and y = … ? :smile:
 
ahh... thanks! Got it now
 

Similar threads

  • · Replies 12 ·
Replies
12
Views
2K
Replies
19
Views
3K
  • · Replies 40 ·
2
Replies
40
Views
5K
Replies
2
Views
2K
Replies
2
Views
1K
  • · Replies 2 ·
Replies
2
Views
2K
Replies
7
Views
2K
Replies
5
Views
2K
  • · Replies 11 ·
Replies
11
Views
3K