Discussion Overview
The discussion revolves around generating a 1A current at 11 MHz in a toroidal circuit, specifically focusing on the design and calculations related to inductance, voltage requirements, and the properties of the core material. Participants explore theoretical and practical aspects of this electrical engineering problem.
Discussion Character
- Technical explanation
- Mathematical reasoning
- Debate/contested
Main Points Raised
- One participant inquires about the appropriate device to generate a 1A current at 11 MHz in a toroidal circuit.
- Another participant notes that the voltage required depends on the number of turns, suggesting that with 35 turns, nearly 1000 volts would be needed at 11 MHz.
- There is a discussion about the terminology, clarifying that a "solenoid around a toroid" is simply referred to as a toroid.
- Participants debate the calculation of voltage based on the number of turns, with one suggesting it could be around 8 kV for 100 turns.
- There is skepticism regarding the purpose of the project, with one participant suggesting it may be related to "free energy," which is often viewed with suspicion in the forum.
- Participants discuss the formula for voltage in relation to inductance and current, with one providing the equation V = 2πfLI and questioning how to derive voltage from the inductance parameter A_L.
- Another participant raises concerns about the feasibility of using a solenoid at such a high frequency, questioning the practicality of mechanical actuation at 11 MHz.
- Discrepancies in values for permeability (μ) and the correct approach to calculating inductance are highlighted, with suggestions to use data sheet values instead of approximations.
- One participant presents a formula for energy in an inductor and discusses the complexities of AC current flow.
Areas of Agreement / Disagreement
There is no consensus on the calculations or the purpose of the project. Multiple competing views exist regarding the voltage requirements, the terminology used, and the feasibility of the proposed setup.
Contextual Notes
Participants express uncertainty about the correct values for core material properties and the implications of using different formulas for calculating voltage and inductance. There are unresolved questions about the practical application of the circuit design.