Absolute motion analysis of pulley-spring system

10 replies · 2K views · last reply
bremenfallturm
Messages
81
Reaction score
13
Homework Statement
A mass m is suspended from the ceiling using a light spring with constant k, and two light pulleys. The mass is also attached to the floor using a light dampener, with constant C. Determine: The period time assuming undampened motion. If C>0, motivate how the period will change.
Relevant Equations
Newtons 2nd law
$$\sum \vec F = m \vec a$$
Hello!
I have this problem from an old exam I'm trying to solve. The problem is in Swedish so I've translated it:
A mass m is suspended from the ceiling using a light spring with constant k, and two light pulleys. The mass is also attached to the floor using a light dampener, with constant C. Determine: The period time assuming undampened motion. If C>0, motivate how the period will change.
NOTE that I accidentaly wrote $$C\neq 1$$ in the picture below. The correct problem statement is above.
But that part is not what I have problems with. The answer key says "if the block moves a distance x, the upper pulley moves a distance 2x, and the spring moves a distance 4x" (no further elaboration given). I can not find the last thing, aka. how the spring moves a distance 4x, even though I imagine it's very easy to figure out.
I tried solving it like this:
Handwritten exam problem 3 with a hand-drawn diagram: a mass m hangs from a ceiling spring k via two pulleys, with a dampener C attached to the floor below.

Handwritten solution sketch: a datum line at top with pulley B hung from spring k, cable lengths s_A and s_B, a block m on a cable over pulley A, and a dashpot c. Notes give s_A + (s_A - s_B) = l_1, then 2v_A = v_B and 2a_A = a_B, and ask to relate spring elongation x to a_B.


Hand-drawn free-body diagrams of a pulley system: pulley A with mass m and dashpot C, pulley B on a spring k with displacement s_B, and FBD equations mg - 2S1 = ma_A and S1 - S2 = a_B.

Handwritten derivation: 4/2 m(a_A - g) - kx = a_A/2, then m(a_A - g) - kS_B = a_A, then kx = m(a_A - g) - a_A, then x = (1/k) m[a_A - g] - a_A, followed by the note 'this is overcomplicating for sure... need to find that the spring moves a direction 4x if the mass moves a direction x!'

Forgive me in advance if I used some mechanical terms or had some grammar errors in that solution, I'm not a native English speaker.

Thank you for any help!
 
bremenfallturm said:
But that part is not what I have problems with. The answer key says "if the block moves a distance x, the upper pulley moves a distance 2x, and the spring moves a distance 4x" (no further elaboration given).
Hi. Consider the left-pulley and the rope around it.

One end of this rope is fixed to the ceiling and the other end is attached to the (centre of the) right-pulley at point P.

Q1. If the left-pulley moves down a distance x, how far does P move?

Q2. You now know how far the right-pulley moves. Applying the same reasoning as for Q1, how much is the spring stretched?
 
Steve4Physics said:
Hi. Consider the left-pulley and the rope around it.

One end of this rope is fixed to the ceiling and the other end is attached to the (centre of the) right-pulley at point P.

Q1. If the left-pulley moves down a distance x, how far does P move?

Q2. You now know how far the right-pulley moves. Applying the same reasoning as for Q1, how much is the spring stretched?
Hi, I know that the right pulley moves a distance ##2x## when the left pulley moves a distance ##x##. I can come to that conclusion from the way the velocities are related, which I came up with in my solution.

I can't see how to apply the same method for the spring...
 
bremenfallturm said:
Hi, I know that the right pulley moves a distance ##2x## when the left pulley moves a distance ##x##. I can come to that conclusion from the way the velocities are related, which I came up with in my solution.

I can't see how to apply the same method for the spring...
Doesn’t pulley B have the same relationship to the spring that pulley A has to pulley B?
 
bremenfallturm said:
Hi, I know that the right pulley moves a distance ##2x## when the left pulley moves a distance ##x##.
Correct. But you are not being asked how far the right pulley moves.

