- #1
PSuran
- 25
- 4
Hi everyone.
Firstly, I'm not a physicist, so relatively "intuitive" explanations would be greatly appreciated :)
I'm confused by the following:
Let's say we have a partition / wall, which resonates at a specific natural frequency. If the resonance is relatively high Q (low damping), then Transmissibility is much larger than "1" (LINK) . I read this as sound "amplification". But even if the partition resonance is Low Q, Transmissibility never goes below 1 (https://www.digikey.com/-/media/Images/Blogs/2018/December/Minimize%20Mechanical%20Vibrations%20with%20Highly%20Damped%20Elastomers/minimize-mechanical-vibrations-with-highly-damped-elastomers-img2.jpg?ts=82dc11df-6b94-444b-a9ea-eb8d140d0a80&la=en-US). I interpret this like so - At resonant frequency, the level (sound) will always be amplified (compared to no partition). NOTE: Ignore flanking sound, and other possible sound transmission paths. The above is a theoretical, free field vs. half space example.
But on the other hand, when building sound absorption devices, we use the same device - a resonating panel, optimally low Q (no ringing).
So my confusion is this - How can the same resonating system both amplify and absorb sound?
I'm certain I'm getting something wrong. I would really appreciate an answer, this is really bugging me :)
Firstly, I'm not a physicist, so relatively "intuitive" explanations would be greatly appreciated :)
I'm confused by the following:
Let's say we have a partition / wall, which resonates at a specific natural frequency. If the resonance is relatively high Q (low damping), then Transmissibility is much larger than "1" (LINK) . I read this as sound "amplification". But even if the partition resonance is Low Q, Transmissibility never goes below 1 (https://www.digikey.com/-/media/Images/Blogs/2018/December/Minimize%20Mechanical%20Vibrations%20with%20Highly%20Damped%20Elastomers/minimize-mechanical-vibrations-with-highly-damped-elastomers-img2.jpg?ts=82dc11df-6b94-444b-a9ea-eb8d140d0a80&la=en-US). I interpret this like so - At resonant frequency, the level (sound) will always be amplified (compared to no partition). NOTE: Ignore flanking sound, and other possible sound transmission paths. The above is a theoretical, free field vs. half space example.
But on the other hand, when building sound absorption devices, we use the same device - a resonating panel, optimally low Q (no ringing).
So my confusion is this - How can the same resonating system both amplify and absorb sound?
I'm certain I'm getting something wrong. I would really appreciate an answer, this is really bugging me :)