Absolute speed of light conundrum

  • Thread starter Stanaz
  • Start date
  • #1
6
0

Main Question or Discussion Point

I would greatly appreiciate some insight into this question to allow me to beter understand the nature of relative simultainety.

A rocketship is traveling at v=.5c and passes a tree at the instant a lightning bolt strikes it.

Now some time later (in referance to the rocket) say the light wave from the lightning has propegated distance L. As the rocket is traveling at speed .5c will it be at a distance .5L???
This was my first intuitive answer but then i remembered that the speed of light is absolute regardless of which refereance frame you are in

Now if this is true does this mean that at some time later (time t) the light wave is C times t meters infront of the spaceship and infact an external observer would not observe the rocket passing the tree and the lightning strike to be simultaneous??? In fact they would see the lightning strike the tree before the rocket got to it??

This entire idea has got me perplexed just because i have so many different possibilities in my head and no intuitive instinct to base a true answer on.

Any input will be greatly appreiciated.
 

Answers and Replies

  • #2
365
11
From the rocket's point of view, it is standing still, and the tree went past it at 0.5c when the lightning went off. From the rocket's frame, the tree will be at 0.5L whenever the light pulse is at L.

From the tree's point of view, it is standing still, and the rocket went past it at 0.5c when the lightning went off. From the tree's frame, the rocket will be at 0.5L whenever the light pulse is at L.

Your next question has to do with what I believe to be the #1 most important realization that someone learning relativity must make. Even my relativity textbook does not hammer this point well enough. Making this realization helped me personally go on to learning the basics of relativity. The only place I have found this important piece of information was actually on the wikibooks.org site:

http://en.wikibooks.org/wiki/Special_Relativity/Introduction

There is sometimes a problem differentiating between the two different concepts "relativity of simultaneity" and "signal latency/delay." When simultaneous events in one frame are viewed as not simultaneous in another it is either because:

1. They truly aren't simultaneous in the second frame due to relativistic effects, or,
2. They just appear that way due to delay of light,

or both. They can occur together but the two effects are not the same thing. One can always factor out the light delay by calculating when the signal was transmitted using the speed of light and the distance to the object. Relativity isn't based solely on the finite speed of light, crazy stuff is really happening.
Put aside the effects of what you as an observer sees as a result of light taking a while to show you events. When we are calculating events in time and space we are calculating as they actually happen having already accounted for the effects of light's latency in showing us these events.

As the page above says, crazy stuff is really happening, even after you take into account the fact that you see events after they happen as a result of light's limited speed.
 
Last edited:
  • #3
6
0
Thank you i didn't really get into the thought of the stuff moving past the rocket that helps alot. But do you mean that the tree will be .5L behind the rocket and the Light a whole L infront of the rocket or the rocket will still be half way between the tree and the front of the light wave at all times??
 
  • #4
365
11
Thank you i didn't really get into the thought of the stuff moving past the rocket that helps alot. But do you mean that the tree will be .5L behind the rocket and the Light a whole L infront of the rocket or the rocket will still be half way between the tree and the front of the light wave at all times??
Well to the rocket, the light will travel in all directions (forming a sphere) and the tree will always be at half the radius of the sphere being formed by the light emanating from the rocket (to the rocket, the rocket is standing still and light is emanating from it at the same speed in all directions).

Also please note I was only talking about magnitude of distance in the preceding post, I assume you understand that the directions are of course opposite between the rocket and the tree.
 
Last edited:
  • #5
6
0
Thankyou for the help makes alot more sense now
 

Related Threads for: Absolute speed of light conundrum

  • Last Post
2
Replies
30
Views
4K
  • Last Post
Replies
10
Views
2K
  • Last Post
Replies
23
Views
11K
Replies
39
Views
14K
  • Last Post
2
Replies
31
Views
546
Replies
4
Views
3K
Replies
49
Views
5K
Replies
3
Views
2K
Top