Say the rope is attached to the spring at point Q (end of rope). The spring is stretched by an amount equal to the distance moved by Q. You need to find how far Q moves. This is not the same as the distance moved by the right-pulley.

You didn't answer my Post #2 questions!

Steve4Physics said:
Q1. If the left-pulley moves down a distance x, how far does P move?
and
Steve4Physics said:
Q2. You now know how far the right-pulley moves. Applying the same reasoning as for Q1, how much is the spring stretched?
 
Sorry!

Defining point ##A## and ##B## as in my solution above (##B \iff P## according to your definition), I get that
If the point ##A## is moved a distance ##x##, point ##B## moves a distance ##2x## since ##v_B=2v_A##

In my solution, I defined ##s_B## to be the distance to point ##B## from the set datum line. The length of the cord to that pulley is ##l_2 = 2s_B## and the change of ##s_B## is ##v_B=2v_A##, where I'm getting confused is that doesn't the spring get stretched out with the same distance ##s_B## too?
 
bremenfallturm said:
In my solution, I defined ##s_B## to be the distance to point ##B## from the set datum line. The length of the cord to that pulley is ##l_2 = 2s_B## and the change of ##s_B## is ##v_B=2v_A##, where I'm getting confused is that doesn't the spring get stretched out with the same distance ##s_B## too?
I think the problem is that you are working out ##s_B##, which is the position of pulley B. But that’s not what you need to work out!

Try this...

Each pulley has it’s own rope, one end of the rope is fixed to the ceiling, the other end is 'moveable'.

We need to consider the movement of:
- each pulley;
- the moveable end of each pulley’s rope.

If a pulley moves down some distance ##d##, the moveable end of its rope moves down a distance ##2d##. That's the key point.

If pulley A (left) moves down a distance ##d_A=x##, then the moveable end of its rope moves down a distance ##2d_A = 2x##.

Pulley B (right) is attached to the moveable end of A’s rope. Therefore pulley B must move down down a distance ##d_B=2x##.

***Therefore the movable end of B’s rope moves down a distance ##2d_B = 2(2x) = 4x##.***

Since the moveable end of B's rope is attached to the spring, the spring is stretched by an amount ##4x##.
 
bremenfallturm said:
where I'm getting confused is that doesn't the spring get stretched out with the same distance ##s_B## too?
Diagram of a pulley system hung from a ceiling: pulley B is attached by a spring labelled k to the ceiling, pulley A hangs below B, and a block labelled m hangs from pulley A, with the caption Original pulleys set up.


Two side-by-side diagrams of a pulley and spring system with an instantaneous lever model: two circular pulleys with levers marked r and r, a spring, and a hanging block labelled m, with the caption above reading Considering each pulley as an instantaneous lever.


Diagram of a two-lever mechanism inside a hatched wall frame, with a purple upper lever and blue lower lever. Labels show forces 0.25mg, 0.5mg and mg, and displacements 4d, 2d, 2d and d, with arm lengths r. Caption reads: mg(d) = 0.5mg(2d) = 0.25mg(4d).
 
Attachments
Last edited:
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: Steve4Physics and jbriggs444
Lnewqban said:
Nice idea to show what's going on! In the above attachment it might avoid possible confusion if:

- the centre of the left lever is shown moving a distance d (unmarked at present);

- the right end of the left lever is shown moving a distance 2d (marked as 'd' at present).
 
Steve4Physics said:
In the above attachment it might avoid possible confusion if:
Excellent catch, Steve!
Just corrected it.
Thank you very much.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: Steve4Physics
Hi! Thank you all so much for the help and intuition. What probably seems obvious and intuitive to you didn't do so to me. Additionally, my book didn't elaborate on how the rope and pulley distance change is related.
Many thanks for taking the effort to explain this using the concept of work and for making those clear pictures, they made me understand why this is the case.

Thank you a million times! I regret I found this forum now, where has it been the last 14 years or so I've spent stuyding? :P